Topsoil, subsoil and imported soil: BS 3882, New York and Toronto specifications
BSI's BS 3882 covers topsoil that is moved or traded. New York City Parks and the City of Toronto each write their own soil requirements for tree planting, with figures in the documents below.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. The standard's clause text is not reproduced.
BS 3882:2015, Specification for topsoil
The BSI Knowledge catalogue lists BS 3882 as a current standard published April 30, 2015. It covers natural and manufactured topsoils that are moved or traded. Topsoils that remain in place are outside it. It sets requirements for multipurpose topsoil, and for specialist topsoils that have low fertility or are acidic or calcareous.
BSI describes the standard as setting out classification and composition, with characteristics such as texture, acidity and contaminants. It also covers sampling and analysis, and guidance on handling and site preparation so that soil is not degraded during excavation, delivery or placement.
The 2015 revision was aligned with BS 8601:2013, Specification for subsoil. BSI lists two changes: revised test parameters to reflect the increased use of composted green waste, and a new organic matter test that is less damaging to the environment and health, and cheaper. BSI names gardeners, builders, developers, engineers, architects, utilities and local authorities among the users.
New York City Parks tree planting standards
The New York City Department of Parks and Recreation published its Tree Planting Standards in April 2008. The backfill section calls for natural loam topsoil with humus added only, and no other soil type such as a sand or clay soil. Topsoil must be free from subsoil and come from an area never stripped. It is removed to a depth of one foot, or less if subsoil is met.
| Property | Requirement as printed |
|---|---|
| Organic matter | 8% to 12% by weight, by dry combustion with a multiplying factor of 2. It may not exceed 14%. |
| pH | 6.0 to 7.0 inclusive |
| Sieve analysis, wash test | Share passing: 100% at the 2 inch sieve, 95% to 100% at 1 inch, 90% to 100% at number 4, 30% to 60% at number 100. |
| Clay | Measured by ASTM D 422. The Engineer may reject topsoil where more than 60% of the material passing the number 100 sieve is clay. |
| Electrical conductivity | Less than 1500 mhos per cm by the saturated paste method. A higher level would indicate excessive salt content. |
A truckload with too much undesirable material is rejected, and no topsoil is delivered frozen or muddy. At final inspection, soil that does not appear to meet the specification means no final sign-off of the permit.
New York's standards give a separate section to a patented structural soil mix. Trees are not planted directly in it. It serves only as a base under impermeable surfaces. Its proportions by dry weight are 83% crushed stone and 17% clay loam, with hydrogel at 1 ounce per 200 pounds of stone. The clay loam in that mix is 2% to 5% organic matter, with pH 5.5 to 6.5 and a cation exchange capacity above 10.
New York's sample tree pit table assumes a pit depth of 2 feet. A pit 7 feet wide and 6 feet long has 42 square feet of surface and 84 cubic feet of soil. A continuous pit 7 feet wide and 100 feet long has 700 square feet and 1,400 cubic feet.
Toronto Green Standard, version 4
The City of Toronto's Toronto Green Standard version 4, ecology and biodiversity measures for city-owned facilities, was last modified July 25, 2025. Measure EC 1.1 sets the soil volume. Each separate new or retained tree planting area must have access to a minimum of 30 cubic metres of soil. The total is figured as 40% of the site area, divided by 66 square metres, times 30 cubic metres.
- Growing medium depth is no less than 800 mm and no more than 1600 mm, measured from the sidewalk surface.
- The minimum tree planting area width is 2.5 m on private property.
- Soil material is provided in compliance with the City of Toronto Construction Specification for Growing Medium. Boulevard mix type 3 is the standard mix for trees in hard surfaces.
- Soil quality testing may be required to find out whether existing soil areas are suitable for tree planting.
- Soil cells on City property follow the City's General Specification and Key Performance Criteria for Soil Cells.
Subsoil and imported soil in these documents
None of the three defines subsoil by layer or depth. BS 3882's catalogue page refers to a separate subsoil standard, BS 8601:2013. New York excludes subsoil from topsoil by name. Toronto points to its own growing medium specification instead of a named standard.
Sources
- BSI Knowledge, BS 3882:2015, Specification for topsoil, published April 30, 2015, catalogue page, read October 19, 2026
- City of New York Department of Parks and Recreation, Tree Planting Standards, April 2008, read October 19, 2026
- City of Toronto, Toronto Green Standard version 4, ecology and biodiversity, City agency, corporation and division owned facilities, modified July 25, 2025, read October 19, 2026