ArbNation Join free

Questions to ask a tree risk assessor before hiring: trade body and extension lists

The Arboricultural Association lists five questions for a contractor, from insurance to references. Mississippi State Extension and UF/IFAS add the TRAQ qualification for anyone who judges hazardous trees.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The Arboricultural Association, Mississippi State University Extension and UF/IFAS Extension in Hillsborough County each publish questions for people who hire a tree professional. The Arboricultural Association is the UK trade body, and its leaflet is written for tree owners getting quotes for tree work. The two extension pieces come from the United States and speak to tree evaluation and to removal. Other pages on this site list the trade-body question lists for arborists and what trade bodies say to look for when hiring.

The five questions in the Arboricultural Association leaflet

The Association's "Choosing your arborist" page puts its questions at step four of a six-step process. They can be asked before, during or after the site visit. It recommends three companies for quotes, and site visits are normally free.

QuestionWhat the Association prints beside it
Are you insured?A reputable contractor will be happy to show a copy. Cover should include Public Liability and, if there are employees, Employers' Liability. The Association recommends at least £5m for Public Liability
Are you qualified?Staff hold minimum qualifications for the work, most often chainsaw use and tree climbing, usually from NPTC or Lantra, shown by a plastic ID-style card or an A4 certificate
Do you work to a recognised standard?The answer will normally be the British Standard (BS 3998). Some contractors quote a European equivalent
Are you a member of a professional organisation?The Arboricultural Association and the International Society of Arboriculture are named. Individual membership does not cover standards of work, the leaflet adds
Can you provide the details of someone who could give a reference?Asked when the contractor was not recommended by someone the owner knows. Online reviews from earlier customers are also mentioned

What the quote should hold

Step five of the leaflet lists what a written quote carries. That is the specification, how arisings are handled, the height stumps are left at, who checks legal limits such as a Tree Preservation Order or a Conservation Area, and whether a deposit is asked. The leaflet adds that cheapest is not always best.

It also separates two schemes. The Association's Approved Contractor directory covers businesses assessed on health and safety, office procedures, worksite safety and work quality. Individuals may instead hold ISA certification, which the leaflet describes as an assessment of the person's knowledge. It notes that tree work is not directly regulated in the UK.

Qualifications named by the US extension services

Mississippi State Extension published its piece on November 5, 2025. The article says a company or individual should at a minimum be ISA certified, carry insurance and be bonded. A bond lets a client file for compensation if a job is unfinished or damage occurs. Butch Bailey, a forestry specialist, says ideally they hold the Tree Risk Assessment Qualification, TRAQ, but calls its absence "not a deal-breaker" where ISA certification is held.

UF/IFAS Extension in Hillsborough County, in a post dated October 2, 2024, lists its own questions for someone hired to trim, plant or diagnose trees.

  • Are they certified? The treesaregood.org site lets a name or certification number be checked.
  • What other qualifications do they hold? TRAQ is described as additional training in tree risk assessment, PPQ as the Prescription Pruning Qualification, an additional qualification in pruning, and BCMA as Board-Certified Master Arborist.
  • What work have they done on similar trees, and can they show photos?
  • What recommendations do they have for the health of the tree?
  • What professional development have they attended?
  • Do they have references?

The UF/IFAS post calls TRAQ essential for arborists asked to determine potential tree risk. Mississippi State treats it as a bonus on top of ISA certification. The two pieces differ on that point.

Sources