Tree funds, replacement fees and canopy targets: Portland, Toronto and Kelowna compared
Portland charges a fee in lieu into a tree fund, Toronto accepts cash at 120 percent of two years of planting and care, and Kelowna counts replacement trees by trunk size. Toronto also holds a 40 percent canopy target.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. Section numbers and editions are given for each city below. Other fee rules are in the tree replacement fees guide, and canopy goals for more cities are in the canopy targets guide.
The three cities side by side
| City | Fee and how it is set |
|---|---|
| Portland | Fee in lieu paid into the Tree Planting and Preservation Fund: the entire cost of establishing a new tree, with five years of maintenance |
| Toronto | Cash in lieu when planting on site is not physically possible: 120 percent of the cost of planting and two years of maintenance |
| Kelowna | Compensation to the City after unpermitted cutting: the cost of replacement trees, planted at the City's discretion |
Portland
Portland City Code section 11.10.070, amended effective January 3, 2025, allows a fee in lieu of planting or preserving trees where other parts of Title 11 allow it. The fee goes into the Tree Planting and Preservation Fund. It is set per tree as the entire cost of establishing a new tree under the City Administrator's standards. That cost covers the materials and labor to plant the tree and to maintain it for five years. The code says the fee is reviewed annually and adjusted if needed.
Section 11.15.010 describes the fund. Its purpose is to facilitate tree planting, and to see that mitigation or tree replacement happens when preservation or density standards are not met on a site. Money may be spent only on planting trees on public or private property, buying conservation easements that keep trees and canopy, and acquiring land to protect trees or groves. Contributions can come from in-lieu payments under tree permits, in-lieu payments for preservation or planting, restoration fees from enforcement against private trees, and voluntary contributions. The City Forester administers the fund in a separate account independent of the general fund, and any balance carries forward.
Section 11.50.040 sets the mitigation during development. An applicant must preserve and protect at least one third of the nonexempt trees 12 inches and larger in diameter on the site, and all nonexempt trees 20 inches and larger, unless mitigation is paid. Table 50-1 sets the mitigation.
| Size of tree removed | Required mitigation |
|---|---|
| At least 12 and less than 20 inches in diameter | The cost of two 2-inch replacement trees |
| 20 inches or more | The cost per inch of tree removed |
For the 12 to 20 inch band the code ties the fee to the per-inch restoration fee in the Title 11 fee schedule. For trees of 20 inches or more it uses the per-inch Planting and Establishment Fee in Lieu for development. A tree of 36 inches or more that is not preserved needs a posted notice and a notice to the neighbourhood association for at least 45 calendar days before the permit issues. Affordable housing projects approved for system development charge exemptions are exempt from the 20 inch mitigation, pro-rated to the share of approved dwelling units. For street trees and City trees of 6 inches or more, the code requires at least one replacement tree, and the mitigation may be paid into the fund.
Toronto
Toronto Municipal Code chapter 813, Trees, in the edition dated May 12, 2022, lets the General Manager of Parks, Forestry and Recreation attach conditions to permits. Section 813-10 allows the General Manager to require payment of the appraised value of any trees removed, plus removal and replacement costs, and a minimum of one replacement tree on site for each tree removed. Where planting is not physically possible on site, the General Manager may require planting at another suitable location or accept cash in lieu of 120 percent of the cost of planting and maintaining a tree for two years.
Section 813-20 repeats the cash in lieu figure for permits to destroy trees: 120 percent of the cost of replanting and maintaining the trees for two years. It also says replacement trees are planted and kept in good condition for two years, and that a replacement that does not survive or is in poor condition within two years is replaced. Section 813-10 allows a letter of credit as a tree protection guarantee, in an amount covering the appraised value of the tree to be protected, the removal costs and the replacement costs. It also allows a tree planting security deposit equal to two years of planting and maintenance, released when the trees are healthy two years after planting.
Section 813-29 sets the penalty for a conviction at a minimum fine of CA$500 and a maximum of CA$100,000 per tree, plus a special fine of CA$100,000. Section 813-12 applies to private trees of 30 centimetres or more measured at 1.4 metres above ground level. Section 813-20 extends the permit conditions to replacement trees under 30 centimetres.
Kelowna
Kelowna's Tree Protection Bylaw No. 8041 counts replacement trees by the size of the tree removed. Section 10.1 requires replacement within one growing season, and section 10.3 adds compensation to the City for the cost of replacement trees when a person cuts or damages a protected tree without a permit, on top of any penalty. Section 8.3 sets security at 125 percent of the value of the replacement trees and site restoration. Section 8.2 makes the security a cash deposit or an irrevocable letter of credit.
| Trunk diameter at breast height | Replacement trees |
|---|---|
| 0 to 151 mm (6 inches) | 2 |
| 152 to 304 mm (12 inches) | 3 |
| 305 to 456 mm (18 inches) | 4 |
| 457 to 609 mm (24 inches) | 6 |
| 610 mm and larger (36 inches) | 8 |
Under sections 8.4 and 8.5, the City returns 90 percent of the security after an inspection one year after planting if the replacement is in satisfactory health, and holds back 10 percent for another year. Section 13.1 of the bylaw sets the penalty at not more than CA$10,000.
Toronto canopy target
A City of Toronto report to the Infrastructure and Environment Committee, dated November 18, 2021, recommended that Council reaffirm a target of 40 percent tree canopy cover by 2050, to line up with the TransformTO Net Zero Strategy. The report traces the target to the Strategic Forest Management Plan, adopted by Council on February 20, 2013, which set a city-wide target of 40 percent. It says canopy grew from 26.6 to 28 percent to 28.4 to 31 percent over ten years. Portland's and Kelowna's codes in this comparison set no canopy percentage in the sections read.
Sources
- City of Portland, Oregon, City Code 11.10.070 Fees (amended effective January 3, 2025), read October 16, 2026
- City of Portland, Oregon, City Code 11.15.010 Tree Planting and Preservation Fund, read October 16, 2026
- City of Portland, Oregon, City Code 11.50.040 Tree Preservation Standards, Table 50-1, read October 16, 2026
- City of Toronto, Municipal Code chapter 813, Trees, edition dated May 12, 2022, read October 16, 2026
- City of Toronto, report on reaffirming the tree canopy target, dated November 18, 2021, read October 16, 2026
- City of Kelowna, Tree Protection Bylaw No. 8041, read October 16, 2026