ArbNation Join free

Subcontract climbers injured on a job: who the boards treat as the employer

WorkSafeBC says a contractor who supplies only labour would likely be the hirer's worker. A Minnesota appeals court held a general contractor liable for an uninsured subcontractor's hurt employee.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The sources are WorkSafeBC in British Columbia, the Minnesota Workers' Compensation Court of Appeals and two GOV.UK pages for Great Britain.

British Columbia: WorkSafeBC

WorkSafeBC states that some contractors may be a business's workers. The business is then their employer and pays premiums for their coverage. A contractor is a worker if the contractor does not operate as an independent business.

Contractor likely a workerContractor likely an independent business
Supplies only labourHas multiple contracts with different clients
Supplies labour and minor materials such as nails, drywall tape or puttyAdvertises and provides services to the public
Works regular hours on an ongoing basisProvides major equipment of their own

WorkSafeBC says a hirer of a registered contractor who is not paying premiums could be liable for premiums on the work done. It recommends a clearance letter before and after services, to confirm a business is registered and paying.

It also covers personal coverage. A proprietor or partner may be registered for their workers but have declined Personal Coverage for themselves. WorkSafeBC states that such a person is not covered under the Workers Compensation Act as a worker, so the hirer could face a lawsuit after a workplace accident. Privacy law stops WorkSafeBC saying whether someone bought it. The hirer may request proof of purchase from the contractor.

Minnesota: Barron v. Szulim and Paul Wagner Homes

The Minnesota Workers' Compensation Court of Appeals decided this case on August 15, 2007. It involved a carpenter, not a climber, but it addresses a hurt worker, an uninsured subcontractor and an uninsured general contractor.

The carpenter answered a newspaper ad and was hired by a subcontractor who framed houses for the general contractor. He was paid an hourly wage with no taxes withheld and received a 1099. The subcontractor's insurance certificate did not include workers' compensation. In August 2004 the carpenter fell from scaffolding and dislocated an ankle.

The court held these points:

  • The carpenter was the subcontractor's employee, not an independent contractor or partner.
  • Minnesota Statutes section 176.042 presumes construction workers who might otherwise be independent contractors are employees. The employer escapes the presumption only by proving all nine listed conditions, which the court found were not met.
  • The record showed the subcontractor operated his own business and filed as a sole proprietor. Section 176.042 subdivision 1 does not govern his relationship to the general contractor.
  • The general contractor is liable for benefits under section 176.215, subdivision 1, and holds a right of subrogation against the subcontractor.
  • The 65 percent penalty under section 176.183 falls on the uninsured employer, which is the subcontractor, not the general contractor.

Great Britain: GOV.UK employment status pages

GOV.UK states that a person is self-employed if running a business for themselves and taking responsibility for its success or failure. Self-employed people are not paid through PAYE and do not have an employee's rights. They do have protection of their health and safety.

HMRC may regard someone as self-employed for tax even when employment law gives a different status. A person is probably self-employed if self-employed for tax and most of six points hold. They bid or quote for work and have no direct supervision. They invoice, pay their own National Insurance and tax, get no holiday or sick pay, and work under a contract that uses terms such as independent contractor. A contractor can be self-employed, have the status of a worker, or have the status of an employee if working for a client and employed by an agency.

The HMRC Check Employment Status for Tax tool gives HMRC's view for tax and National Insurance. Both pages deal with tax and employment rights. Injury cover is outside what they print.

Claim contacts are listed in the guides to US state workers' compensation contacts and workers' compensation for sole owners.

Sources