Summer branch drop: sudden limb failure in calm weather, from UK and US sources
Summer branch drop is the failure of a large limb on a mature tree in summer, with no obvious cause. Reports link it to calm weather, often after heavy rain ends a dry spell. The mechanism is not settled.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page draws on a UK government research note and two articles from tree journals. It is not training and does not teach the work. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one.
Definitions
The Department of the Environment Arboricultural Research Note of 1989, reviewed in 2007, describes apparently healthy and stable trees that occasionally shed large limbs in summer for no obvious reason. It says the pattern seems linked to certain weather patterns but the factors are not fully understood. The note says no definitive information is available. It records reports on oak, sweet chestnut, beech, ash, poplar, willow and horse chestnut, and, in the years before the note, frequent reports on English elm.
Richard Harris wrote in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in 1983 that at least 19 genera are susceptible. His abstract puts the failures in calm summer weather, on hot afternoons in Australia and the United States, and in England in calm weather after a heavy summer rain that ended increasing soil dryness. Jeremy Barrell, writing for the Institute of Chartered Foresters in 2014, gives a short definition: the failure of mature branches in summer with no obvious cause.
The limbs that fail
The research note describes branches that are long and drawn out, at least 10 cm (4 in) across, usually reaching to or past the edge of the crown. The break often falls some way from a fork. The wood at the break may look sound. Where a break is short, at right angles to the branch, it is often linked to decay, but sound-looking wood may hide an earlier internal weakness. Young, vigorous trees seem less prone, and over-mature trees may shed branches repeatedly.
Harris reports limbs up to a metre across. Breaks most often came 1 to 4 m from the attachment, less often at the attachment, and less often still at the main leader or the whole top. He found no outward sign tied to an impending failure.
Characteristics Barrell lists
Barrell says that in broad terms three primary characteristics must be present before an event is put down to summer branch drop. These are a large mature tree, a prolonged dry summer period, and no obvious defect or other cause. Secondary ones are failure soon after heavy rain, in the afternoon, in calm weather, suddenly, with a load crack. He adds that susceptible genera and large senescent trees with long, heavy, drawn-out branches on a horizontal attachment are known, and that the fracture is often across the branch some way out from the trunk. The same tree can drop more than one branch.
Explanations on record
All three authors say the cause is not proven. The research note says the many explanations lack conclusive evidence, and that reports rest on casual observation, so their subjectivity must be borne in mind. It sets out some theories. The first is an internal weakening, perhaps from winter storm damage or snow, with a later stress triggering the break. The second is water stress after a dry spell, which is known to crack conifer stems. The third is the added weight of fresh foliage, shoots and fruit carrying surface water after a shower, producing a turning moment.
Harris adds that limbs should be lighter on a hot afternoon because transpiration is high, which makes the failures puzzling. Water has been seen flowing from both sides of some fractures, and he raises xylem pressure and wetwood gas pressure, up to 60 psi (4.2 kg/cm2) in elm trunks, as possibilities. Barrell calls the mechanism poorly researched. He says risk is widely stated to be too low to justify precautions, yet anecdotal evidence points to more events than first thought.
The research note ends by saying the phenomenon can damage people and property, and that owners are advised to inspect routinely for visible defects. Harris lists measures for managers, among them warning people or roping off areas from late spring to early fall, and shortening and lightening long horizontal branches. Massaria disease of plane has its own page.
Sources
- Department of the Environment Arboricultural Advisory and Information Service, Arboriculture Research Note, Summer branch drop (Rushforth, amended Patch), 1989, reviewed 2007, hosted by the Arboricultural Association, read October 16, 2026
- Institute of Chartered Foresters, Summer Branch Drop: time for a rethink? (Jeremy Barrell), August 5, 2014, read October 16, 2026
- Harris, R.W., Summer Branch Drop, Arboriculture and Urban Forestry 9(4), 111-113, April 1983, read October 16, 2026