QTRA in outline: Registered Users, the Target-Tree-Tolerable structure and published thresholds
Quantified Tree Risk Assessment values the target first, then the tree's size and its probability of failure. A calculator turns the three into a risk of harm, set against advisory thresholds at 1 in 1,000, 1 in 10,000 and 1 in 1,000,000.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page draws on four pages from the QTRA website. It is not training and does not teach the work. Quantified Tree Risk Assessment (QTRA) was developed by Mike Ellison at Cheshire Woodlands. Its publisher says the method moves tree safety away from labelling trees safe or unsafe. It quantifies the risk of harm from tree failure so that owners can balance safety against tree values and work to predetermined limits of tolerable or acceptable risk.
The three components
QTRA's About page names the components as Target (the land use), Size and Probability of Failure. The target is assessed first. Valuing it first tells the owner and the assessor whether a survey or inspection of the trees is needed, and with what rigour. Where it is, the assessor then rates the tree's size and its probability of failure.
The ranges for the three go into a QTRA calculator, which gives a colour-coded risk of harm in traffic-light colours. The About page treats the result as the product of the probabilities of the three components. For a whole tree population, it says targets can be zoned in six target ranges, and that older trees beside high-value targets usually carry the greatest risk of harm.
Advisory risk thresholds
The About page prints a table of QTRA advisory risk thresholds, with boundaries at 1/1,000, 1/10,000 and 1/1,000,000. Its bands, descriptions and actions run as follows.
| Band | Description | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Unacceptable | Risks will not ordinarily be tolerated | Control the risk |
| Unacceptable (where imposed on others) | Risks will not ordinarily be tolerated | Control the risk; review the risk |
| Tolerable (by agreement) | Risks may be tolerated if those exposed to the risk accept it, or the tree has exceptional value | Control the risk unless there is broad stakeholder agreement to tolerate it, or the tree has exceptional value; review the risk |
| Tolerable (where imposed on others) | Risks are tolerable if ALARP | Assess costs and benefits of risk control; control the risk only where a significant benefit might be achieved at a reasonable cost; review the risk |
| Broadly acceptable | Risk is already ALARP | No action required; review the risk |
ALARP means as low as reasonably practicable. The publisher ties the thresholds to widely applied and internationally recognised levels of risk tolerance. The tolerability framework behind such levels is covered in the guide to tolerable risk of harm.
The Registered User programme
QTRA says that applied by untrained personnel, the system leads to misapplication. The Registered User programme exists to keep the system's value through consistent application and ongoing development. Registered Users have attended training in the principles of probabilistic tree safety management and the use of QTRA. The publisher reports that appraisals of the same tree by surveyors not trained to a common standard have produced variable results.
Registration is not restricted to arborists. QTRA is target led, and the programme says site management staff have an important role. It says an arborist can be as ill-placed to quantify the value of targets as a building surveyor is to assess the stability of trees. Registered User training gives no guidance on assessing tree stability.
The programme pages give two workshop lengths. One passage says Registered Users must attend a one-day workshop. Another describes a two-day workshop limited to 20 delegates. The home page refers to a one-day course.
Registered Users receive a User Manual, sample documents and a manual calculator, and access to a discussion list. They can download a registration key for a Windows calculator program and use the QTRA Calculator Web App, which runs on Windows desktop, iPhone and Android, with updates during the registration period. Users may choose to be listed in the QTRA Registered User Directory.