ArbNation Join free

Resistance drilling: what a resistograph measures and what journals report about it

A resistograph pushes a thin needle into wood at a constant feed and plots the drag. Two journal papers, a U.S. Forest Service report and one maker's page describe what the trace shows and where it falls short.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Drill resistance measurement in trees is described here as the named journals, the Forest Service report and the maker publish it. It is not training and does not teach the work. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one.

How the trace is made

A 2010 review in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry by Johnstone, Moore, Tausz and Nicolas puts constant feed drills among the moderately invasive decay detectors. The drill controls and measures the feed rate of the bit and maps the result electronically or on a graph. A resistograph records drilling resistance on a strip chart or electronic recorder as the bit goes in at a constant drive. The height of the trace shows resistance, and decay in the path of the bit shows as a fall. The needle tip is 3 mm wide, and the depth of drive is 300 to 1500 mm. The review also names a simpler method, a portable drill whose operator senses the change in resistance and reads the shavings.

Accuracy in the field studies

Costello and Quarles tested the device in the Journal of Arboriculture in 1999. They drilled 16 Tasmanian blue gum and 5 Scotch elm, then cut and sectioned the trees along the drill paths and measured wood density. The resistograph agreed closely with density on soundwood depth in 85.5% of blue gum cases and 100% of elm cases. The portable drill agreed in 73% and 81%. Drill results varied considerably between operators.

The same paper reports limits. The resistograph did not detect early to intermediate decay, below about 20% weight loss, though it found decay above that. About 15% of its blue gum readings deviated from density by more than 6 cm, and some were false negatives. Soundwood profiles differ among species, so the authors want the profile of the test species known before decay assessments are made. Both methods need interpretation of the trace, and the authors conclude that soundwood assessments are only as good as that interpretation.

The 2010 review adds a second test. Johnstone and colleagues paired the drill data with a decay compartmentalization model in blue gum. A linear regression found that the predicted area of decay explained 76% of the variation in the readings.

Holes left in the wood

The review sets out findings that disagree. Kersten and Schwarze found that shavings left in the hole give decay fungi a substrate. Toussaint and colleagues found more decay along needle paths in linden. Helliwell found staining and discoloration around 6 mm and 10 mm holes two years later. Weber and Mattheck argued that constant feed drills do not cause long-term decay, because the tree forms compartmentalization reaction zones after 8 to 10 years.

Drilling after sonic screening

Decay tests on 10 red pines that supported a ropes course in Michigan in September 2006 are in a U.S. Forest Service report by Allison, Wang and Ross. The team screened by visual assessment and a single-path stress wave test, then used two tomographs, then drilled the three suspect trees with a resistograph to a depth of 40 cm. Tomography and drilling both confirmed trunk decay in those trees. The report states that precise quantification of decay location and size is beyond these tools. Combined, tomography and drilling allow an estimate of the approximate area of decay and the average intact trunk shell in the sections tested. It also cites thresholds for critical risk of failure: more than 40 percent of cross-sectional area decayed, assuming no cavity opening, and a remaining shell under 15 percent of trunk diameter.

Makers' declared figures

Rinntech lists the figures below on its Resistograph page. The maker names street, park and forest trees as uses, with detection of decay, cavities and cracks, and also lists poles and playground equipment. The 650 series figures come from one properties list that covers both models.

Rinntech Resistograph models as the maker declares them
ModelDrilling depthSpeedResolution
650-EA50 cmUp to 300 cm/min1/50 mm
650-SC50 cmUp to 300 cm/min1/100 mm
4303-P30 cmUp to 40 cm/min1/10 mm
4453-P45 cmUp to 40 cm/min1/10 mm
4453-S45 cmUp to 40 cm/min1/100 mm
4452-S45 cmUp to 30 cm/min1/100 mm

The maker lists the 4303-P, 4453-P, 4453-S and 4452-S as previous models. It adds that versions with up to 100 cm drilling depth are available on request.

Sources