Rigging ring as the primary rigging point: what the ISA book and makers' manuals say
A 2022 Tree Care Industry Magazine report on one green ash found stationary rigging rings cut stem strain by about a third against a rotating block, with no matching drop in lead rope load.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The named codes and training bodies are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.
The terms the sources use
| Term | Wording in the source |
|---|---|
| Rigging point | The 2009 paper: where the lowering rope is anchored to the tree. When it sits below the piece being removed, it is a block attached to the tree by a sling, with the rope run through the block and tied to the piece. |
| Negative rigging | The 2021 magazine article: top-down or dynamic rigging where the rigging point is below the material being controlled. The article calls it the least desirable method in terms of free fall, and often key to tree removal. |
| Positive rigging | The same article: static rigging where the pulley is above the rigging point and the system is pre-loaded, usually by the ground crew, to reduce dynamic force. |
| Rigging rings and thimbles | The 2022 report: fixed devices meant to hold a consistent friction point, which in theory would reduce the magnification of forces that a rotating sheave produces. |
The 2022 test
Matt Follett and co-authors, in Tree Care Industry Magazine, compared four anchor devices on an 18-inch (45 cm) green ash. One was a rotating block and three were stationary devices. The rigged piece weighed 425 pounds (93 kg) and was notched 24 feet 7 inches (7.5 m) above ground. A ramp and cart stood in for the ground person letting the rope run. Each device had three drops, with the piece craned back up between drops.
The authors report that the load at the friction device with the stationary devices was routinely about half the load with the block. Peak stem strain fell by about one third. Combining the friction device reading with an accelerometer on the falling piece gave an approximate load at the upper anchor, and that fell too.
The tension in the lead section of the rope did not fall in the same way. One stationary device showed no significant difference from the block. The authors explain it as unchanged potential energy: only a longer time to slow the piece reduces peak load there. They note the figure is a running-rope, best case result. They also write that climbers feel the reduced stem and anchor load but not the load on the rope, and may be inclined to take a larger piece than the lead rope and its attachment can bear.
What earlier tests found
The 2022 report cites Kane (2019) as finding little difference between rings and a block for peak loads, in a test where the load dropped into the system from above and stopped abruptly. The report calls that the worst-case scenario and says more work was needed under running-rope conditions.
The 2009 paper by Kane, Brena and Autio measured a block, not a ring. It reports that force at the block was more than double the rope tension, and that friction in the block added about 20 percent to twice the tension. For the block, the 2022 report says the anchor sees roughly twice the falling load because force on one side is matched on the other.
Where the sources do not agree or do not reach
- The 2022 report finds a reduction in stem strain of about a third. The 2019 drop test it cites found little difference in peak loads. The two tests loaded the system differently: abrupt stop against running rope.
- The 2021 article advises attaching the block as close to the tree as possible, especially in negative rigging, and does not mention rings.
- The ISA store lists The Art and Science of Practical Rigging as a DVD and workbook set. The store page carries no text from the set.
Related pages are blocks and pulleys and forces in rigging.
Sources
- Follett, Lecigne, Detter, Gocke and Messier, Testing Equipment and Techniques to Reduce Loads on the Stem, Tree Care Industry Magazine, July 1, 2022, read October 19, 2026
- Kane, Brena and Autio, Forces and Stresses Generated During Rigging Operations, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 35(2), March 2009, read October 19, 2026
- McCombs and O'Shea, Exploring the Principles of Rigging, Tree Care Industry Magazine, July 1, 2021, read October 19, 2026
- International Society of Arboriculture, webstore product listing, read October 19, 2026