Rope and ascender research in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry: what each paper tested
Arboriculture & Urban Forestry has published drop tests on toothed ascenders, breaking-load tests on rigging hitches and ropes, and force measurements on rigging and on the tie-in point. Each paper's question, method and result is below.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Brian Kane is the author or lead author of every paper in the table below. The International Society of Arboriculture published them in its journal Arboriculture & Urban Forestry (AUF). The journal's rigging and climbing keyword pages list the papers.
What each paper tested
| Paper and question | Method | Headline result |
|---|---|---|
| Kane, Brena and Autio, Forces and Stresses Generated During Rigging Operations, 35(2), March 2009, pages 68 to 74. Question: What forces and stresses do rigging operations produce, and which variables predict them? | Thirteen red pines (Pinus resinosa) were removed with conventional techniques. Forces at the block and in the rope were measured on the top and four later pieces, and trunk stress was calculated from strain readings. | Mass of the piece was the best predictor of force at the block and tension in the rope. Fall distance, fall ratio and notch angle and depth were less important and showed counter-intuitive relationships. Trunk stress differed little between tops and pieces. |
| Kane, Compatibility of Toothed Ascenders with Arborist Climbing Ropes, 37(4), July 2011, pages 180 to 185. Question: Are common toothed ascenders compatible with arborist climbing ropes in a fall? | Ascenders were drop-tested on four arborist climbing ropes and a static rescue rope, in March and April 2010, in a red oak about 12 m up. The method followed the EN 12841-2006 test for Type B rope grabs, with changes, using an 86 kg mass. | Of 67 tests, the arrest distance met the standard's limit of 2 m only 10 times. Impact loads averaged more than 5 kN, and a backup friction hitch above the ascender raised them to more than 6 kN. |
| Kane, Breaking Load of Hitches and Ropes Used in Rigging, 38(1), January 2012, pages 1 to 5. Question: How strong are the hitches arborists tie in slings and rigging ropes, and does the rope matter more than the hitch? | Four hitches (clove, cow, running bowline and timber) were tied around a utility pole on seven rigging ropes and loaded gradually until they broke. | Breaking load was similar across hitches and varied widely across ropes. The spread between ropes was 16.6 kN, against 1.45 kN between hitches. Rope type explained 88 percent of the variance in breaking load. |
| Kane and Arwade, The Effect of Climbing Line and Ascent Technique on the Magnitude and Frequency of Arboricultural Climbing Loads, 48(6), November 2022, pages 309 to 318. Question: Does the choice of climbing line change the load on the tie-in point while a climber ascends? | The lead author ascended to three tie-in points in different trees, using two ascent techniques and three climbing lines, while loads were measured at the tie-in point. | Loading ran between 1.1 and 1.5 times the lead author's weight and did not differ by technique, line or their interaction. Loading frequency differed by technique, not by line. |
The ascender drop tests
The 2011 paper starts from the makers' limits. Product literature warns against falls that cause impact loads, and the paper says ascenders are usually classified as Type B rope grabs under EN 12841-2006. A Type B grab on a working line goes with a safety line carrying a Type A rope grab. Kane writes that many of those limits are broken in tree climbing.
The tests used one 86 kg drop mass, with the ascender 1000 mm and 2000 mm below the dynamometer. That gave fall factors of 1.04 and 0.52. Limited extra runs used 4000 mm of rope, a 110 kg mass, a backup hitch and a Prusik knot in place of an ascender.
On the full set, arrest distance stayed within 2 m in 3 of 33 tests at 1000 mm and in 7 of 34 at 2000 mm. The ascenders cut and stripped the outer sheath of the arborist ropes. Both tests at 110 kg completely severed one rope. On the static rescue rope, the arrest distance did not exceed 2 m in any test.
Kane's discussion calls the tests a clear demonstration that toothed ascenders and the arborist ropes tested are incompatible. He adds that it seems prudent for the Z133 safety standard to address ascender use in tree climbing.
The hitch and rope breaking-load tests
In every test of the 2012 paper the rope failed at the first bend where the standing part entered the hitch, whichever hitch was tied. That matches the finding that hitches differed little.
The author lists a limit himself: the load was applied gradually, and rigging loads are usually dynamic. He cautions against choosing a rope or sling on breaking load or specific strength alone. He also records that even the weakest knotted rope in the test was stronger than the loads measured while removing red pines in the 2009 paper.
The tie-in point loads
The 2022 abstract gives the aim as helping climbers choose tie-in points. Footlocking produced loads at a wide range of frequencies. Ropewalking was tied to two distinct frequencies. The authors name how much a tie-in point can carry, checked from the ground, as the subject for future studies.
Other climbing papers on the journal's keyword page
The keyword page for climbing lists further papers whose results are not reported here:
- Kane and Ryan, Residual Strength of Carabiners Used by Tree Climbers, 35(2), March 2009, pages 75 to 79.
- Kane, Friction Coefficients for Arborist Ropes Passing Through Cambium Saver Rings, 33(1), January 2007, pages 31 to 42.
- Gathright, Yamada and Morita, Tree-Assisted Therapy: Therapeutic and Societal Benefits from Purpose-Specific Technical Recreational Tree-Climbing Programs, 34(4), July 2008, pages 222 to 229.
- Zillmer, Boeder and Genich, A Productivity Timing System for Tree Climbing Training, 26(2), March 2000, pages 97 to 105.
The rigging keyword page also lists Donzelli, Comparison of the Frictional Properties of Several Popular Arborist Blocks, 25(2), March 1999, pages 61 to 68.
Sources
- Brian Kane, Compatibility of Toothed Ascenders with Arborist Climbing Ropes, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 37(4), July 2011, read October 16, 2026
- Brian Kane, Breaking Load of Hitches and Ropes Used in Rigging, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 38(1), January 2012, read October 16, 2026
- Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, keyword page: rigging, read October 16, 2026
- Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, keyword page: climbing, read October 16, 2026
- Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, Volume 48 Issue 6 table of contents, November 2022, read October 16, 2026
- Brian Kane and Sanjay R. Arwade, The Effect of Climbing Line and Ascent Technique on the Magnitude and Frequency of Arboricultural Climbing Loads, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 48(6), abstract, read October 16, 2026
- Brian Kane, Sergio Brena and Wesley Autio, Forces and Stresses Generated During Rigging Operations, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 35(2), abstract, read October 16, 2026