Rope grabs and back-up devices: types, standards and Kane's 2011 arrest tests
In Brian Kane's 2011 drop tests, toothed ascenders on four arborist ropes met the EN 12841-2006 arrest limit of 2 m in 10 of 67 tests. SafeWork NSW section 4.6 says a back-up on the main line should be considered.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The named codes, standards bodies and journals are described here as published. It is not training and does not teach the work.
Type A and type B rope grabs
EN 12841 sorts rope adjustment devices into types. Kane's paper in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry notes that toothed ascenders are usually classed as type B rope grabs, devices for positioning on a working line. A type A rope grab is the fall arrest type.
The paper reports the makers' own warnings. A climber who uses a type B grab on the working line must also be secured to a safety line by a type A grab. Falls that load the ascender with an impact are to be avoided. Which tree work codes cite the type letters is set out in the guide to EN 12841 rope adjustment device types.
BSI lists BS EN 12841:2024, Personal fall protection equipment. Rope access systems. Rope adjustment devices, published March 31, 2024. Its catalogue entry says the British text is identical to EN 12841, gives the status as current, under review, and files the standard with committee PH/5 under ICS code 13.340.60. The entry carries no scope text.
What Kane's tests measured
Kane (Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 37(4), July 2011, pages 180 to 185) dropped an 86 kg mass onto toothed ascenders in March and April 2010. The ascenders ran on four new arborist climbing ropes and on one static rescue rope. A lanyard joined the ascender to the mass, and a dynamometer on a branch about 12 m up a red oak recorded the load.
The method followed the EN 12841-2006 type B test with changes for tree work. The ascender took the mass as a static load for 60 seconds before the throwline holding it was cut. Each rope and length combination had five to ten replicates. Ascenders showed fatigue, usually a bent frame beside the cam, and were retired after several tests.
| Rope between dynamometer and ascender | Fall factor | Tests | Tests within 2 m |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1000 mm | 1.04 | 33 | 3 |
| 2000 mm | 0.52 | 34 | 7 |
| Both lengths | Not applicable | 67 | 10 |
All ten tests within 2 m came from two of them. The other two never stopped the ascender inside 2 m. The static rescue rope, tested separately, did not exceed 2 m in any test.
Impact load and the back-up hitch
Impact loads averaged more than 5 kN with an ascender alone. Kane reports a mean of 5.1 kN across the ascender tests. A 3-wrap, 6-coil Prusik knot in place of the ascender gave the greatest loads, with a maximum of 8.5 kN.
The study also tied a friction hitch above the ascender as a back-up, as popular climbing literature shows. The hitch left arrest distance about the same and raised the impact load to more than 6 kN. Kane adds that the hitch was only mildly tightened, to mimic one pushed up the rope during a footlock, and that it was effective in three of ten tests. He allows that a hitch may still guard against other accidents, such as a branch knocking the ascender off the rope.
Other limited tests sit outside the 67. At 4000 mm of rope, arrest distance topped 2 m in two of five tests on one arborist rope. With the mass raised to 110 kg, both tests on one arborist rope cut the rope through completely.
How the ropes failed the test
On the arborist ropes the ascender cut and stripped the outer sheath, which bunched up and slowed the fall. On two ropes only a few inner strands remained in some tests, with a residual diameter near 5 mm. The core of the other two looked undamaged to the eye.
Kane's reading is that toothed ascenders and the arborist ropes tested are not compatible. The maker data he cites has a toothed ascender cutting the sheath of a 13 mm kernmantle rope at 6.5 kN. He proposes that the ANSI Z133 standard of 2006 should address ascenders in tree climbing. He also notes the 60 Hz recording rate, below the 1000 Hz the standard requires, so the true peak loads may be higher.
SafeWork NSW section 4.6
The SafeWork NSW Tree works code of practice, March 2026, has a section on mechanical ascenders, descenders and rope grabs. It lists points to be considered when selecting, using and maintaining them.
- The devices should suit the rope specifications of the system, with attention to the recommended rope diameter for each device.
- They should be self-locking, or used with another device that is self-locking.
- Descent devices should brake automatically when the operator lets go of the control hand.
- Faulty or defective equipment should be removed from service until repaired and assessed as fit for use.
- Where mechanical ascenders are used, consideration should be given to a backup (secondary attachment) on the main climbing line in case the ascender fails mechanically.
The code defines an ascender as a knot or mechanical device used for ascending a rope and positioning the climber in the tree. It commenced on March 27, 2026 and replaced the 1998 Amenity Tree Industry Code of practice.
Where the sources differ
The NSW code says consideration should be given to a backup on the main climbing line when mechanical ascenders are used. Kane found that one common form of backup, a friction hitch, did not shorten the arrest distance. Kane tested a toothed ascender, one friction hitch, and a drop mass that stands for a worst-case fall.
Sources
- Kane, B., Compatibility of toothed ascenders with arborist climbing ropes, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 37(4):180-185, July 2011, read October 16, 2026
- BSI Knowledge, BS EN 12841:2024 catalogue entry, published March 31, 2024, read October 16, 2026
- SafeWork NSW, Tree works code of practice, March 2026, section 4.6 and glossary, read October 16, 2026