ArbNation Join free

Tree-care claims against the research: 17 claims, the studies and the extension positions

Seventeen common tree-care claims, each set against Washington State University's Landscape Myths fact sheets, a University of Maryland extension page, and one Virginia planting trial.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The Landscape Myths series comes from Linda Chalker-Scott, an Extension Horticulturist at Washington State University's Puyallup Research and Extension Center. Each fact sheet takes one piece of advice in quotation marks and answers it. The sheets used here carry no date. The Maryland page carries an update date, and the trial is Day and Harris (2007).

Wording in the right-hand column is the named source's. Where a source hedges, the hedge stays.

Pruning and wounds

Claims about wound dressing, topping and pruning at transplant
ClaimWhat the source reports
Apply wound dressing after pruning to insure against insect or fungal invasionWSU calls it a myth. Dressings seal in moisture and decay, sometimes feed pathogens, prevent wound wood from forming, inhibit compartmentalization and eventually crack. They do not prevent entry of decay organisms or stop rot.
Wound dressing is justified for looksWSU: use "for aesthetic reasons" is never justified.
Oaks pruned where oak wilt occurs need treated woundsWSU: there may be some benefit for susceptible trees such as oaks in oak wilt areas. Research supporting that advice is "sketchy at best". A light fungicide or insecticide coat may be justifiable for spring or summer pruning. Dormant-season pruning greatly reduces the chance of infection, and WSU says wound treatment is then to be avoided.
Trees heal their woundsWSU: trees do not heal. They isolate damage with suberized, lignified wood, and callus grows from the wound edge toward the centre. The wound wood stays for the life of the tree.
Topping is like a haircut; the tree grows out of itWSU: plant scientists and arborists unanimously agree topping is unjustifiable. It reports sun damage, nutrient stress, insect attack and decay following incorrect pruning, and weakly attached epicormic branches that can fall.
Cutting back the top is the same as thinning to a lateralWSU separates them. A reduction cut goes back to a lateral at least one-third the diameter of the limb removed. Topping cuts to a point with no suitable lateral, so several shoots compete. WSU says reduction cuts suit decurrent or rounded trees and should never be used on excurrent or pyramidal ones except to remove multiple leaders.
Prune the crown of a transplant to match its lost rootsWSU calls it a myth: pruning when transplanting is not necessarily beneficial and may harm the tree. One study found water use rose after the first 5 to 6 weeks as new shoots grew. WSU adds that conflicting evidence exists and that short-term and long-term effects differ.

Staking

Claims about staking new trees
ClaimWhat the source reports
New trees should be staked firmly and securelyWSU calls it a myth. Its three "cardinal sins" are staking too high, too tightly and too long.
Staking helps a tree standWSU lists effects of improper staking: taller growth with less caliper, less trunk taper, uneven xylem, a smaller root system, rubbing and girdling injuries, and snapping in wind after stakes come off.
Every new tree needs stakesWSU: most containerized and correctly dug B&B trees do not need staking, and bare-root trees often do. Where stakes are used, its summary puts them no higher than two-thirds of tree height, flexible ties, and removal once roots establish, within one growing season at most.

Fertilizer

Claims about fertilizing, with the trial and two extension pages
ClaimWhat the source reports
Fertilize a tree when it is plantedMaryland Extension: not recommended at planting, since nitrogen then seems to suppress root growth. Day and Harris: fertilizer at recommended rates did not speed establishment of red maple or littleleaf linden over three years.
Fall fertilizing beats springDay and Harris found no evidence fall applications were more effective. Maryland lists fall, late October to early December, or late winter to early spring as the times if fertilizing, and names late summer and early fall as times not to.
Fertilizer fixes landscape problemsMaryland: fertilizer is not a remedy for landscape problems. It advises a soil test where a deficiency is suspected.
Spray large shade trees through the leavesMaryland: plants absorb some nutrients through leaves, but large shade trees are not fertilized this way. Very small trees can benefit if a soil test finds a deficiency, and the benefit lasts one season.
Feed a drought-stressed plantMaryland: never fertilize a drought-stressed plant. Proper watering of new plantings is the most important maintenance practice for establishment.
Yellow leaves mean the tree needs ironMaryland: iron chlorosis is a symptom of a soil pH problem, with iron less available above pH 7.0. Chelated iron corrects it temporarily and the symptoms return unless pH is corrected. It also lists poor drainage, over-watering, over-mulching, deep planting, root nematodes and root injury as other causes of chlorosis.
More nitrogen makes a healthier treeMaryland: excess nitrogen can produce long succulent shoots that attract sucking insects such as aphids, and high concentrations can burn roots.

Where the sources differ or stop short

The WSU sheets and the Maryland page name little of the research behind them; the wound sheet names Shigo and the Maryland page cites unnamed research studies. The Day and Harris paper lists its method and its numbers and says where its result may not hold. The trial covers two species on one soil in Virginia.

The WSU wound-dressing sheet allows one exception. It notes that many regions specify treated wounds on oaks in oak wilt areas, and it calls the supporting research sketchy.

Sources