Second opinions on tree work: consultants, contractors and extra quotes, per tree bodies
The Arboricultural Association and Iowa State Extension split tree advisers from tree workers, and TCIA and the AA both put several opinions or quotes in their hiring lists.
This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Two kinds of arborist answer a tree owner's question, and the trade bodies name them differently. The Arboricultural Association (AA) in the United Kingdom calls them consultants and contractors. Iowa State University Extension calls them consulting arborists and practicing arborists. Neither body sets out a procedure for settling a disagreement between two arborists. What each publishes is the split between advice and work, and the call for more than one opinion or quote.
Consultants and contractors
The AA's Find a Professional page splits people able to care for trees into consultants, also called tree advisers or arboriculturists, and contractors, also called tree surgeons or arborists.
| Role | What the bodies record |
|---|---|
| Consultant (AA); consulting arborist (Iowa State) | Gives specialist opinion on tree health, safety, preservation, trees and buildings, planning and other law (AA). Gives recommendations but does not carry out the tree care procedures (Iowa State) |
| Contractor (AA); practicing arborist (Iowa State) | Provides tree planting, pruning and felling services, and some also advise on maintenance and on pest and disease control (AA). Performs the actual tree care practices (Iowa State) |
The AA offers an analogy. The consultant is like a building surveyor, structural engineer or architect, and the contractor is like the site manager with skilled bricklayers and carpenters. It runs separate directories: Registered Consultants, ARB Approved Tree Surgeons and ARB Approved Utility Tree Surgeons. It reports that everyone listed has met its assessment standards. Most Registered Consultants, the AA adds, work nationwide for regular clients or on larger, complex projects.
Iowa State Extension, in its How to Hire an Arborist article, states that the owner's situation determines which type of arborist is needed. Its consulting examples are building near established trees, changing the grade around trees, and working out the value of a damaged tree. Some arborists also appraise trees in dollars for tax, insurance and casualty loss purposes, and some develop planting plans. The article adds that owning a truck and chainsaw does not automatically qualify someone as an arborist.
More than one quote or opinion
The Tree Care Industry Association (TCIA) page Hiring a Tree Care Company lists getting additional estimates or opinions of the needed work among the things to do when meeting an arborist. It also lists a signed contract that states the cost, the dates and exactly what is to be done.
The AA's Choosing your Arborist page sets out a six-step process. Step one is to pick companies to offer a quote, and the AA recommends three. Site visits are normally free. At the visit the owner explains both the work wanted and the objectives, because the AA says a good contractor can advise the best way to meet the goals from their knowledge and experience. The AA also notes that a quote should state who checks legal constraints, such as a Tree Preservation Order or a Conservation Area.
The AA states that the cheapest quote is not always best. It adds that reliability, courtesy and work to industry safety standards are worth paying for, and that it is courteous to tell unsuccessful contractors they were not chosen.
Where the pages stop
None of these pages gives wording on sharing a consultant's report with a contractor, or on weighing two conflicting reports. The consultant and contractor split above is the closest the bodies come to it. For more on the two roles, see the guide to consultants and tree surgeons and the guide to the consulting arborist.
Who to call
- Arboricultural Association, Find a Professional: directories of Registered Consultants and ARB Approved tree surgeons in the United Kingdom
- Iowa State University Extension, Natural Resources: the split between consulting and practicing arborists, with a list of consulting arborists in Iowa
- A consulting arborist: independent opinions on tree health, risk and value
Sources
- Arboricultural Association, Find a Professional (consultants and contractors), read October 16, 2026
- Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, How to Hire an Arborist (from publication F-366 by Tivon E. Feeley), last reviewed February 1, 2020, read October 16, 2026
- Tree Care Industry Association, Hiring a Tree Care Company, page dated May 5, 2023, read October 16, 2026
- Arboricultural Association, Choosing your Arborist (Tree Surgeon), last modified June 12, 2025, read October 16, 2026