Reading a tree bid tabulation: unit prices, estimated quantities, unbalanced bids and non-responsive columns
A bid tab prints each bidder's unit price against a quantity, and the line total is the two multiplied. FHWA guidance and FAR Part 14 describe unbalanced bids, price review, corrections and responsiveness.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The offices are the contracting offices named on each invitation for bids and the transportation agencies that run the lettings.
Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) Part 14, Sealed Bidding, is federal procurement regulation, and the NCDOT sheets below come from a state agency. The FAR shows how federal sealed bidding treats the same terms. The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) guideline on bid review is written for state transportation agencies, and it applies to traditional design-bid-build projects. It does not apply to design-build, construction manager/general contractor or indefinite delivery/indefinite quantity contracting.
The columns on a sheet
NCDOT Division 6 tabulation D6D2.SBE.005 is dated August 22, 2019 and covers Tree Removal, Stump Grinding & Overhang Clearing in Cumberland and Harnett counties. Six bidders print a unit cost and a total cost on each of 21 lines.
| Column | What it holds | Example on the 2019 sheet |
|---|---|---|
| Line | The item number | 4 |
| Sec # | A specification section number, or the letters SP | 1651 on the tree removal lines, 200 on the stump lines, SP on overhang clearing |
| Description | The work item and its size | 21 inch Dia. Tree Removal |
| Qnty and unit | The quantity printed for the line and its unit | 50 EA |
| Unit cost | One bidder's price per unit | Bidder A, US$210.00 |
| Total cost | Unit cost times quantity | US$10,500.00 |
| Total | The sum of that bidder's line totals | Bidder A, US$28,141.20 |
Clark County's sheets label the quantity column differently. Bid #2714 prints EST QTY. Invitation to Bid #2803 prints APPROX QTY PER YEAR, and its total for each line is the unit price times that approximate quantity.
The Clark County totals add sales tax. On bid #2714, Bidder A's sub-total of US$24,675.00 plus Washington State sales tax at 8.4 percent, US$2,072.70, gives a net total bid of US$26,747.70.
Quantity times unit price
On the 2019 NCDOT sheet, line 21, Mobilization, has a quantity of 40 each. The bidders' unit costs run from nothing to US$1,475.00, and each line total is the unit cost times 40.
| Bidder | Mobilization unit cost (40 each) | Line total |
|---|---|---|
| Bidder A | US$0.00 | US$0.00 |
| Bidder B | US$200.00 | US$8,000.00 |
| Bidder C | US$800.00 | US$32,000.00 |
| Bidder D | US$900.00 | US$36,000.00 |
| Bidder E | US$800.00 | US$32,000.00 |
| Bidder F | US$1,475.00 | US$59,000.00 |
The same sheet prices tree removal and stump grinding by diameter, from 6 inches to 52 inches, each with its own quantity.
A unit price and a market price
The FHWA guideline describes the engineer's estimate as the amount the agency considers fair and reasonable and is willing to pay for the work. One way to build it matches line-item quantities from the plans to historical unit bid prices, adjusted for project conditions and the general market, including the competitive bidding environment. Relying only on historical data may not be appropriate when the data comes from a non-competitive bidding environment.
FHWA calls it quite normal for different contractors to place costs such as overhead or expected profit in the unit cost of different items. Those costs normally go in items the contractor expects will not be eliminated or cut well below the quantity.
The 2019 NCDOT sheet shows how far apart one bidder's unit prices can sit. Bidder D prints US$1.00 on each of the nine stump grinding lines and US$900.00 on each of 40 mobilizations. Bidder A prints US$36.00 to US$320.00 on the stump lines and US$0.00 on mobilization. The sheet does not mark either bidder as unbalanced.
On the 2024 NCDOT sheet D6D3.SBE.016, Bladen and Columbus counties, the seven bidders' unit prices for overhang clearing, per linear foot with a quantity of 500, run from US$1.00 to US$12.00 for six bidders and US$845.00 for Bidder G. Bidder G's line total there is US$422,500.00, and its printed total bid is US$673,315.00. The other six totals run from US$79,400.00 to US$187,800.00.
Unbalanced bids
FHWA's main concern for the agency is that bids have not been materially unbalanced to take advantage of errors in the plans or specifications. Unbalancing can also occur on lump-sum and unit-priced items performed early in a project. A mathematically unbalanced bid can be hard to tell from a materially unbalanced one. Wisconsin DOT's process, which FHWA gives as an example, examines significant items that are mathematically unbalanced, meaning a set percentage over or under the engineer's estimated unit price. If quantity errors are found, the agency checks whether corrected quantities would change the bidder ranking, and a change in ranking indicates a materially unbalanced bid.
In the FAR, Part 14 lets a bid be rejected if the prices for any line items or subline items are materially unbalanced (14.404-2). The price analysis before award must consider whether bids are materially unbalanced (14.408-2). A bid can also be rejected if the contracting officer determines in writing that it is unreasonable as to price, and the FAR says that covers the prices of individual line items and the total price (14.404-2).
FHWA lists factors for bid review. They include the comparison against the engineer's estimate, the number of bids, the range of bids, the identity and location of bidders, and any unbalancing. Another is whether unit bid prices differ widely from the estimate or from other bids. The number of bids by itself does not indicate the degree of competition, and one factor may mean little in isolation.
Corrections and non-responsive columns
The 2019 NCDOT sheet marks two printed totals, Bidder B's US$50,550.00 and Bidder D's US$85,726.00, with a double asterisk and the note "Corrected Bid". The 2024 sheet prints "Corrected after Bid Review" in red, and three cells for Bidder D are also red: the line totals for lines 11 and 12 and the total bid. Neither sheet says what was corrected.
The FAR allows a clerical mistake that is apparent on the face of a bid to be corrected before award, after the contracting officer gets the bidder's verification of the bid intended. Its examples include an obvious misplacement of a decimal point and an obvious mistake in designation of unit (14.407-2).
The second column on Clark County's Invitation to Bid #2803 sheet prints US$0.00 on every line and Non - Responsive in the first total cell. FAR 14.301 says that to be considered for award, a bid must comply in all material respects with the invitation for bids.
Sources
- Federal Highway Administration, Guidelines on Preparing Engineer's Estimate, Bid Reviews and Evaluation, page updated October 12, 2021, read October 15, 2026
- Acquisition.gov, Federal Acquisition Regulation Part 14, Sealed Bidding, read October 15, 2026
- North Carolina Department of Transportation, Division 6 bid tabulation D6D2.SBE.005, August 2019, read October 15, 2026
- North Carolina Department of Transportation, Division 6 bid tabulation D6D3.SBE.016, August 2024, read October 15, 2026
- Clark County, Washington, bid 2714 tab sheet, on-call hazard tree removal, read October 15, 2026
- Clark County, Washington, invitation to bid 2803 tab sheet, on-call tree services, read October 15, 2026