Tree benefit per tree: annual benefits and costs in USFS Community Tree Guides by region
Three USDA Forest Service community tree guides put the average annual net benefit of a large public tree at US$113 in the Northeast, US$101 on the Northern California coast and US$47 in the Lower Midwest.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The Center for Urban Forest Research at the Forest Service's Pacific Southwest Research Station published community tree guides by US climate region. Each one models benefits and costs for a small, a medium and a large tree, over 40 years, from research in one reference city. The figures are model results, each tied to its region and report.
| Region and report | Model basis | Small, medium, large, conifer |
|---|---|---|
| Northeast, PSW-GTR-202 (August 2007) | Queens, New York City; 66 percent survival over 40 years; Kwanzan cherry, red maple, Japanese zelkova, eastern white pine | US$5 to US$9; US$36 to US$52; US$85 to US$113; US$21 to US$33 |
| Lower Midwest, PSW-GTR-219 (March 2009) | Indianapolis, Indiana; 50 percent survival over 40 years; eastern redbud, littleleaf linden, northern hackberry | US$4 to US$12; US$12 to US$24; US$47 to US$60; no conifer |
| Northern California Coast, PSW-GTR-228 (April 2010) | Berkeley, California; 55 percent survival over 40 years; camphor, cherry plum, velvet ash, Monterey pine | US$29 to US$41; US$42 to US$60; US$101 to US$122; US$142 to US$146 |
In the Northeast the high end of each range is a public tree. In the Lower Midwest and Northern California Coast guides it is a yard tree. The Lower Midwest guide puts its high figure on a yard tree opposite a west-facing wall.
Northeast
The Northeast guide gives average annual benefits of US$26 to US$30 for a small tree, US$69 to US$79 for a medium tree, US$125 to US$147 for a large tree and US$54 to US$56 for a conifer. Average annual care costs run from US$20 to US$40 per tree. It names energy savings and increased property value as the largest shares of benefits.
Planting is the greatest cost, annualized to US$10 to US$15 per tree per year, with pruning at US$4 to US$18. Summed over 40 years, net benefits for a large tree are US$4,261 for a yard tree opposite a west wall and US$4,531 for a public tree. The guide says public trees produce higher net benefits than private trees, mainly because of lower maintenance costs, and that the standard of care for public trees is often lower.
Lower Midwest
The Lower Midwest guide gives average annual benefits of US$15 to US$21 for a small tree, US$27 to US$35 for a medium tree and US$58 to US$73 for a large tree. Annual costs run from US$9 to US$24 per tree, with yard and public trees priced separately. Here the largest benefit shares are reduced stormwater runoff and higher property values.
A large public tree nets US$47 a year and a large yard tree on the west side of a house US$60. Twenty years after planting, the guide puts a large yard hackberry's environmental benefits alone at US$51 a year against US$8 in annual costs. Over 40 years, a large tree nets US$2,356 in a yard and US$1,809 in a public site.
Northern California Coast
The Northern California Coast guide gives average annual benefits of US$41 to US$51 for a small tree, US$57 to US$71 for a medium tree, US$115 to US$135 for a large tree and US$161 to US$176 for a conifer. Care costs run from US$10 to US$33 per tree a year. The guide says environmental benefits alone are greater than tree care costs. Over 40 years a large tree nets US$4,868 in a yard and US$4,034 in a public site, and a conifer US$5,855 and US$5,685.
What the guides share
- Benefits rise with mature tree size in all three guides.
- Each guide calls its approach a first-order or general approximation that can be adapted to local planting projects. Each is based on research in one reference city.
- Care costs and mortality rates come from a survey of municipal and commercial arborists.
- Benefits come from tree growth curves and models that account for regional climate, building characteristics, air pollutant concentrations and prices.
- The survival rates differ by region: 66, 50 and 55 percent over 40 years.
The Forest Service's Treesearch record for the Northern California Coast guide lists the report as informally refereed, published in 2010. Other benefit and canopy figures are in the i-Tree Eco guide and the urban tree carbon guide.
Sources
- USDA Forest Service Treesearch, Northern California coast community tree guide (McPherson and others, 2010), read October 16, 2026
- McPherson and others, Northern California Coast Community Tree Guide, PSW-GTR-228, April 2010, read October 16, 2026
- McPherson and others, Northeast Community Tree Guide, PSW-GTR-202, August 2007, read October 16, 2026
- Peper and others, Lower Midwest Community Tree Guide, PSW-GTR-219, March 2009, read October 16, 2026