ArbNation Join free

Pruning in the first season after planting: what extension and ISA publish

Four publications cover pruning at planting. Iowa State and ISA keep it to defective, dead or broken wood, while the University of Florida sets a 25 percent foliage cap and allows leader work.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on four publications about pruning a newly planted tree. It is not training and does not teach the work. They are two Iowa State pages, an ISA brochure and a University of Florida paper. The brochure is the Pruning Young Trees leaflet of the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA), hosted by the City of Seattle. The paper is UF/IFAS publication ENH1022 by Edward F. Gilman.

Where the four publications agree

All four tie pruning to the leaves. Iowa State's FAQ explains that trees use sugars made by the foliage for growth, so severe pruning of a new tree cuts food production and slows growth. The ISA brochure says leaves and their supporting branches are major sites of food production and storage, and that removing too much canopy can "starve" the tree.

All four also keep the lower branches. Iowa State wants the small side branches left on the trunk because they thicken the trunk, shade it against sunscald and shield it from equipment, animals and vandals. The ISA brochure keeps some branches, at least for a while, to build trunk diameter. ENH1022 calls the branches on a young tree temporary, to be removed over the years.

Where they differ at planting

What each publication allows at planting
PublicationPruning at planting
Iowa State, Pruning Young Trees (reviewed May 2024)Research has shown faster growth and earlier establishment when pruning at planting is limited to weak, dead, diseased, rubbing or injured branches
Iowa State, FAQ on a newly planted tree (updated December 3, 2024)Corrective pruning only: double leaders and dead, broken or crossing branches
ISA brochure, hosted by the City of SeattleLimited to dead or broken branches. All other pruning is held back until the second or third year, when the tree has recovered from transplanting stress
UF/IFAS ENH1022, Gilman (reviewed 07/2025)No more than 25 percent of live foliage removed. Competing leaders and branches shortened or removed so one stem can lead. Broken, cracked or severely damaged branches removed

So the sources do not share one rule for the first season. Iowa State's page widens the list to rubbing and weak wood, its FAQ adds double leaders, and ISA names only dead or broken branches. ENH1022 goes furthest, treating the first pruning as the start of a 25-year training plan.

The 25 percent figures

ENH1022 prints a foliage cap for each visit. It is 25 percent at planting, 40 percent at two years, 35 percent at four years and 25 to 35 percent at eight years. Its list of strategies also asks for a live crown ratio above 60 percent and a dominant leader made by subordinating all but one codominant stem.

The ISA brochure uses a different figure for a different job. Its limit is no more than 25 percent of the crown in one pruning, given in the part on how many branches to remove from a tree being trained. The first-season rule in the same brochure is the narrower dead-or-broken one.

After the first year

Iowa State describes pruning after the tree is established, usually one year after planting, as training. It spreads that training over three to five years and says no more should come off in a year than the shape or strength needs. It aims for a single central leader and scaffold limbs on wide attachment angles, spaced 24 to 36 inches apart on alternating sides of the stem. The FAQ says the lower limbs come off gradually over the next 5 to 10 years.

The ISA brochure puts permanent branch spacing at about 3 percent of the tree's eventual height, which is 1.5 feet (0.5 m) on a tree that can reach 50 feet (15 m). It gives 8 feet (2.4 m) as clearance in most settings and up to 16 feet (5 m) on the road side of a street tree. For cuts, Iowa State puts them just outside the branch bark ridge and ISA just outside the branch collar.

For more on training in later years, see the guide to structural pruning of young trees, and for how age changes the work, the guide to pruning young trees by age.

Sources