ArbNation Join free

Root collar excavation: why it is done, how deep roots are buried and what crews find

Ohio DNR, NC State Extension, Iowa State and TCI Magazine describe digging down to the root flare of a buried tree. A survey of 302 street trees found transport roots under 1 to 11 inches of soil.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on four published sources about locating a buried root flare. It is not training and does not teach the work. Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) published an article reprinted from The Buckeye in January 2003. The others are a North Carolina Cooperative Extension plant health alert, an Iowa State University Extension answer on planting depth, and a TCI Magazine report on a job in Rhode Island.

The root collar and the flare

ODNR defines the root collar as the part of a plant where the stem and root system meet. The flare is where it changes from stem wood to roots. Four to eleven large transport roots radiate from it and carry water and minerals. Iowa State calls the trunk flare the natural widening at the base of the trunk where it passes into the root system, and puts the proper planting depth where the flare is level with or slightly higher than the grade.

ODNR also notes that roots need oxygen. It gives 25 percent of soil volume as good for root growth, 5 percent as the level where growth stops, and 2 percent as the level where roots decline and die.

How deep is buried

ODNR cites University of Minnesota research that as little as one inch of soil over the flare can hide stem-girdling roots until it is too late. In sugar maple, significant decline in health began at four inches of soil. A survey of 302 street trees found buried roots "alarmingly common": the transport roots of every studied species lay under 1 to 11 inches of soil, and condition fell as soil depth rose. Minneapolis rejected some trees with 16 inches of soil over the flare.

NC State's extension agent found root collars buried 6 to 12 inches on the trees pictured in his alert. Iowa State notes the flare is sometimes buried by soil during spring potting, at times by an inch or more.

How the burial happens

ODNR names two nursery causes: hilling soil up around the trunk for weed control, and setting liners as deep as 12 inches in the beds. It adds that planting the soil line level with the site's soil line can still bury the roots if the ball carries excess soil. Digging the hole too deep and not firming the backfill lets a tree settle. Volcano mulching adds to the problem, and ODNR says heat from composting mulch can cook a trunk.

NC State adds that girdling roots follow planting too deep, or planting a tree still in burlap and basket, and that years of heavy mulch do the same. Maples are named as notorious for girdling roots.

Signs of burial

ODNR looks for a trunk that goes into the ground like a pole instead of flaring, and for a tree that pushes soil aside when rocked. NC State lists a flattened trunk, dying limbs on one side and dead areas of bark on the lower stem. It also treats lichens on stems as a sign the tree has not grown well in recent years, since bark shed by growth keeps lichens off.

Iowa State warns that deep planting can kill trees within months or lead to chronic problems, chiefly stem-girdling roots. ODNR lists slow growth, atypical leaf size and colour, disease susceptibility and poor cold hardiness, and says the problem usually takes several years to show.

What the excavation involves

ODNR finds digging is often needed to find the flare. It names plastic hand tools for small jobs and the Air Spade, which uses high-pressure air to remove soil without damaging roots. NC State describes raking out mulch, excavating the root collar so it is exposed to the air, keeping mulch to no more than 2 to 3 inches, and removing soil back to the original grade as far as possible. It adds that aerating around the roots with an air spade or auger, organic matter and low-nitrogen fertilizer can help.

TCI Magazine followed a crew at a Bradford pear that had been hit by mulch mounding. They used a pneumatic air tool fed by a compressor at about 300 psi, with the nozzle output at about 3,000 psi, which the article says moves soil particles but does not damage roots. The crew worked in a wagon-wheel pattern and exposed the roots from the trunk out to about 3 feet. The aim was to find girdling roots. They finished with 2 to 3 inches of composted woodchip mulch, kept off the base of the tree.

TCI Magazine adds that soil excavation can encourage fibrous roots to grow outward toward the dripline instead of circling near the trunk. It also says air-tool work eases compacted soil by opening pore space. The crew wore coveralls, gloves, head, eye, face and hearing protection, which the article ties to ANSI Z133.

Results reported

NC State shows a Chinese elm that was not growing, then a sound tree years after excavation, and says a girdling root found on a paperbark maple had cut off water to the upper stem. A case study of zelkovas on 5th Avenue compares one excavated tree with its untreated neighbours. Several years later the excavated tree had more branches and faster trunk growth. These are case reports, not trials.

Planting depth at installation is on its own page in the guide to planting depth and root flare.

Sources