ArbNation Join free

Soil volume in city design standards: Toronto, Calgary, Winnipeg, Leeds and New York

Toronto asks for 30 m3 of soil per tree, Calgary about 14 m3, and Leeds up to 30 m3 for a large tree. New York City prints pit sizes instead of a cubic figure.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The Minnesota Stormwater Manual keeps a list of cities that set a minimum soil volume for trees. Toronto, Leeds and New York City also publish their own documents, covered below. The Rutgers and Trees and Design Action Group figures are on tree pit soil volume, and a comparison of planting rules is in planting specs compared by city.

Minimums per tree in the Minnesota list

The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency's stormwater manual lists these figures as the jurisdictions print them. Volumes are in cubic metres, with cubic feet in brackets.

Minimum soil volume per tree as listed by the Minnesota Stormwater Manual
JurisdictionSingle treeShared volume
Toronto30 m3 (1059 c.f.), depth 0.9 to 1.2 m20 m3 (706 c.f.) per tree
CalgaryAbout 14 m3 (494 c.f.), sized for a 25 year tree life7 m3 (247 c.f.) more for each added tree in interconnected plantings
Winnipeg8.5 m3 (300 c.f.) to 12.75 m3 (450 c.f.)17.0 m3 (600 c.f.) to 25.5 m3 (900 c.f.) for two trees
Langley, British Columbia10 m3 (353 c.f.) in parking lots and, in the servicing bylaw, street treesNot listed
Denver750 c.f., an internal city standardNot listed

Winnipeg's optimal planting medium depth is 900 mm, and 760 mm is accepted where 900 mm is not feasible. The same list carries other Ontario and British Columbia municipalities, Emeryville in California and Kitchener, which sets figures by mature size class.

Toronto Green Standard, version 4

Measure EC 1.1 of the Toronto Green Standard, version 4, low-rise residential, sets the total soil volume with a formula: 40% of the site area, divided by 66 m2, times 30 m3. Each separate new or retained tree planting area must have access to a minimum of 30 m3 of soil. EC 1.2 asks for the same 30 m3 per large growing shade tree along street frontages.

The standard defines a tree planting area as continuous soil that roots can reach. The soil is at grade, including in a planter on grade or a continuous soil trench. Growing medium is no less than 800 mm and no more than 1600 mm deep, measured from the sidewalk surface. Private property planting areas are at least 2.5 m wide. Soil cells on City property follow the City's own specification. Trees not required by a tree permit may share soil volume, and the standard allows from one tree per 30 m3 to groupings of trees.

Leeds City Council guidance

Leeds City Council's Urban Tree Planting guidance, revision C of December 2018, sets target volumes from crown area. It credits the Lindsey and Bassuk research with a ratio of 0.6 cubic metres of soil per square metre of crown projection, or 2 cubic feet per square foot.

Leeds target soil volume by mature crown
Mature crownCrown areaTarget soil volume
Large (8 m diameter or more)50 m230 m3
Medium (5 to 8 m)19.6 m212 m3 (11.8 m3)
Small (3 to 5 m)7.1 m25 m3 (4.24 m3)
Small to mediumNot stated8.5 m3

Volume cannot be achieved with extra depth: Leeds puts the maximum useful depth of soil under BS 3882 at 900 mm. A lower volume than calculated is not accepted without overriding justification. The formula does not apply to fastigiated and columnar trees. Soil beyond the pit, such as verges and gardens, can count when roots are connected through break-out zones.

New York City Parks planting standards

The New York City Department of Parks and Recreation, in Tree Planting Standards dated April 2008, prints no cubic minimum. It asks for tree pits as large as possible, with 4 by 10 feet or 5 by 10 feet as the ideal sizes. A sample table gives pit volumes: a 7 foot wide pit 6 feet long holds 84 cubic feet of soil, and a continuous pit 100 feet long holds 1400.

The standards encourage continuous tree pits and define a grouped planting in a continuous pit as two or more trees in a single trench at least 30 feet long. They list shared soil volume among the benefits of grouping.

Sources