Soft rot, white rot and brown rot: how each type takes strength from wood
Brown rot cuts wood strength faster than white rot in the early stages, and soft rot is typically shallow. The Forest Service Wood Handbook, Forest Service Alaska Region notes and Penn State Extension give the strength figures and the wood each rot leaves behind.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page draws on a Forest Service handbook chapter, Forest Service Alaska Region notes and a Penn State Extension article. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one.
Brown rot
The Forest Products Laboratory's Wood Handbook, chapter 14, says brown-rot fungi extensively remove only the cellulose. The wood turns browner, can crack across the grain into cube-like pieces, shrinks, collapses and can be crushed into powder. Brown-rot fungi commonly colonize softwoods, but they can colonize both softwoods and hardwoods when temperature and moisture favour decay.
The Alaska Region notes call brown rots particularly detrimental to tree strength. They degrade the cellulose fibres and leave brownish lignin that dries into brittle cubes. For one brown cubical butt rot in spruce and hemlock, the notes record a rapid loss of tensile strength, even at fairly early stages, that may lead to breakage on the lower bole.
White rot
The Wood Handbook says white-rot fungi usually remove both lignin and cellulose. The wood may lose colour and look bleached. It does not crack across the grain, and until severely degraded it keeps its outward dimensions, does not shrink or collapse, and often feels spongy.
The Alaska notes put it this way: white rots decompose all wood components, and the wood stays fibrous until very late stages of decay. Penn State Extension adds that the remaining light-coloured cellulose becomes soft and spongy, or stringy. White-rot fungi commonly occur on hardwoods, in the Wood Handbook's wording.
Soft rot
The Wood Handbook describes soft rot as caused by fungi more closely related to the molds than to the brown-rot and white-rot fungi. It calls soft rot a third and usually less important kind of decay. The rot is usually relatively shallow and primarily affects the outer surface. Affected wood is greatly degraded and often soft when wet, and the wood just beneath the zone may be firm. Soft rot is favoured by wet conditions and by surfaces that are alternately wetted and dried over a considerable period.
Penn State Extension describes soft rot as caused by both bacteria and fungi, whose enzymes break down cell walls and the materials between them. It adds that the fungi grow slower than the brown-rot and white-rot fungi. The Wood Handbook treats bacteria in wood as ordinarily of little consequence, though some may cause strength losses over long periods, particularly in forest soils.
Strength loss in the Wood Handbook
| Stage | What the chapter reports |
|---|---|
| Early | Decay first affects toughness, the ability to withstand impacts. In laboratory tests, toughness losses ranged from 6% to over 50% by the time 1% weight loss had occurred. |
| Next | Reductions in strength values related to static bending follow. |
| 10% weight loss | Most strength losses may be expected to exceed 50%. At this weight loss, or less, decay is detectable only under the microscope. |
| Visible decay | Wood with visually discernible decay may be assumed to be greatly reduced in all strength values. |
| Eventually | All strength properties are seriously reduced. |
The chapter adds that brown-rot fungi cause greater reductions in strength in the early stages of decay than white-rot fungi do. Strength losses during early stages of decay depend to a great extent on the fungi involved and to a lesser extent on the type of wood.
Limits of the sources
The Wood Handbook chapter covers wood as an engineering material, such as lumber, poles and ties, and notes that some decay fungi colonize the heartwood or sapwood of living trees. The Alaska notes and Penn State Extension deal with living and dead trees but give no strength percentages.
Sources
- USDA Forest Service Forest Products Laboratory, Wood Handbook, Wood as an Engineering Material (FPL-GTR-282, 2021), chapter 14, Biodeterioration of Wood, read October 19, 2026
- USDA Forest Service Alaska Region, Conifer Stem Decays (updated 2025), read October 19, 2026
- Penn State Extension, Understanding the Spread of Decay in Trees (updated November 10, 2024), read October 19, 2026