ArbNation Join free

Butternut (Juglans cinerea): what the agencies record

Butternut is a fast-growing, short-lived walnut of the eastern United States and Canada, valued for its nuts. The agencies call butternut canker its most serious disease. The page also gives its range, size, leaves and wood.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The facts here come from US federal and university publications. It does not identify trees from descriptions or photos and does not say what should be done with any tree. The comparison table is in the family overview, tree species in the agency records.

At a glance

ItemWhat the source records
Scientific nameJuglans cinerea L., walnut family (Juglandaceae)
Other namesWhite walnut, oilnut (Silvics, FEIS); lemon nut (NC State Extension)
Mature size, SilvicsRarely more than 30 m (100 ft) tall and 91 cm (36 in) in diameter; average trees 12 to 18 m (40 to 60 ft) tall and 30 to 61 cm (12 to 24 in) in diameter
Life span, SilvicsUsually not longer than 75 years
Nut, SilvicsOblong-ovoid, pointed, 3.8 to 5.5 cm (1.5 to 2.2 in) long, ripe in September and October
Most serious diseaseButternut canker (Silvics, FEIS)

Native range

The Silvics of North America chapter finds butternut from southeastern New Brunswick through New England except northwest Maine and Cape Cod. The range runs south to northern New Jersey, western Maryland, Virginia, North Carolina, northwestern South Carolina, northern Georgia, northern Alabama, northern Mississippi and Arkansas. Westward it reaches central Iowa and central Minnesota. It also grows in Wisconsin, Michigan and northeast into Ontario and Quebec.

The USDA Fire Effects Information System (FEIS) draws the western edge at eastern Iowa and southeastern Minnesota, with disjunct populations in Wisconsin and Michigan, and notes that butternut is cultivated in Hawaii. Both sources call butternut an uncommon tree, with a declining frequency, through most of its range. Its range overlaps black walnut, but butternut occurs farther north and not as far south.

Size and form

Silvics calls butternut a small to medium-sized tree that grows fast, especially as a seedling, and is short lived. It is intolerant of shade and does not survive under shade from above. NC State Extension gives 40 to 60 feet tall and as wide, with an open, rounded, spreading crown. The trunk is short, forked or crooked. Virginia Tech Dendrology gives up to 60 feet, also with a forked or crooked trunk and wide-spreading branches.

NC State Extension says butternut grows best along streambanks, on slopes and on rock ledges. Silvics adds that it grows better than black walnut on dry, rocky soils, especially those of limestone origin, and is widely considered more winter-hardy.

Leaves, bark and twigs

Virginia Tech gives alternate, pinnately compound leaves 15 to 25 inches long with 11 to 17 oblong-lanceolate leaflets, green above and paler below. NC State Extension gives leaves of 10 to 20 inches with 11 to 19 leaflets, each 2 to 5 inches long. The two sources print different leaf lengths and leaflet counts.

Virginia Tech describes the bark as light, ashy gray, with flat-topped, shiny ridges that develop diamond-shaped patterns. The twig is stout, yellow-brown to gray, with a chambered pith that is very dark brown. Leaf scars are three-lobed, resembling a monkey face, with a tuft of hairs above the scar resembling an eyebrow.

Look-alikes

Virginia Tech lists black walnut, bitternut hickory, tree-of-heaven and English walnut as look-alikes. The FEIS says butternut and black walnut are very similar but differ in two ways. Butternut has a pad of small dense hairs crosswise along the upper margin of old leaf scars, which black walnut lacks. The underside of butternut leaflets is densely covered with stellate hairs, while black walnut's leaflet hairs are almost inconspicuous. NC State Extension separates black walnut by fruits that stain hands and a strong odor from the stem and crushed leaves. The FEIS records hybrids with English walnut and Japanese walnut, and calls reports of crosses with black walnut unsubstantiated.

Flowers and nuts

Silvics dates flowering from April to June depending on location. The species is monoecious, with slender male catkins and short female spikes on the current year's shoots. The nut matures in September and October of the year of pollination, singly or in clusters of 2 to 5, with a sweet, oily, edible kernel in an indehiscent husk covered in glandular hairs. Commercial seed-bearing age begins at about 20 years and is best from 30 to 60 years, with good crops every 2 to 3 years.

Like other members of the walnut family, butternut produces juglone, which Silvics calls selectively toxic to associated vegetation. The greatest concentrations are in root tissue and fruit husks. NC State Extension puts the effect usually out to the drip line. The guide to juglone and black walnut covers the compound further.

Wood

Silvics puts more value on butternut's nuts than on its lumber. The soft, coarse-grained wood works, stains and finishes well, and small amounts go into cabinetwork, furniture and novelties. The sweet nuts are prized as food by people and animals.

Insects and diseases in the agency records

Silvics lists insects commonly found on butternut: wood borers, defoliators, nut weevils, lace bugs, husk flies and bark beetles. The most serious insect pest it names is the butternut curculio (Conotrachelus juglandis), which injures young stems and fruit.

  • Butternut canker. Silvics and the FEIS call butternut decline, or butternut canker, the most serious disease. Silvics says the disease is reported to have eliminated butternut from North and South Carolina. The FEIS says it is reported to have almost eliminated it there.
  • Bunch disease. Silvics names a mycoplasma-like organism as the thought cause of a yellow witches' broom, and butternut seems more susceptible than black walnut.
  • Birds. Silvics reports the common grackle destroying immature fruit.
  • Fire and storms. Silvics calls butternut very susceptible to fire damage and subject to frequent storm damage.

Status

The FEIS review lists the federal legal status of butternut in the United States as no special status. NC State Extension reports the tree placed on the endangered species list in some parts of the United States and has been all but eliminated in some southern states.

Sources