ArbNation Join free

Soil biology claims: microbial inoculants and compost tea

Soil products sold for trees promise living fungi and microbes. An Iowa State article, a 2003 study of street trees and a Washington State University fact sheet report what the trials found.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Mycorrhizal fungi and compost teas are the two soil biology products that extension and research papers have tested on trees. The mycorrhizal side has its own page, mycorrhizal products and what trials show.

Inoculants on established street trees

Arboriculture & Urban Forestry published a study by Appleton, Koci, French, Lestyan and Harris in March 2003. They injected a commercial mycorrhizal product into the soil around three kinds of established tree in Virginia: 13 cm pin oak, 13 cm red maple and 61 cm willow oak. Planting soils at all three sites had been disturbed by construction.

On pin oak, six months later, root colonization and root dry weight did not differ between treatments. A year later, trunk diameter and leaf chlorophyll did not differ either. Willow oak showed no difference in colonization at six months.

Red maple roots did show more colonization with both inoculant treatments. Root dry weight rose with the fertilizer plus inoculant treatment compared with the control and the inoculant alone. On willow oak, root dry weight also rose with the fertilizer and inoculant combination. The authors found no measurable growth benefit from the inoculant unless it was combined with fertilizer.

Roots at every site already carried some mycorrhizal fungi before treatment. The authors suggest this may explain the weak response, or that fungi already in place kept the added fungus out. They add that having roots analyzed for existing colonization may help decide whether an inoculant could do anything.

Why the evidence is thin

The same paper lists reasons that trial results on inoculants are often inconclusive. Treatments are not replicated, designs are poor or lack a control, and evaluation periods are short. Some products hold more than spores, such as biostimulants, dilute fertilizers or bacteria. Few trials confirm colonization in a laboratory.

Iowa State University Extension's Yard and Garden article by Jeff Iles, April 23, 2004, lists the trials published to that date. Silver linden inoculated at transplanting grew more, and its fall yellowing came later. That response first showed two years after installation. Live oak backfilled with spores showed no significant effect on stress, survival or growth. Willow oak showed no survival or growth benefit after one year.

Iles calls his list, give or take a stray paper or two, the sum total of published research. He writes that it seems premature to make adding spores to backfill standard practice. He calls the treatment promising but largely unproven.

Compost tea

A Washington State University Puyallup fact sheet by Angie Cahill and Linda Chalker-Scott defines compost tea as a liquid extract made by diluting compost with water. Anecdotal evidence suggests teas may work against pathogens that cause leaf and fruit disease. The theory is that microbes in the tea act as biological controls. Few controlled, replicable studies exist to support the claims.

Results conflict, the sheet says, because compost age and ingredients, tea preparation and application all vary. It lists what must be defined before a benefit can be credited to a tea: the compost source, the method of preparation, the chemical properties, the active ingredients, the timing and the target pathogen.

The authors ran their own trial on 32 flowering cherry trees of eight cultivars in a Seattle arboretum plot. Half were sprayed with compost tea and half with water at popcorn, full bloom and petal drop. Brown rot rates were close in the two groups. The tea did not reduce disease, and on some cultivars infection was worse. The sheet concludes that more research is needed before any definitive recommendation.

It also warns that teas used as fertilizer add nitrogen, potassium and other minerals all at once. Plants are unlikely to absorb all of it, and the surplus may contribute to eutrophication of watersheds. It concludes that properly composted organic material makes a good mulch and that compost teas have not been suitably characterized or validated scientifically.

Gaps in the sources

  • None of the three tests the soil food web as a framework. The street tree study only mentions that a commercial laboratory rated pre-treatment colonization as acceptable, with no numbers given.
  • The inoculant studies cover a few oak, maple and other species at a few sites. In the street tree study each treatment had four trees on pin oak and red maple and three on willow oak.
  • The compost tea trial tested one disease on flowering cherry. It did not test soil drenches on tree roots.

Sources