Street tree tolerance lists: salt and drought ratings from Cornell, Utah State, Minnesota
Cornell prints a salt list and a 1 to 12 moisture chart, Utah State rates salt, drought and drainage on five levels, and Minnesota's stormwater table uses Yes, Limited and No.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Extension and agency tree lists rate the same stresses on different scales, so one tree can read differently from list to list. The three lists below are described as published, with their scales first.
| List | Stresses rated | Scale |
|---|---|---|
| Cornell Urban Horticulture Institute, Recommended Urban Trees (Bassuk and others) | Soil moisture, soil pH, shade, salt, structural soil use | Moisture on a 1 to 12 chart; pH in three bands; salt, shade and structural soil as lists |
| Utah State University Extension, TreeBrowser (245 trees) | Shade, salt, drought, poor drainage, alkalinity, transplanting ease | Low, Low-Medium, Medium, Medium-High, High |
| Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, tree species tolerance to stresses (53 entries) | Urban stress, soil texture, salt, anaerobic, alkali, vehicle exhaust and drought stress | Yes, Limited and No for salt; letter codes for the rest |
Cornell Recommended Urban Trees
Cornell's collection covers trees hardy to USDA Zone 6 or colder. Its moisture chart runs from 1 to 12. Numbers 1 to 3 mean occasionally saturated or very wet soil, 4 to 6 consistently moist and well drained, 7 to 9 occasional dry periods and 10 to 12 prolonged dry periods. Shading on the chart marks the conditions a tree survives reasonably well.
The salt entry refers only to a plant's observed tolerance or sensitivity to salt in the soil, not to spray. Cornell calls the information anecdotal and does not separate spray from soil. Heavy salt applications are damaging whatever the reported tolerance, and salt applied in late October, early November or April can harm trees.
The tree groupings section lists 36 trees observed to have some salt tolerance, among them red maple, river birch, hackberry, ginkgo, honeylocust, swamp white oak, bur oak, bald cypress and American elm. For soil pH it sorts trees into acid only (pin oak and bald cypress), acid to neutral (17 trees) and acid to alkaline, up to pH 8.0 (49 trees). Compaction appears through a list of 42 trees suitable for CU-Structural Soil, a patented mix of stone and soil that Cornell developed for trees under pavement.
Utah State TreeBrowser
Utah State Extension's TreeBrowser covers 245 native and introduced trees from Utah and the Intermountain West. Shade, salt, drought, poor drainage and alkalinity each use five levels, and ease of transplanting uses Low, Medium and High. Salt tolerance means tolerance to salt on above-ground surfaces, though it can indicate some tolerance to soil salinity. Drought tolerance covers low soil moisture, heat or low humidity. Poor drainage covers waterlogging, compaction or otherwise poorly oxygenated soil. Alkalinity means soil pH above 6.5 to 7.
The help page defines growth and size bands in the same way, for example medium height as 20 to 40 feet. It also notes that the typical life span of a good tree in a suburban neighbourhood is 30 to 50 years, while downtown trees may last only 5 to 10 years.
Minnesota stormwater table
The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency's table has seven columns: scientific name, common name, minimum zone hardiness, demonstrated tolerance to urban stresses, soil texture tolerance, salt tolerance and stress tolerance. Soil texture uses C for coarse, M for medium and F for fine. Stress uses A for anaerobic, L for alkali, V for vehicle exhaust and D for drought. A footnote says the urban stress column does not consider salt, which has its own column. The table carries no date of its own, and its footnotes credit Cornell's Bassuk and others (2009), Dirr (1998), the USDA Plants Database and the MPCA's 2024 stormwater plant guide.
| Tree | Urban stress and soil texture | Salt and stress codes |
|---|---|---|
| Red maple (Acer rubrum) | Urban stress Yes; soil CMF | Salt No; stress ALD |
| Swamp white oak (Quercus bicolor) | Urban stress Yes; soil CMF | Salt No; stress A |
| Littleleaf linden (Tilia cordata) | Urban stress Yes; soil CM | Salt No; stress D |
| Green ash (Fraxinus pennsylvanica) | Urban stress Yes; soil CMF | Salt Yes; stress ALD |
| Thornless common honeylocust (Gleditsia triacanthos var. inermis) | Urban stress Yes; soil MF | Salt Yes; stress LD |
| Ginkgo, male only (Ginkgo biloba) | Urban stress Yes; soil CM | Salt Yes; stress blank |
Where the lists disagree
Red maple and swamp white oak show the split. Cornell's grouping puts both among trees observed to have some salt tolerance. Minnesota rates both No for salt, though its footnotes credit Cornell's 2009 publication for the salt column. The scales differ: Cornell's list is a yes-or-no membership list, and Minnesota's column can read Yes, Limited or No. The tables give no reason for the difference.
These lists describe ratings at species or cultivar level. Cornell says its lists are a guide to selection and that site assessment comes first. Damage from salt and drought is described in road salt injury and drought injury.
Sources
- Cornell University Urban Horticulture Institute, Recommended Urban Trees: introduction and use, woodyplants.cals.cornell.edu, read October 16, 2026
- Cornell University Urban Horticulture Institute, Recommended Urban Trees, trees grouped by site or planting conditions (PDF), read October 16, 2026
- Utah State University Extension, TreeBrowser help, read October 16, 2026
- Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, Minnesota Stormwater Manual, tree species list: tolerance to stresses, read October 16, 2026