ArbNation Join free

Soil compaction: bulk density limits for root growth, by soil texture

USDA NRCS prints three bulk density bands by texture: ideal, may affect roots, and restricts roots. Sandy soils restrict above 1.80 g/cm3, heavy clays above 1.47. A USDA Forest Service report explains why texture sets the limit.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Bulk density is the dry weight of soil per volume, usually given in grams per cubic centimetre (g/cm3). USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) Urban Technical Note 2 records that compaction raises it, cuts pore space and shifts pores toward smaller sizes. The same bulk density can be harmless in sand and close to the limit in clay, so the figures below are tied to texture.

NRCS bands by soil texture

Table 2 of NRCS Urban Technical Note 2 (March 2000) gives the general relationship of bulk density to root growth. It credits the NRCS Soil Quality Institute, 1999. Values are in g/cm3. The rows are printed as the note has them, including the overlapping texture names.

Bulk density and root growth by soil texture, NRCS Urban Technical Note 2, Table 2 (g/cm3)
Soil textureIdealMay affect root growthRestricts root growth
Sands, loamy sandsbelow 1.601.69above 1.80
Sandy loams, loamsbelow 1.401.63above 1.80
Sandy clay loams, loams, clay loamsbelow 1.401.60above 1.75
Silts, silt loamsbelow 1.301.60above 1.75
Silt loams, silty clay loamsbelow 1.101.55above 1.65
Sandy clays, silty clays, some clay loams (35 to 45 percent clay)below 1.101.49above 1.58
Clays (more than 45 percent clay)below 1.101.39above 1.47

The note lists bulk density sampling among its ways to detect compaction. It also gives a penetrometer figure: roots cannot penetrate soil compacted to 300 psi or more, and this varies with soil type and moisture at testing. Compaction is mostly a problem in the top 12 inches of soil, the note records.

Why texture sets the limit

The USDA Forest Service report WSDG-TN-00005 (Daddow and Warrington, January 1983) calls the point where root growth essentially stops the growth-limiting bulk density (GLBD). Roots move through large pores or push soil particles aside. At the GLBD most pores are smaller than the root tips, and the roots cannot push hard enough.

Fine particles mean smaller pores and more resistance at a lower bulk density. The report cites a silt loam with 19 percent macropore space and 2.5 bars of penetration resistance at 1.4 g/cm3, against a sandy loam with 28.9 percent macropore space and 1.2 bars at the same density. It also cites a sunflower study in which roots stopped at 1.75 g/cm3 in sandy soils and at 1.46 to 1.63 g/cm3 in clayey soils.

The authors chose bulk density over soil strength because strength readings depend heavily on moisture and on the penetrometer used. Their GLBD estimates come from a regression on 21 published soil and plant records, with an r-squared of 0.70 and a standard error of 0.09 g/cm3.

Selected records behind the GLBD estimate, Daddow and Warrington 1983, Table 1
SoilPlantSand / silt / clay (percent)Limiting bulk density (g/cm3)
Colo clayCorn27 / 31 / 421.30
Nutley clayPea6 / 39 / 551.37
Nixon silt loamPitch pine, Austrian pine, Norway spruce22 / 64 / 141.40
Columbia loamCotton44 / 37 / 191.55
Lakewood sandy loamPitch pine, Austrian pine, Norway spruce66 / 26 / 81.60 to 1.80
Miles loamy fine sandCotton83 / 8 / 91.82

The report works one example: a clay loam of 30 percent sand, 34 percent silt and 36 percent clay falls between the 1.45 and 1.55 g/cm3 lines on its textural triangle, so its GLBD is about 1.50 g/cm3.

Limits the report states

  • The GLBD values apply only to soils with less than 3 percent organic matter, less than 10 percent coarse fragments and particle density near 2.65 g/cm3. Soils outside those limits lack the research to set values.
  • Individual forest species may respond differently from the agricultural plants that supplied most of the data, and long-term forest data are scarce.
  • The values assume soil water near field capacity. Near saturation or near wilting, aeration or water stress may limit growth more than bulk density.
  • Strong soil structure lets some roots grow along ped faces, and most of the soils behind the triangle were structureless.
  • Most data came from core bulk density measurements. Other methods can give very different values.

The report also says small increases in bulk density can cause large losses in root growth well below the limit. It treats a soil at its GLBD as highly compacted and a soil approaching it as one where productivity could be seriously impaired. It gives a seedling example: a clay-textured soil near 1.40 g/cm3 sits close to its limit, while the same density in a sandy soil probably has little effect.

Forest Research rootable profile

Forest Research in the United Kingdom describes a rootable profile as soil with a bulk density below 1.5 g/cm3 to at least 0.5 m depth and below 1.7 g/cm3 down to 1 m. Its guidance is a rootable profile of at least 1 m for sustainable tree establishment and at least 0.5 m for grass. These thresholds come from a different agency and setting than the NRCS table.

Forest Research reports a long-term trial at a restored sand and gravel quarry on Italian alder, Corsican pine, Japanese larch and silver birch. It compared complete cultivation to 1.1 m, industrial ripping to 0.9 m, deep ripping to 0.75 and 0.9 m with a prototype ripper, and an unloosened control. Complete cultivation remained the most effective method of easing compaction, and the prototype ripper and industrial rippers showed no significant difference in penetration resistance or tree performance. Forest Research also reports that recompaction often occurs within the first year after deep ripping. For research on decompaction, see decompacting soil around trees.

Sources