ArbNation Join free

Pruning walnut and hickory: timing, sap and juglone in extension sheets

Purdue lists January to March as the dormant window for black walnut. The Arboricultural Association puts walnut in summer or mid winter. Wisconsin and Iowa differ on how long juglone lasts after a walnut comes out.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on what the named extension services and tree bodies publish. It is not training and does not teach the work. No opened source gives pruning advice for hickory itself. Hickory appears here only in the juglone material, as a tree that makes the same chemical in smaller amounts. The tree profile is in black walnut.

Walnut timing

Purdue University Extension's bulletin FNR-76, on corrective pruning of black walnut for timber form, gives the dormant season, January through March, as the best time. Sap may run from the wounds, and Purdue says this does not harm the tree. Some pruning may also be done in late June or early July to remove multiple stems, particularly after late spring frost damage.

The Arboricultural Association lists walnut as prone to bleeding, with poor tolerance of hard pruning. Its optimum time is summer or mid winter. Its text on when to prune adds that walnut, birch and maples lose sugars if cut in early spring, so those cuts are carried out when the risk is low, in summer or mid winter. The two bodies overlap on winter. Purdue says sap running from the wounds does not harm the tree, while the Association gives bleeding and the loss of sugars as the reason to avoid early spring. See bleeding sap after pruning for more.

Form and cut size on young walnut

Purdue's bulletin starts pruning one, or at the most two, growing seasons after the seedling is out-planted and continues annually until the desired log length is reached. Its main idea is a chosen leader: where there are multiple leaders, only the straightest and usually the tallest is left, and the competing ones are removed. Branches that gain over one inch in diameter are also taken off young trees.

For timber trees, Purdue gives a rule of thumb that no branch exceeds 1.5 to 2 inches in diameter before removal. It says pruning branches larger than 2 inches often leads to decay. It also warns that removing branches with no real reason cuts the leaf area and that young trees stripped of branches grow slender stems that suffer in wind. Cutting a poor seedling to the ground slows it: after ten years, trees cut at ground level had not caught up with those left uncut.

Juglone and what it does to nearby plants

The University of Wisconsin-Madison Division of Extension says black walnut makes juglone in amounts that cause wilting, yellowing and sometimes death in susceptible species. English walnut, pecan, shagbark hickory and bitternut hickory make it in relatively small amounts. Juglone is in the roots and also in leaves, nut hulls, bark and wood, in lower concentrations than in the roots. Wisconsin puts the toxic zone around a mature walnut, in most cases, within 50 to 60 feet of the trunk.

Wisconsin reports that black walnut wood chips are safe to use as mulch, because the wood does not break down to produce juglone. Leaves are safe after hot composting.

Iowa State University Extension also lists butternut and pecan as other juglone producers, with black walnut making the most. It adds that very little research shows juglone damaging plants near the root system, stump, leaf litter, fallen fruit or walnut mulch.

How long juglone lasts after removal

The two extension sources print different timelines. Iowa State says juglone is present in very small amounts in leaves, stems and wood and breaks down quickly in soil, so most of it is gone a few months after the tree is removed. It calls replanting in the next growing season safe. Wisconsin says cutting down a black walnut does not solve the problem immediately, because juglone can persist until the roots have decomposed, which can take five or more years.

QuestionSource and wording
Dormant pruning windowPurdue: January through March
Walnut, optimum timeArboricultural Association: summer or mid winter; prone to bleeding
Juglone after removalIowa State: mostly gone in a few months. Wisconsin: can persist five or more years
Hickory pruningNo opened source

Sources