ArbNation Join free

Rock mulch, landscape fabric and rubber mulch around trees: what extension says

Washington State, Arizona and Nevada extension publications agree that rock mulch holds heat. They split on landscape fabric under rock, and only the Washington State guide discusses rubber mulch at length.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Three university extension publications cover mulch that is not wood or bark. Washington State University (WSU) Spokane County Extension wrote C075, Guide to Mulches (revised 2023). University of Arizona Cooperative Extension, Yavapai County, wrote Backyard Gardener #30 (June 25, 2022). The University of Nevada, Reno wrote Special Publication 06-10, Mulches for Nevada Landscapes. None is about trees alone, and none is a rule. Wood mulch depth and trunk gaps have their own page in the guide to mulch depth and volcano mulching.

Rock and gravel

WSU calls rock and gravel permanent installations, best used around foundation plants. The drawback is heat: most rocks reflect solar radiation and can make a very hot landscape in summer. Crushed rock and lava rock look manicured, resist compaction and cannot blow away. Debris builds up on top, though, and lets weed seeds germinate, and weeds are hard to pull out of rock.

Arizona says rock and gravel collect heat, which raises cooling costs for the house and irrigation costs for the landscape in summer. Weed seeds blow into stone and establish, even over fabric. Rock is still widely used for its persistence, easy upkeep and clean look.

Nevada finds that rock mulches raise the temperature of both the soil and the surrounding air. Inorganic mulches give no nutrients and do not build soil structure. Water-conserving desert landscapes often rely on rock, while plants from outside the desert gain little from it and suit organic mulch better because it keeps soils cooler.

Landscape fabric under rock or wood

Landscape fabric in the three publications
PublicationOn landscape fabric
WSU C075Usually not recommended for home use. Woven weed barrier lets a little air and water through at first, then clogs and causes the same problems as black plastic. Weeds germinate on top and root through it. Fabric and plastic disrupt the life cycles of many pollinators and soil invertebrates. Black plastic or weed fabric under rock is a measure WSU does not recommend
Arizona BYG #30Usually used as a base under bark, chips or gravel. Soil blows in and weeds often grow on top after a few years. The author recommends forgoing fabric on residential landscapes
Nevada SP 06-10For best weed control in desert rock mulch, it is advisable to put landscape fabric, not sheet plastic, on the soil first. A layer of fabric under 2 inches of rock is sufficient. Fabric is rarely used alone, and under a permanent mulch it counts as permanent

The sources disagree. WSU and Arizona describe fabric as a problem over time. Nevada treats it as part of a rock mulch for dry ground, and adds that mixing organic and inorganic mulch in one bed does not give the best protection.

Rubber mulch and shredded tires

Only WSU treats rubber mulch at length. It classes shredded tires and rubber mats as synthetic, since they hold more than 60 percent synthetic rubber made from petroleum-derived hydrocarbons. Once ignited they burn extremely hot and are hard to extinguish, so WSU says they should never be applied in areas at risk of wildfire. Recent research also links the tire chemical 6PPD-quinone to harmful aquatic pollution, especially for Coho salmon.

Nevada lists shredded rubber among inorganic mulches. Arizona does not name rubber mulch.

Plastic sheeting

WSU does not recommend black plastic in home landscapes: it is impermeable, cuts water and oxygen to roots and soil life, and breaks into small pieces in sunlight. Arizona advises against black plastic under other mulches because it keeps water and oxygen out of the soil. Nevada rarely recommends plastic mulch, because it tears easily and is usually removed and thrown out at the end of the season.

Organic mulch near the trunk

All three set organic mulch against the rock options. Nevada puts organic mulch three to four inches thick, with six inches between mulch and trunk to limit disease, insects and vertebrate pests. WSU spreads it 6 inches from the trunk out to the drip line if possible, and warns that a volcano against the trunk invites insect and rodent damage. Arizona puts organic layers at 2 to 3 inches thick at least.

Sources