ArbNation Join free

Silvicultural systems defined: clearfell, shelterwood, selection and coppice

Clearfell, seed-tree, shelterwood, selection and coppice are the named ways to harvest and renew a woodland. The US Forest Service and Forest Research define each by the age structure it leaves and the way the old crop is cut.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Forest Research defines silviculture as the care and cultivation of woodlands, as opposed to arboriculture, which is the care and cultivation of individual trees. The US Forest Service glossary calls silviculture the art and science of controlling the establishment, growth, composition, health and quality of forests and woodlands. A silvicultural system, in the Forest Service white paper on silvicultural terminology, is a planned series of treatments for tending, harvesting and reestablishing a stand.

Age structure

The Forest Service sorts systems by how many age classes a stand holds. An even-aged stand has one age class, and its trees usually differ in age by less than 20 percent of the rotation, the age at which the stand is to be regenerated. A two-aged stand has two age classes. An uneven-aged stand has three or more. The white paper calls these end points of a continuum and says stands matching either extreme are seldom found in nature.

Forest Research uses the words regular and irregular for the same idea in Britain. A glossary in a Forestry Commission bulletin defines regular as even-aged and uniform, and irregular as uneven-aged with several canopy layers over a small area.

The systems

Silvicultural systems as the sources define them
SystemDefinitionAge structure
Clearfell, clearcutCutting essentially all trees to give a fully exposed microclimate for a new age class. Forest Research describes a single felling of the crop at the end of the rotationEven-aged
Seed-treeA clearcut except for a few seed-producing trees left to regenerate the area. The Forest Service paper sets the test at an average of at least six desirable trees kept per treated acreEven-aged
ShelterwoodA new age class develops under the moderated microenvironment of the residual trees. Forest Research describes the uniform system as clear fell, except that the old crop is cleared by two or more successive regeneration fellingsEven-aged
Single tree selectionIndividual trees of all size classes are removed more or less uniformly through the stand, giving growing space and room for regenerationUneven-aged
Group selectionTrees are cut in small groups and new age classes are established. The group width is commonly about twice the height of the mature treesUneven-aged
CoppiceTrees are cut and most regeneration comes from sprouts or root suckersEven-aged

Clearfell and its variants

The Forest Service paper cites a definition of clearcutting as the harvesting in one operation of all trees, with the expectation that a new even-aged stand will be established. Regeneration follows natural seeding, seed in the slash or forest floor, planting or direct seeding. Common variants are strip clearcutting and patch clearcutting. The paper puts large-patch clearcuts usually above two acres and small-patch clearcuts often below it. A clearcut with reserves keeps varying numbers of live trees for goals other than regeneration, which produces a two-aged stand.

Forest Research gives the rotation for clearfell as a minimum of 40 to 60 years, which may be longer than 160 years for slow-growing species such as oak. It adds that clearfell usually means planting on larger areas, with natural regeneration from seed on smaller ones. The Forestry Commission bulletin glossary defines extensive clear cutting as complete removal over about 30 to 50 hectares or more, with felling usually inside three years and no seed trees kept. Its patch clear cutting uses coupes of about 5 to 30 hectares.

Shelterwood

The Forest Service glossary lists up to three cuts in a shelterwood sequence. They are an optional preparatory cut, a seed cut that sets up the moderated microenvironment and seedbed, and a removal cut that frees the new age class from the overwood. Cutting can be uniform, in groups or patches, or in strips.

The Forestry Commission bulletin describes shelterwood systems as partial felling that leaves a scattered overstorey of mature trees as seedbearers, with regeneration in their overhead or side shelter. It defines group shelterwood as regeneration in groups, usually under 0.6 hectares. Forest Research lists the uniform, group, irregular shelterwood and strip and wedge systems. It says the strip and wedge system reduces the risk of wind damage to a crop.

Selection

Forest Research says selection systems differ from the others because felling and regeneration are not restricted to a specific area. Felling takes place across the whole woodland according to tree form, age and size. The result is an uneven age structure, a continuous canopy and a woodland that can closely resemble natural woodland. A standard selection system removes single trees. A group selection system removes trees from small areas, which Forest Research says is commonly used to favour light-demanding species that struggle to regenerate otherwise.

The Forestry Commission bulletin glossary treats single tree selection as the classical system for continuous forest cover. It puts coupe size in group systems normally below 0.25 hectares, or 50 by 50 metres.

Coppice

Forest Research defines coppicing as cutting the stem of certain broadleaf species back to near the ground so that multiple stems grow from the stool. Not all species coppice, and some coppice unreliably. Conifers do not coppice. The Forest Research table lists the following coppice systems.

  • Short rotation coppice, cut on a 3 year rotation, usually grown as an agricultural crop.
  • Coppice, on a 12 to 20 year rotation, with the whole stool clear felled at the end and usually a small area felled each year.
  • Coppice selection, also on 12 to 20 years, with weaker stems thinned, for example to 5 stems per stool.
  • Coppice with standards, where coppice on 12 to 20 years sits under single large trees that grow on for seed or timber. The standards run a full high forest rotation of at least 40 to 60 years.

The Forest Service defines the coppice regeneration method as even-aged, with the previous stand cut and the majority of regeneration from sprouts or root suckers. The white paper leaves coppice out of its main discussion because of its limited relevance in western North America.

Thinning and other intermediate cuts

Between regeneration cuts, the Forest Service glossary defines thinning as an intermediate treatment that reduces stand density mainly to improve growth, enhance forest health or recover potential mortality. Forest Research says thinning can be systematic, for example every third tree, or selective, for example the 20 percent of trees with the poorest form. The Forest Service lists release, improvement cutting, salvage cutting and sanitation cutting as other intermediate treatments.

Sources