Backfill amendments at planting: what extension and trials report
Extension services in Florida, Utah, Arizona and Georgia all advise refilling the planting hole with the soil that came out of it. A University of Florida trial on live oak found no benefit from any backfill amendment.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Extension services and one field trial publish findings on amending the backfill around a newly planted tree. Backfill is the soil returned to the hole after the root ball is set. An amendment is anything mixed into it, such as compost, peat, gel or fertilizer.
The extension position
All four extension publications reach the same position for ordinary soil.
| Publication | Position on backfill |
|---|---|
| University of Florida IFAS, ENH871 (Gilman) | In all but exceptional cases of very poor soil, extensive research on trees shows no need to put amendments, fertilizers, spores, gels, humic acids or organic products in the backfill. It is better to replace bad soil than to amend it |
| Utah State University Extension, Tree Planting Rules, Rule 6 | Backfill with native soil and no amendments. Organic matter such as peat moss, up to 25 percent of soil volume mixed in thoroughly, only for a very poor soil such as clay subsoil or rock |
| University of Arizona Cooperative Extension, AZ1022 (Schuch) | Fill the hole with unamended soil. Manure, compost and wood chips do not improve growth and may inhibit it |
| University of Georgia Extension, Fulton County | No compost or fertilizer in the planting hole, because organic matter holds too much water around fragile roots. Native soil is best |
Exceptions: poor soil and mycorrhizal spores
Gilman's fact sheet names two. Where the existing soil is so bad or contaminated that all soil over a large area is replaced with good-quality soil, as in a parking lot island or a small sidewalk cutout, the soil is swapped rather than amended. Spores of mycorrhizal fungi have also produced large growth responses in strip mine soils, many of which are essentially sterile. The sheet adds that there are few, if any, reports of a response in urban and suburban landscapes, and most studies show none.
Utah State's rule leaves room for peat on very poor soil. The Georgia article places soil amendment earlier in the sequence: lime, fertilizer or compost go on the site according to a soil test, before the tree goes in.
Slow-release fertilizer
Gilman reports that slow-release fertilizer at planting has not been tied to better survival or growth in fairly good soil. Where it is used, it can go on top of the root ball and backfill or on top of the mulch rather than in the hole, because most roots end up near the surface. Soluble fertilizer on a new plant can burn roots. Utah State says fertilizer at planting stimulates root rots and puts the wait at one to two years. Arizona says nitrogen is usually lacking and can go on the surface a year after planting.
The live oak trial
Gilman (2004) planted 210 live oaks, 5 cm (2 in) caliper, from 41 cm containers into a fine sand with less than 2 percent organic matter at a former nursery site in Florida. Seven treatments were compared, including a nontreated control backfilled with native soil.
- Two hydrogels and a pulp-and-paper byproduct mixed into the backfill.
- Composted yard waste, one part to two parts soil.
- A humic and kelp liquid and a growth regulator, paclobutrazol, poured over the root ball.
- The control, with frequent or infrequent irrigation in each case.
Over two years, top growth did not improve on any amended tree. The growth regulator slowed trunk and height growth. Root weight in the backfill matched the control for every amendment. Amendments made no difference to survival or growth under minimal or plentiful irrigation. In the first season, trees watered three times a week grew about twice as fast as trees watered only for the first three months. Growth evened out in the second season. Of the 210 trees, 207 survived, and all three deaths came in the first five months.
The paper says its result contradicts manufacturers' promotional literature and supports nearly all published studies on trees. It reviews older trials. Pine bark in backfill hurt growth unless fertilizer offset the nitrogen it tied up, and peat gave a more fibrous root system that did not spread into the surrounding soil. The authors conclude that the data do not support amendments in backfill, at least in good soil.
Where the sources stop
The trial used a container live oak in good, uncompacted soil, and the paper limits its conclusion the same way. Mulch, planting depth and decompaction are covered in the guide to planting depth and the root flare and the guide to soil decompaction.
Sources
- Gilman, Effects of Soil Amendments and Irrigation on Live Oak After Planting, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 30(5), 2004, read October 16, 2026
- University of Florida IFAS Extension, Amendments at Planting and Backfilling, ENH871/EP127 (Gilman), 2002, read October 16, 2026
- Utah State University Extension, Tree Planting Rules (Kuhns and Mooter), read October 16, 2026
- University of Arizona Cooperative Extension, Planting Guidelines: Container Trees and Shrubs, AZ1022 (Schuch), revised November 2012, read October 16, 2026
- University of Georgia Extension, Fulton County, Planning for Tree Planting Success, Part 3 (LaTora), April 16, 2024, read October 16, 2026