ArbNation Join free

Tree-care research papers: journal rules, Cochrane bias guidance and CONSORT

Arboriculture & Urban Forestry sets rules for how a study is described and reviewed. Cochrane and CONSORT publish what makes a trial result unreliable and what a trial report should contain.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Four bodies publish rules that bear on a tree-care paper: the journal that prints it, the Cochrane Handbook on bias, the CONSORT reporting guideline and the UK Research Integrity Office. Cochrane and CONSORT are written for health research, not for trees. Their definitions carry over; their examples do not.

What the journal requires of a paper

Arboriculture & Urban Forestry calls itself an international Open Access journal on the selection, establishment, culture, maintenance and function of individual trees, and on forests in and around human settlements. Its author guidelines fix the shape of a paper.

  • Article types. Original Articles carry a structured abstract with four headings: Background, Methods, Results and Conclusions, up to 250 words, and run to 8,000 words at most. Review Articles run to 10,000 words. Short Communications, up to 5,000 words, are the type for preliminary or novel results on limited data sets.
  • Methods. The Materials and Methods section describes the technical and experimental methods so that the work may be replicable. The statistical procedures used to analyze the data must be stated.
  • Discussion. The discussion compares and explains differences within the experiment and results contrary to earlier studies. Speculation must be founded in observation and related literature. The limitations of the study must be stated.
  • Funding and conflicts. Any interest that might be seen as influencing an author's objectivity is disclosed, financial or otherwise. A disclosed conflict does not bar publication, and it is printed alongside the article.

How a paper is reviewed

The Editor-in-Chief first assesses every submission. Papers outside the journal's scope are rejected without further review. A paper judged a good fit goes to an Associate Editor, who solicits at least two reviews from experts in the field.

The journal uses double-blind peer review. The Editorial Office hides author identities from reviewers and reviewer identities from authors. Reviewers disclose conflicts of interest and recuse themselves where needed. Misconduct allegations are investigated by the Editorial Office with the Editor-in-Chief, following the Committee on Publication Ethics core practices. Outcomes include rejection, a correction or a retraction.

A worked example of the reporting

A planting trial by Day and Harris in the same journal shows what stated design looks like on the page. Its abstract names 54 red maple and 54 littleleaf linden trees. Its methods name nine treatments and give the planting date, soil type, fertilizer rate and product, and the irrigation trigger.

The authors set out four objectives before the methods. They tested preplanned questions as linear contrasts, and their figures show standard errors for six replications. The paper closes by saying where its results may not hold. The same trial is set out in the page on fertilizing trees at planting.

Bias in the Cochrane Handbook

Chapter 7 of the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions, version 6.5, defines bias as a systematic error, or deviation from the truth, in results. Bias can lead to under-estimation or over-estimation of an effect. Some bias is small; some is large enough that an apparent finding is due entirely to it.

The chapter separates three ideas that are easy to blur:

  • Bias is systematic error. Repeating the same flawed study many times would reach the wrong answer on average.
  • Imprecision is random error. Repeating the study would give different estimates because of sampling variation, but the right answer on average. Smaller studies are subject to greater sampling variation and so are less precise.
  • External validity is how far a result carries to other populations and settings. A study of an unrepresentative group may not generalize without being biased for the group it studied.

Cochrane's risk-of-bias tool, first released in 2008, asked about seven domains: random sequence generation, allocation sequence concealment, blinding of participants and personnel, blinding of outcome assessment, incomplete outcome data, selective outcome reporting and other sources of bias. Its successor, RoB 2, should be used for all randomized trials in Cochrane reviews.

The chapter says it is usually impossible to know how far bias has affected a particular study. It therefore asks whether a result is at risk of bias, not whether it is biased. It reports that over-estimation from missing blinding is larger when the outcome is subjectively measured than when it is objective.

It also describes non-reporting bias, where the choice to publish or report a result depends on its direction. Published trials tend to show larger effects than trials disseminated elsewhere. Small and single-centre studies may be published more readily when they show larger, statistically significant effects. The chapter adds that source of funding and authors' conflicts of interest bear on both bias in a study and bias in a synthesis.

CONSORT 2025

The EQUATOR Network lists the CONSORT 2025 statement as the updated guideline for reporting randomised trials, with a checklist. It was published simultaneously in five journals in 2025: BMJ, JAMA, The Lancet, Nature Medicine and PLoS Medicine. An explanation and elaboration paper appeared in BMJ.

EQUATOR also lists extensions of the guideline, among them cluster randomised trials, harms, non-inferiority trials, abstracts and non-pharmacological treatments. CONSORT 2010 has translations in 12 languages. The guideline covers randomised trials.

UKRIO resources

The UK Research Integrity Office publishes a Code of Practice for Research, a Checklist for Researchers, case study packs, an Authorship Integrity Toolkit and a Concordat self-assessment tool. Its resource list is sorted by topic: good practice and governance, research misconduct, ethics in human and animal research, publication ethics including authorship, research culture, and equality, equity, diversity and inclusion.

Sources