Street tree survival and lifespan studies compared: Roman and Scatena, Hilbert, Bigelow
Annual street tree survival runs from 94.9 to 96.5 percent in one meta-analysis, and annual mortality has a median of 2.5 to 2.6 percent for street trees in a 56-study review.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Three papers put numbers on how long street trees last: a 2011 meta-analysis, a 2019 literature review and a 2024 Philadelphia monitoring study. Each measures a different thing.
| Study | Method | Reported figure |
|---|---|---|
| Roman and Scatena, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, 2011 | Meta-analysis of 16 earlier studies, plus a Philadelphia case study of trees 2 to 10 years after planting | Annual survival 94.9 to 96.5 percent; population half-life 13 to 20 years; mean life expectancy 19 to 28 years |
| Hilbert, Roman, Koeser, Vogt and van Doorn, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, September 2019 | Literature review of 56 studies of street, yard and park trees | Annual mortality 0.6 to 68.5 percent for planting cohorts and 0 to 30 percent for repeated inventories |
| Bigelow and colleagues, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, 2024 | 103 permanent plots in Philadelphia, followed for 6 years | Annual mortality 3.68 percent; live trees fell from 2,657 to 2,542, a 4.33 percent decline |
The 2011 meta-analysis
Roman and Scatena compiled survivorship rates from 16 earlier studies. They found annual survival rates for individual studies mostly above 91.0 percent. For a pooled subset they regressed the natural log of cumulative survivorship against time since planting. The result was an annual survival rate of 94.9 to 96.5 percent and a population half-life of 13 to 20 years.
Estimated mean life expectancy came out at 19 to 28 years. The authors call that considerably longer than the 7-year or 13-year average street tree lifespan reported in earlier studies. Their Philadelphia case study gave similar rates and lifespans. They encourage demographic methods and repeat monitoring every few years.
The 2019 literature review
Hilbert and colleagues reviewed 56 studies of trees along streets, in yards and in landscaped parks. They counted both trees found dead and trees removed as mortality. Quartiles of annual mortality, with the range where studies gave a range:
| Group | Median | First / third quartile |
|---|---|---|
| Repeated inventories of mixed-age trees (18 studies) | 2.28 to 2.59 | 1.57 to 1.59 / 3.02 to 3.30 |
| Planting cohorts, all (21) | 4.40 to 6.48 | 2.81 to 3.76 / 7.08 to 9.33 |
| Planting cohorts, establishment, up to 5 years (16) | 6.60 to 7.00 | 3.96 to 5.02 / 9.33 to 10.43 |
| Planting cohorts, after establishment (8) | 2.76 to 3.76 | 1.50 to 1.53 / 3.81 to 4.73 |
| Street trees (20) | 2.54 to 2.61 | 1.59 to 1.60 / 4.60 to 5.45 |
| Mixed locations (14) | 4.30 to 5.10 | 2.22 to 2.99 / 6.77 to 7.49 |
| Residential yards (3) | 4.60 | 4.21 / 5.60 |
| Parks (2) | 2.19 | 1.74 / 2.65 |
Ranges appear where a study gave several years or several mortality values. The lower figure comes from the low end of each study's range and the upper from the high end. In planting cohorts, annual mortality tended to be highest in the first five years. The review names taxa (15 articles), tree size or age (13) and site characteristics (12) as the most cited biophysical factors. It names stewardship, maintenance and vandalism (15 articles) as the most cited human factors.
The 2024 Philadelphia study
Bigelow and colleagues tracked street trees on 103 randomly located permanent plots over 6 years. Mortality followed a Type III curve, with the highest annual rates in the smallest size class. Survival was linked to crown vigor, expected mature stature, drought tolerance, site type, land use, impervious surface within 15 m, demolition on the parcel, and neighbourhood poverty, vacancy and renter share. The authors point to small trees, sidewalk cut-outs, commercial or industrial areas and demolition sites as places where management could raise survival.
Why the figures differ
- Roman and Scatena report survival. Hilbert and colleagues and Bigelow and colleagues report mortality. A mortality of 3.68 percent is a survival of 96.32 percent, inside the 2011 range.
- The 2019 review counts removals as mortality, as almost all of the studies it covers do.
- Cohort studies follow trees planted together, and inventory studies follow trees of mixed age already standing. The review reports the two separately.
- Philadelphia appears in the 2011 and 2024 papers with different designs: trees 2 to 10 years after planting in one, permanent plots followed for 6 years in the other.
The causes of these losses have their own guide.
Sources
- Roman and Scatena, Street tree survival rates: meta-analysis of previous studies and application to a field survey in Philadelphia, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, 2011, abstract on University of Pennsylvania Earth and Environmental Science, read October 16, 2026
- Bigelow, Fahey, Grabosky, Hallett, Henning, Johnson and Roman, Predictors of street tree survival in Philadelphia, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 94, 2024, USDA Forest Service Treesearch, read October 16, 2026
- Hilbert, Roman, Koeser, Vogt and van Doorn, Urban Tree Mortality: A Literature Review, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 45(5), September 2019, USDA Forest Service PDF, read October 16, 2026