ArbNation Join free

Work-as-imagined and work-as-done: Safety-I, Safety-II and HSE human factors

HSE defines human factors as the job, the individual and the organisation. A Eurocontrol white paper and Ireland's HSA both separate work-as-imagined from work-as-done, and the white paper adds Safety-I and Safety-II.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Safety science has a vocabulary for the gap between the written procedure and the job as it happens on site. Three official or agency publications set out the terms: the UK Health and Safety Executive, Ireland's Health and Safety Authority, and a Eurocontrol white paper hosted by the European Union Agency for Railways.

HSE's definition of human factors

HSE's introduction to human factors quotes the definition from its guidance Reducing error and influencing behaviour (HSG48). Human factors are the environmental, organisational and job factors, and the human and individual characteristics, that influence behaviour at work in a way that can affect health and safety.

HSE splits this into three linked parts. The job covers the task, workload, the working environment, displays and controls, and the role of procedures. The individual covers competence, skills, personality, attitude and risk perception. The organisation covers work patterns, culture, resources, communications and leadership.

HSE adds that interventions will not work if they look at the three parts in isolation. It also notes that people usually try to adapt to poor job, equipment or environment design, and that this can affect their health and safety.

On culture, HSE gives an example: a new starter quickly learns the behaviour that fellow workers and supervisors treat as normal. Workers also respond to cues from managers, though not always as intended.

Work-as-imagined and work-as-done

The Health and Safety Authority in Ireland ties the two terms to risk assessment under section 19 of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005. Its human factors page says the aim is to take account of what really happens in a task, which it calls work-as-done, and not an imagined version of the task.

The HSA defines work-as-imagined as how we think others might do the work. It says that when we imagine work we tend to be overly optimistic: we imagine that people do not make mistakes, follow procedures and work in ideal conditions.

The HSA lists questions to put to a task. They include which errors and non-compliances are relevant, what has gone wrong in the past, what makes the task difficult or frustrating, and what those who do the task think are the most effective controls. It also asks what the crew would tell an apprentice to watch out for.

For finding the answers, the HSA points to task analysis: breaking a task into smaller parts, walking and talking through it, and asking questions where the task happens.

Safety-I and Safety-II

The Eurocontrol white paper is by Erik Hollnagel with Jörg Leonhardt, Tony Licu and Steven Shorrock. It describes Safety-I as the view that safety means as few things as possible going wrong. In that view, things go wrong because of technical, human and organisational failures, and people are mainly a liability or hazard.

The white paper dates that view to the 1960s to 1980s, when systems were simpler. Safety-II is the alternative: as many things as possible go right. People are treated as a resource, and everyday performance variability is the reason things usually go right.

PointSafety-I, then Safety-II
Safety isAs few things as possible going wrong, then as many as possible going right
People areA liability or hazard, then a resource for flexibility and resilience
The response isTo react when something happens or a risk is judged unacceptable, then to anticipate developments and events
An investigation looks forThe causes and contributory factors of an adverse outcome, then how things usually go right, as a basis for explaining how they occasionally go wrong

On the gap between the two kinds of work, the white paper describes work-as-imagined as an idealistic view of the formal task, covering what should happen under nominal conditions. Work-as-done describes what actually happens as work unfolds in a concrete situation.

The authors argue that safety could once be pursued by making work-as-done identical to work-as-imagined, through detailed instructions and training. They say today's more complex systems make the two differ a great deal. Failures cannot be prevented by removing performance variability, in their words, because successes and failures both depend on it.

The white paper does not call for dropping existing methods. It says most can stay in use, possibly with a different emphasis, and it recommends combining the two ways of thinking. On the practical side, the authors write that risks can only be understood by getting out from behind the desk and into operational environments with operational people.

Where tree work fits

None of the three publications mentions tree work. The white paper comes from air traffic management, and HSE and the HSA write for employers in general.

Sources