Structural soil, soil cells and suspended pavement: what Cornell, Smiley and the US EPA report
Cornell's structural soil is a stone lattice with clay loam in the voids. A 2006 trial under pavement found the most tree growth and health in noncompacted soil under a suspended slab.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Three documents cover the types: a 1998 Cornell paper by Bassuk, Grabosky, Trowbridge and Urban, a 2006 field trial by Smiley and co-authors in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, and the US Environmental Protection Agency's Stormwater to Street Trees. The volume figures that sit under these systems are on tree pit soil volume.
The problem under pavement
The Cornell paper opens with the lack of an adequate volume of soil for tree roots. Soil under pavement is compacted to carry loads, which stops roots. It estimates that an urban tree in this setting lives an average of 7 to 10 years, where 50 or more could be expected with better soil. Smiley and co-authors, citing Craul, call usable soil the most limiting factor for urban tree growth.
Three types
| Type | What it is | Load |
|---|---|---|
| Structural soil | Compactable stone with clay loam and a little hydrogel | Compacted to meet pavement base requirements |
| Suspended pavement | Slab held on footers or pillars over noncompacted soil | Slab engineered for expected loads |
| Structural cells | Cell network that carries the surface and leaves the soil below uncompacted | Engineered, up to vehicular loads |
Structural soil
The Cornell paper describes gap-graded crushed stone, clay loam and a hydrogel stabiliser, mixed by weight at 100 stone, 20 loam and 0.03 hydrogel. The stone is narrowly graded from 3/4 to 1 1/2 inch, angular, with no fines. The mix is compacted to not less than 95 percent Proctor density with a California Bearing Ratio above 40, in 6 inch lifts. The paper prefers 36 inches of depth and encourages a 24 inch minimum rooting zone.
For continuous street planting, it calls a trench 8 feet wide and 3 feet deep, parallel to the curb, minimally adequate. It lists the costs: deeper excavation, drainage and the mix itself. It suggests the system suits new construction and infrastructure repair, where deep excavation is already paid for.
The EPA puts structural soils at 70 to 80 percent angular gravel and 20 to 30 percent clay loam, with a small amount of hydrogel and 20 to 25 percent void space. A depth of 24 to 36 inches is considered optimal. Its design notes: the high volume of rock may stop a large tree reaching full size, large volumes may be needed because the mixes are only 20 to 30 percent soil, and the stone type shifts pH.
The 2006 field trial
Smiley, Calfee, Fraedrich and Smiley planted snowgoose cherry and Bosque lacebark elm into 5.4 m3 (189 ft3) of medium under concrete. Five treatments were tested: compacted soil, a gravel and soil mixture, a manufactured aggregate alone, that aggregate with soil, and noncompacted soil under a suspended slab. After 14 months, noncompacted soil gave more trunk diameter growth than the two aggregate treatments, higher chlorophyll readings than all others, and more twig growth, shared with the gravel and soil mix.
The authors write that suspended pavement over noncompacted soil gave the most growth and health. They add that structural soils hold roughly 20 percent soil by volume, while suspended pavement can hold nearly 100 percent noncompacted. The slab must be engineered for loads and may need more reinforcement and footers than pavement over structural soil. The trial covers 14 months and two species, and the authors note species differences in response.
Suspended pavement and structural cells, per the EPA
The EPA says a network of pillars, piles or structural cells supports the surface and leaves the soil below uncompacted. Depending on design, it can carry varying surface loads, including vehicles. The EPA cites the 2006 trial: trees in suspended pavement systems had better colour, more root growth and grew faster and larger than most other treatments, including structural soil. It says contiguous suspended areas are needed to manage runoff, not just a few cells.
Sources
- Bassuk, Grabosky, Trowbridge and Urban, Structural Soil: An Innovative Medium Under Pavement That Improves Street Tree Vigor, ASLA Annual Meeting Proceedings 1998, via USFS Urban Forestry South, read October 15, 2026
- Smiley, Calfee, Fraedrich and Smiley, Comparison of Structural and Noncompacted Soils for Trees Surrounded by Pavement, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 32(4), 2006, read October 15, 2026
- US Environmental Protection Agency, Stormwater to Street Trees: Engineering Urban Forests for Stormwater Management, read October 15, 2026