ArbNation Join free

Employee or self-employed for tax: HMRC, CRA, Inland Revenue and Revenue tests

Four tax offices outside the United States decide employee or self-employed on the facts of the working relationship, not the label. HMRC runs an online check, the CRA lists factors, Inland Revenue lists five tests, Revenue in Ireland uses five questions.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. It covers the United Kingdom, Canada, New Zealand and Ireland. The Australian Taxation Office tool page did not open, so Australia is not here. For the United States, see the rule history for federal wage law.

United Kingdom: HMRC's check employment status tool

HMRC publishes the Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool. It gives HMRC's view of whether a worker on a specific engagement is employed or self-employed for tax. That status decides who works out and pays the tax and National Insurance contributions due. HMRC stands by every result the tool gives, as long as the information entered stays accurate and follows its guidance.

Anyone can use it: hirers, workers, agencies and third parties. It is also used to find out whether the off-payroll working (IR35) rules apply to an engagement. A contract must be in place or expected, and it can be written, verbal, implied or a mix. The tool draws on the contract details, the worker's responsibilities, and who decides what work is done and when, where and how it is done. The same list covers how the worker is paid and any corporate benefits or reimbursed expenses. A result can be saved and used as a status determination statement. HMRC points to its Employment Status Manual for more.

Canada: the CRA's RC4110

The Canada Revenue Agency guide RC4110 says "The facts of the working relationship as a whole decide the employment status". The question is whether the person is engaged to carry out services as a person in business on their own account, or as an employee. The CRA cancelled RC4110 as of January 30, 2026. Its replacement is Employment status: Employee or self-employed. The factors below are those of the cancelled guide.

The first step is the intent of the worker and payer, a contract of service or a contract for services. Intent can be shown by a written agreement, testimony or the parties' actions. The replacement page says all of the facts, including the actual terms and conditions of employment, determine a worker's employment status, not just the intention. The CRA then considers whether the facts reflect the stated intention.

Factors in RC4110, outside Quebec
FactorPoints toward self-employmentPoints toward employment
ControlWorker is usually free to work when and for whom they choose, and can accept or refuse workPayer often directs, scrutinizes and controls how and when the work is done
Tools and equipmentLarge worker investment, with repair and insurance on the workerPayer supplies the equipment
Helpers and substitutesWorker can hire and pay assistants or substitutesWorker must do the work personally
Financial riskFixed ongoing costs, unreimbursed expenses, liability for unmet obligationsExpenses reimbursed, no exposure
Chance of profitWorker sets prices, serves several payers, gains or loses moneyPay may vary by commission or bonus, but no business upside

The guide says that being required to provide tools of the trade does not in itself mean a worker is self-employed, and that chance of profit is considered from the worker's perspective, not the payer's. Quebec has a separate three-step approach under the Civil Code of Québec: the parties' intent; the factors of carrying out the work, remuneration and the relationship of subordination; and a comparison of intent with the actual working relationship.

Either the worker or the payer can ask the CRA for a CPP/EI ruling on Form CPT1. The guide gives June 29 of the year after the work as the deadline, a 90-day appeal period, and says it does not replace a formal ruling.

New Zealand: Inland Revenue's IG 16/01

Inland Revenue issued Interpretation Guideline IG 16/01 on March 8, 2016. It replaces IG 11/01 and says the Commissioner's approach is unchanged. The Income Tax Act 2007 defines an employee by reference to a PAYE income payment, a payment of salary or wages made in connection with employment. Case law reads that as a contract of service. Under the Goods and Services Tax Act 1985, supplies under a contract of service are not taxable. The statutes do not say how to find a contract of service, so Inland Revenue relies on the common law.

The five common law tests in IG 16/01
TestWhat it examines
Intention of the partiesWhat each party intended as to the nature of the relationship
ControlHow far the employer or principal controls the manner of the work; high control supports employee
IndependenceHow much independence the person has over the work; high independence supports contractor
FundamentalWhether the person is in business on their own account
IntegrationWhether the person is integrated into the business, which supports employee, or is an accessory to it

The guideline names the Supreme Court decision in Bryson v Three Foot Six Ltd [2005] NZSC 34 as the leading case. It says Bryson is consistent with the Court of Appeal in TNT Worldwide Express Ltd v Cunningham [1993] 3 NZLR 681.

Ireland: Revenue's five-question framework

Revenue's Tax and Duty Manual Part 05-01-30, last reviewed May 2026, applies the Supreme Court judgment of October 20, 2023 in The Revenue Commissioners v Karshan (Midlands) Ltd t/a Domino's Pizza. Revenue decides status for tax. The Department of Social Protection decides it for PRSI. The Manual notes there is no single legal definition of employed or self-employed in Irish or EU law.

  1. Does the contract exchange wages or other remuneration for work?
  2. Is the worker agreeing to provide their own services, not those of a third party?
  3. Does the employer exercise enough control to make the agreement capable of being an employment agreement?
  4. Do the terms and the working arrangements point to the worker working for themselves or for the putative employer?
  5. Does the particular legislative regime require any adjustment?

The first three questions act as a filter: a no to any of them means there cannot be a contract of employment. The Manual calls the control question a gateway, the legal minimum before a relationship can be an employment contract.

On construction, the Manual says many workers are treated as self-employed and paid under Relevant Contracts Tax at 0%, 20% or 35%. The same system covers forestry. The Manual calls it highly likely that a worker engaged full time or near full time by one business, with no say over what work is done or when, is an employee for tax. A casual labourer paid by the hour under a foreman's direction is another example it gives. A firm with its own team, a fixed fee, and freedom to send anyone to do the work is its example of a worker properly treated as self-employed.

Sources