ArbNation Join free

How public tree contracts are awarded: sealed bids, proposals and on-call contracts

Public agencies award tree work by sealed bid to the lowest responsive and responsible bidder, or by proposal when price is weighed against other factors. The federal Acquisition Regulation sets both routes, and the UK Procurement Act 2023 guidance covers the British equivalent.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The federal rules are in the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR), Parts 14 and 15, on the General Services Administration's acquisition.gov site.

Two routes to an award

The two federal routes, as the FAR describes them
ItemSealed bidding (FAR Part 14)Negotiation (FAR Part 15)
SolicitationInvitation for bidsRequest for proposals (FAR 15.203)
DiscussionsBids are evaluated without discussionsExchanges with offerors are allowed; award without discussions is possible if the solicitation says so
Award basisResponsible bidder whose conforming bid is most advantageous, considering only price and the price-related factors in the invitationThe proposal that is the best value to the Government, under the factors stated in the solicitation

Sealed bidding

FAR 14.101 lists five steps: an invitation that describes the requirement accurately and completely, public notice of it, sealed bids opened at the stated time and place, evaluation without discussions, and an award with reasonable promptness. The invitation may not carry unnecessarily restrictive specifications that would limit the number of bidders.

Bids must reach the designated office no later than the exact time set for opening (FAR 14.302). The bid opening officer opens them publicly and, if practical, reads them aloud and has them recorded (FAR 14.402-1). Any change to quantities, specifications or opening dates is an amendment sent to everyone who received the invitation (FAR 14.208). A change mentioned at a pre-bid conference does not replace an amendment.

Responsive

FAR 14.301 says a bid must comply in all material respects with the invitation, so that bidders stand on an equal footing. A bid that fails to conform to the invitation's key requirements is rejected under FAR 14.404-2. So is a bid where the bidder adds conditions that change the requirements or limit the bidder's liability. FAR 14.405 treats a minor informality, one of form and not substance, differently: the contracting officer either gives the bidder a chance to cure it or waives it.

Responsible

Responsive is about the paper. Responsible is about the firm. FAR 14.408-2 requires the contracting officer to find the prospective contractor responsible and the prices reasonable before award, with particular care when only a single bid is received. The price analysis looks at whether bids are materially unbalanced. FAR 14.404-1 holds that, once bids are opened, award goes to the responsible bidder with the lowest responsive bid unless there is a compelling reason to reject all bids and cancel.

Mistakes in bids

FAR 14.407-3 allows correction of a mistake alleged after opening only when clear and convincing evidence shows both the mistake and the bid actually intended. If the correction would displace a lower bid, the mistake and the intended bid must be ascertainable mostly from the invitation and the bid itself.

Proposals and best value

FAR Part 15 covers negotiated buying. FAR 15.101 calls the range of approaches the best value continuum. Where the requirement is well defined and performance risk is minimal, price may play a dominant role. The less definite the requirement, the more technical and past-performance factors can weigh.

  • Tradeoff process. FAR 15.101-1 allows an award to someone other than the lowest-priced offeror. The solicitation must state every factor that affects the award and its relative importance. The rationale for the tradeoff must be documented in the file.
  • Lowest price technically acceptable. FAR 15.101-2 awards to the lowest evaluated price among proposals that meet the acceptability standards set in the solicitation.

FAR 15.304 requires price or cost to be evaluated in every source selection, with a narrow exception for the Department of Defense, NASA and the Coast Guard. FAR 15.306 lets an agency award without discussions if the solicitation announced that intention. If the agency holds discussions anyway, it documents why.

On-call contracts

Much public tree work is bought as an indefinite-quantity contract. FAR 16.504 describes it as an indefinite quantity, within stated limits, of supplies or services during a fixed period, with the Government placing orders for individual requirements. The contract must require the Government to order at least a stated minimum, and the contractor to supply up to the stated maximum. The minimum must be more than nominal. FAR 16.504 also states a preference for multiple awards under one solicitation where practicable. The bid tabulations in public tree contract bids show this structure in unit prices and estimated quantities.

Protest windows

FAR 14.408-8 sends protests against a sealed-bid award to FAR Subpart 33.1. FAR 33.103 covers protests to the agency. A protest about an apparent impropriety in the solicitation is filed before bid opening or the closing date for proposals. In all other cases, FAR 33.103 sets 10 days after the basis of the protest is known or should have been known, whichever is earlier. The agency tries to resolve a protest within 35 days of filing. FAR 14.409-1 requires written notice to each unsuccessful bidder within three days after award.

The United Kingdom

The Cabinet Office publishes technical guidance on the Procurement Act 2023, arranged by four stages: plan, define, procure and manage. The titles in the procure stage include Assessing Competitive Tenders, Contract Award Notices and Standstill, and Remedies. The define stage lists Competitive Tendering Procedures, Frameworks and Below-Threshold Contracts. The guidance is written for procurement practitioners in contracting authorities, and a separate Welsh Government site covers devolved Welsh authorities. Contract notices appear on the Find a Tender service.

Sources