Sapwood and heartwood decay: where each rot develops and what the tree keeps
Heart rot develops in the inner wood of living trees, and sap rot in the outer wood under the bark. Penn State Extension and the Forest Service describe how a tree can hollow out and keep growing, and when decay reaches the sapwood.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page draws on a Forest Service bulletin, a Penn State Extension article and Forest Service Alaska Region notes. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one.
Heart rot and sap rot defined
The Forest Service Alaska Region separates the two by place in the stem. Heart rot develops primarily in the heartwood, the inner wood of living trees. Sap rot develops in the sapwood, the outer wood beneath the bark, and is usually extensive only in dead trees. The same notes list wildlife holes, cavities and hollows as signs of stem decay in a live tree, even when no conk or mushroom shows.
Alex Shigo's Forest Service bulletin Tree Decay: An Expanded Concept, published in 1979, takes a different line on the word itself. Shigo writes that the heartrot concept must be abandoned, because it deals only with decay-causing fungi and types of decayed wood. His expanded concept puts the tree's own orderly response to wounding and infection at the centre.
How a tree can be hollow and still growing
Penn State Extension describes a living tree as a compartmented organism. It cannot heal a wound the way an animal does, so it walls off the damaged area and gives up those cells. The walls are mostly chemical and internal. The fourth wall, the barrier zone, is a chemical and physical boundary between the wood laid down after the wound and the wood that was there at the time.
As decay moves through the inside, the tree might lose its centre sapwood and become hollow. The article calls this part of ageing for some trees, while others form heartwood that resists decay. Species and genetics usually drive the difference. Oak, hickory, sugar maple and redwood are strong compartmentalizers. Silver maple, cottonwood and willow are weak ones, and they try to outgrow the column of decay by adding new wood while their centres hollow out.
Penn State adds that decay is usually present in many older trees that are still structurally strong. The Alaska notes make a similar point for conifers: most of these decays do not interfere with the normal growth and physiological processes of a live tree, because the vascular system is unaffected.
When decay reaches the sapwood
The Alaska notes name exceptions. Two fungi, Hartig's conk and the red ring rot fungus, may attack the sapwood and cambium of live trees after living as heart rot fungi. Hartig's conk can kill a hemlock within a decade of fruiting body development, by girdling the sapwood or snapping the stem. The red ring rot decay can progress from the heartwood to the sapwood and cause tree death.
The notes list most of the conifer stem decay fungi as decaying heartwood, and some as occupying both sapwood and heartwood. Artist's conk is listed as a white rot of both sapwood and heartwood that usually lives on dead logs and stumps. Occasionally it turns up as a heart rot on wounds of living trees.
Where the sources stop
The Alaska notes cover conifers in one state. Treesearch carries only the abstract of Shigo's bulletin. None of the three sources gives a figure for how much hollow wood a standing tree can carry.
Sources
- USDA Forest Service Northern Research Station, Shigo, Tree decay an expanded concept (Agriculture Information Bulletin 419, 1979), Treesearch record, read October 19, 2026
- Penn State Extension, Understanding the Spread of Decay in Trees (updated November 10, 2024), read October 19, 2026
- USDA Forest Service Alaska Region, Conifer Stem Decays (updated 2025), read October 19, 2026