Origins of the t/R ratio: Wagener, Mattheck and the one-third rule
The t/R 0.3 line comes from Mattheck and Breloer's 1998 field data on over 1000 trees, and the 33 percent line from Wagener's 1963 pipe formula. They mark about the same decay, and tests found errors both ways.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The ratio compares the thickness of sound wall left in a decayed trunk (t) with the trunk radius (R). Three papers in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry and Royal Society Open Science trace where the number 0.3 came from and how well it held up.
Wagener 1963 and the pipe formula
Smiley and Fraedrich (1992) trace the first attempt to put a number on decay to a 1963 US Forest Service paper by Wagener, which documented tree failure in campgrounds. Wagener measured the diameter of the hollow (d) and the diameter of sound wood (D) and worked out a percent strength loss.
The formula began as an engineers' way to compare the strength of pipes, with the diameters raised to the fourth power. Wagener changed it to the third power to allow for irregular trees. Coder later used the original fourth-power form and set zones where strength loss was excessive, marginal or acceptable. The Bartlett Tree Research Laboratories added a term for wood missing at a cavity opening.
Kane and Ryan (2004) point out that these formulas do not measure strength. They estimate the loss in the stem's moment of inertia, its resistance to bending, and they model the stem and the decay as concentric circles.
Mattheck and Breloer 1998
Kane and Ryan describe the Mattheck and Breloer formula as a different kind. It rests on the buckling strength of a cylinder and was built empirically from failed and standing decayed trees. The formula returns no loss in moment of inertia. Its output is a threshold for action: a ratio of sound wood thickness to radius below 0.3.
The ratio allows for decay that sits off-centre. Mattheck and Breloer treat a cavity opening of less than one-third of the stem circumference as having no effect on failure. They noted that at a ratio of 0.3 the loss in moment of inertia is about 33 percent.
Huang and colleagues (2017) describe the field work behind it. Mattheck and Breloer examined over 1000 broken and standing hardwood and softwood trees in parks and along roads. Most of the broken trees had ratios below 0.3. Huang and colleagues say that this ratio has been used worldwide in visual tree assessment as an approximate upper critical limit for decayed trunks.
The thresholds side by side
| Formula | Threshold |
|---|---|
| Wagener (1963) | More than 33 percent loss in moment of inertia |
| Coder (1989) | 20 to 44 percent is the caution zone, over 44 percent a hazard |
| Smiley and Fraedrich (1992) | 33 percent |
| Mattheck and Breloer (1998) | Ratio of t to R below 0.3 |
Smiley and Fraedrich tested a 33 percent threshold on oaks that broke in Hurricane Hugo. It would have predicted 50 percent of the failures in 90 mph winds and called for removal of 12 percent of the decayed oaks that survived. They suggest 20 to 25 percent may be appropriate for trees with weak wood, decay in crotches, dense crowns, leans or exposed sites.
Test data and limits
Kane and Ryan compared the formulas with the actual loss on cross-sections of 19 trees. The ratio overestimated 3 of the 19 and underestimated none, using the thinnest wall on each stem. The overestimates were trees with small decay areas far off-centre. Two trees with cavity openings of about 22 percent of the circumference and thick walls were nearly underestimated.
The authors conclude that each formula is one tool among several. Each threshold assumes decay is the only defect and nothing else complicates the tree. They call for more study of the loss likely to cause failure.
Huang and colleagues modelled hollow trunks and found failure by splitting below a critical ratio of 0.27 for Taiwan red cypress and 0.21 to 0.27 across four species. They report that this is in close agreement with the field criterion, and that values may vary within and among species. At a ratio of 0.3 a hollow trunk keeps 76 percent of the bending strength of a solid one, and the model does not cover trunks with side openings or heart decay only.
Related pages are how reliably arborists judge decay and visual tree assessment in the German tradition.
Sources
- AUF, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, Kane and Ryan, The Accuracy of Formulas Used to Assess Strength Loss Due to Decay in Trees, 30(6), November 2004, pp. 347-356, read October 19, 2026
- Royal Society Open Science, Huang, Hsu, Lee and Juang, Failure mechanism of hollow tree trunks due to cross-sectional flattening, 4(4), April 12, 2017, read October 19, 2026
- AUF, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, Smiley and Fraedrich, Determining Strength Loss from Decay, 18(4), July 1992, pp. 201-204, read October 19, 2026