Strength loss formulas compared: Wagener, Smiley and Fraedrich, Coder and the t/R rule
Four published rules turn the thickness of sound wood around a decayed trunk into a failure threshold: Wagener at 33 percent, Smiley and Fraedrich at 33 percent, Coder at 20 to 44 percent, and Mattheck and Breloer at t/R below 0.3.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page draws on three peer-reviewed papers. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one.
The four rules
| Rule | Basis | Threshold as published |
|---|---|---|
| Wagener (1963) | Hollow diameter against trunk diameter, cubed. Adapted from the engineers' pipe formula. | Over 33 percent loss |
| Coder (1989) | The engineers' formula itself, with the fourth power. | Caution zone 20 to 44 percent. Hazard above 44 percent. |
| Smiley and Fraedrich (1992) | The Wagener form, with a term for wood missing at a cavity opening. | 33 percent loss |
| Mattheck and Breloer (1998) | Ratio of sound wall thickness t to trunk radius R. Built on the buckling strength of a cylinder. | t/R below 0.3 |
Smiley and Fraedrich, in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in 1992, trace the first rule to a 1963 US Forest Service paper by Wagener on tree failure in campgrounds, the first attempt to put a number on a failure factor. The engineers' formula, strength loss as the fourth power of the hollow-to-trunk diameter ratio, compares pipes. Wagener changed the power to three to allow for the irregular shape of trees. Coder used the original fourth-power form. A tree-care company's research laboratory added the cavity-opening term.
What the formulas measure
Kane and Ryan of the University of Massachusetts, writing in the same journal in 2004, say the first three rules are often called strength loss formulas but actually estimate the loss in stem moment of inertia. They treat the stem and the decay as concentric circles. That ignores the force on the tree and the strength of its wood. Only the amount of decay and the stem diameter go in.
The fourth rule gives no such loss figure. Mattheck and Breloer set a thickness threshold from broken and standing trees, and treat cavities under one third of the circumference as having no effect on failure. At t/R of 0.3, they put the loss at about 33 percent.
Two tests
Smiley and Fraedrich measured oaks around Charlotte, North Carolina, after Hurricane Hugo's 90 mph winds. Fifty-four broken oaks averaged 33 percent strength loss, with 52 showing internal decay. The 31 standing decayed trees they used for comparison averaged 23 percent, and four of them passed 33 percent. At a 33 percent threshold, the formula would have flagged half the failures and 12 percent of the surviving decayed trees. They found no threshold that came close to the ideal, and say a 20 to 25 percent threshold may suit weak wood, decay in crotches, dense crowns, leans or exposed sites.
Kane and Ryan compared each formula with the loss they worked out for 19 real cross-sections using the parallel axis theorem, an engineering method that needs an image of the cross-section. They found:
- Wagener ran 9.6 percent below the actual loss on average, and Coder 15.1 percent below. Both gaps were significant.
- Smiley and Fraedrich ran 0.5 percent below, not a significant gap.
- At the thresholds, Wagener underestimated 3 of 19 trees (16 percent). Coder's caution threshold underestimated 8 (42 percent). Smiley and Fraedrich misclassified 4 (21 percent), 3 low and 1 high.
- The t/R ratio overestimated 3 trees (16 percent) and underestimated none.
The authors write that the formulas must be used as only one of several tools in tree risk assessment. Several trees with high computed losses did not look near failure by visual assessment. They put this down in part to woodlot branching form and shelter from neighbouring trees.
The mechanics behind t/R
A 2017 paper in Royal Society Open Science by Huang and colleagues models hollow trunks. For Taiwan red cypress it splits failure by t/R into Brazier buckling below 0.06, tangential cracking from 0.06 to 0.27, and conventional bending above 0.27. For the four species it modelled, the cracking limit fell between 0.21 and 0.27. The authors call that remarkable agreement with Mattheck and Breloer's field finding, from more than 1,000 broken and standing trees, that most of the broken trees had t/R below 0.3. A hollow trunk at 0.3 keeps 76 percent of a solid trunk's bending strength.
Sources
- Smiley and Fraedrich, Determining Strength Loss from Decay, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 18(4), July 1992, read October 16, 2026
- Kane and Ryan, The Accuracy of Formulas Used to Assess Strength Loss Due to Decay in Trees, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 30(6), November 2004, read October 16, 2026
- Huang, Hsu, Lee and Juang, Failure mechanism of hollow tree trunks due to cross-sectional flattening, Royal Society Open Science 4(4), 2017, read October 16, 2026