Tree hazard signs by tree part: roots, base, trunk and crown in ISA and UC IPM sources
The ISA brochure Recognizing Tree Risk, two local-government copies of its 2011 edition and a University of California page list warning signs by tree part. The brochure says a professional arborist is best placed to judge a defect.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The ISA brochure Recognizing Tree Risk, version 02.2021, lists defects and a checklist of questions for tree owners. Cranbrook, British Columbia, and Volusia County, Florida, host copies of the 2011 edition, and the two copies carry the same text. The University of California Statewide IPM Program adds its own list. The table sorts the signs these sources name by the part of the tree.
Signs by tree part
| Tree part | Signs named | Where listed |
|---|---|---|
| Roots and soil | Cracks or separations in the soil, which may indicate soil heaving from excessive movement of the roots and are a warning sign for failure, especially if the tree is leaning. Fissures in the soil near the base. Roots broken, injured or damaged by lowering the soil level, paving, sidewalk repair or trenching. Wet areas with shallow soil in rural settings | ISA 2021 (defect B); UC IPM; 2011 edition in the local-government copies |
| Site changes | Construction, a change in soil level or the laying of lawns or pavement. Raised soil level. Trees in adjacent wooded areas removed. Adjacent trees fallen over or dead. Earlier failures in the area. An electrical line next to the tree | ISA 2021 checklist; 2011 edition; UC IPM (lowered soil grade photo) |
| Base | Mushrooms present at the base of or under the tree. Fungal fruiting bodies on bark or around the base. Cavities at the base of the trunk | ISA 2021 checklist; 2011 edition; UC IPM |
| Trunk | Loose bark. Cracks or splits in the trunk or where branches attach. Cavities or rotten wood along the trunk or in major branches. Cankers and wounds. A trunk that has developed unusually, with an asymmetric shape that may come from reaction wood. A strong lean, or a tree leaning near a target. Codominant stems, which can often be failure points. A forked trunk with branches and stems equal in size | ISA 2021 (defects C to F); 2011 edition; UC IPM |
| Crown | Large dead branches. Detached or hanging branches, or branches already fallen. Branches arising from one point on the trunk. Poor taper, where weight is concentrated near the end of a branch. Regrowth from topping or line clearance, or a tree that has been topped or heavily pruned. Leaves of an unusual yellow colour or smaller size | ISA 2021 (defects A, G); 2011 edition; UC IPM |
Judging how serious a sign is
The ISA brochure says all trees have the potential to fall and only a small number hit something or someone. It says evaluating how serious a defect is is best done by a professional arborist, and that a tree with a yes answer on the checklist should be examined by an ISA Certified Arborist. The 2011 edition uses the word target for the thing a failing tree could hit.
UC IPM says some hazards are difficult to detect, such as internal decay or unhealthy roots, and that a lightning strike can damage roots or internal tissue without visible damage outside. It adds that damaged or unhealthy trees are hazardous where they could injure people or damage property, and that in natural settings dead and declining trees bring benefits such as cavities for wildlife habitat.
The 2021 edition also names human-caused defects and links them to construction, grade changes, soil compaction and poor pruning. For professional rating methods, see tree risk assessment. For decay signs, see decay and cavities.
Sources
- International Society of Arboriculture, Recognizing Tree Risk, TreesAreGood brochure, v02.2021, read October 16, 2026
- University of California Statewide IPM Program, Recognizing Hazardous Trees, read October 16, 2026
- City of Cranbrook, British Columbia, Tree Risk, copy of the ISA brochure Recognizing Tree Risk, 2011 edition, read October 16, 2026
- Volusia County, Florida, Tree Risk, copy of the ISA brochure Recognizing Tree Risk, 2011 edition, read October 16, 2026