ArbNation Join free

Butternut in Canada (Juglans cinerea) under the Species at Risk Act

Butternut is listed as Endangered on Schedule 1 of the federal Species at Risk Act, and Ontario lists it as endangered. COSEWIC's 2017 report and three Ontario government pages give the range, the canker losses and the protections.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. It also does not identify trees from descriptions or photos and does not say what should be done with any tree. The comparison table is in the family overview, tree species in the agency records.

At a glance

ItemWhat the source records
COSEWIC statusEndangered. Designated November 2003, re-examined and confirmed April 2017.
Federal listingListed as federally Endangered and protected under Schedule 1 of the Species at Risk Act
OntarioEndangered on the Species at Risk in Ontario List (O. Reg. 230/08)
QuebecNot protected through provincial legislation (COSEWIC)
New BrunswickListed under the New Brunswick Species at Risk Act with no prohibitions in place (COSEWIC)
Main threatButternut canker, a fungal disease

The federal assessment

The 2017 COSEWIC assessment and status report on butternut, published on the Government of Canada species at risk public registry, gives the status as Endangered. It meets criterion A2ae+3e+4ae, based on the decline in mature individuals. COSEWIC calls butternut one of only two walnut species native to Canada. The report records it as listed as federally Endangered and protected under Schedule 1 of the Species at Risk Act.

The report puts the native Canadian range in southern Ontario, southern Quebec and portions of western and southern New Brunswick. In Ontario and Quebec the range forms a band of about 1,100 km from Windsor to Quebec City. The extent of occurrence is 266,920 km2 if based only on definitely native occurrences, and 399,440 km2 if all observation records are counted. Conservation data centres compiled records of 863 separate occurrences.

Canker losses in the report

COSEWIC names butternut canker as the main threat. The disease has infected almost all Canadian trees and is causing rapid mortality. Ontario monitoring data from 1,221 trees at 60 sites show a 99.7% infection rate, with annualized mortality of 5.43% from 2008 to 2014-2015.

The report estimates generation time at 45 years. The decline from pre-canker levels is probably already well over 50%, and the disease is projected to cause a near 100% decline from the pre-canker population within one generation. Other threats it lists are habitat conversion, wood harvesting, hybridization with Japanese walnut, white-tailed deer and climate change.

Ontario pages

The Ontario government species at risk page for butternut says the tree was already assessed as endangered when the Endangered Species Act, 2007 took effect in 2008, and a reassessment in November 2017 confirmed the status. It defines endangered as living in the wild in Ontario but facing imminent extinction or extirpation. The page, updated January 12, 2026, reports that surveys in eastern Ontario show most trees infected, and that some infected trees live for many years, which experts hope indicates resistance.

Ontario's species at risk page gives a medium-sized tree that can reach up to 30 m, with grey, smooth bark on younger trees that becomes ridged with age. Its compound leaves have 11 to 17 leaflets, each nine to 15 centimetres long. The fruit is a large nut with a single seed inside a light green, sticky, fuzzy husk. In Canada it occurs in Ontario, Quebec and New Brunswick, and in Ontario from the southwest north to the Bruce Peninsula, south of the Canadian Shield.

The Ontario butternut tree page, updated July 30, 2026, describes a fast-growing, short-lived tree of less than 80 years. It puts butternut scattered across most mixed deciduous forests in southern Ontario except the Bruce Peninsula and Manitoulin Island. The two Ontario pages therefore differ on the Bruce Peninsula. The tree page adds that butternut is often mistaken for black walnut, and that hybrids with non-native walnuts planted for their nuts can be difficult to identify.

The same tree page puts butternut under Ontario's Species Conservation Act, with registration or a permit that may be required for activities affecting protected species. The species at risk page still names the Endangered Species Act, 2007. The assessment guidelines page, updated March 30, 2026, reports that the Endangered Species Act, 2007 and its regulations have been repealed and the Species Conservation Act, 2025 and its regulations are in force.

Ontario health assessment categories

The Ontario butternut assessment guidelines describe how a Butternut Health Expert classifies each tree into one of three categories under O. Reg. 830/21. The classification bears on how the conditional exemption for butternut applies and on species conservation charges set by O. Reg. 829/21.

  • Category 1. The tree is affected by butternut canker to such an advanced degree that retaining it would not support protection or recovery of butternut in the area.
  • Category 2. The tree is not affected, or is affected less than a Category 1 tree, and retaining it could support protection or recovery in the area.
  • Category 3. The tree may be useful in determining sources of resistance to butternut canker.

The guidelines page says butternut is threatened by harvesting, habitat loss, hybridization with exotic walnut species, other diseases, insects and exotic pests, and that these other causes would not likely cause declines alone but weaken the tree to canker. It describes itself as general guidance only, with the legislation prevailing if the two disagree.

Related pages

The Ontario tree page points to eLaws and the Species Conservation Registry for the Act. The disease has its own page, and the tree is described for the United States on the butternut species page.

Sources