Tree inspection duty in US courts: Pennsylvania 2025 and Illinois 2012
Pennsylvania's Superior Court held in 2025 that a jury decides whether an owner was careless to let a tall oak stand above an urban highway. Illinois' Second District reached a duty to inspect a decaying cottonwood in 2012.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here. It restates two published appellate opinions: Harris v. Felouzis, 2025 PA Super 30, and Stackhouse v. Royce Realty and Management Corp., 2012 IL App (2d) 110602.
Harris v. Felouzis, Pennsylvania Superior Court, 2025
The Superior Court filed its opinion on February 10, 2025, in an appeal from Beaver County (No. 85 WDA 2023). The tree was a 110-year-old oak on a steep, wooded hillside above Kennedy Boulevard, a four-lane urban highway in Aliquippa. Its roots gave way and it fell onto a passing car. The owner had never hired an arborist or tree-trimmer. She had seen branches, trunks and limbs lying on the hillside for as long as she could recall.
An arborist called by the owner studied the fallen tree more than a year later. From its trunk rings he opined that the oak would have looked healthy among the other trees before it fell. The jury still found the owner negligent, and the court affirmed. The majority held that whether a landowner unreasonably permits a tree to grow in a dangerous condition near an urban highway is a factual question for the jury.
The majority gave these reasons:
- Restatement (Second) of Torts section 363(2), which the court quotes, covers a possessor of land in an urban area. That possessor is liable to people on a public highway for failing to use reasonable care against an unreasonable risk from the condition of nearby trees. The majority points out that the subsection never uses the word "defect".
- Barker v. Brown (Pa. Super. 1975, en banc) declined to apply the older rule that a landowner owes nothing for harm from a natural condition to land in or near a developed or residential area.
- The Third Circuit's 1931 decision in Brandywine Hundred Realty Co. v. Cotillo, which the majority calls highly persuasive, left the owner's negligence to the jury on similar facts.
- Relevant facts for the jury include the tree's location relative to the highway, its height, its age and the topography.
The owner also argued that the injured driver needed an expert arborist. The court held that argument waived. Her counsel had told the trial court he was "not suggesting" an expert was needed, and a new theory cannot be raised for the first time after trial.
Judge Bender dissented. His opinion would require some evidence that the tree was defective: "Sometimes, healthy trees fall, and no one is to blame." He wrote that the majority's approach incentivizes landowners to cut down healthy trees for no good reason. The majority answered that a visible defect is not a prerequisite for imputing knowledge of risk, because the risk of a tall old tree on a steep hillside above a busy road may be immediately apparent.
Stackhouse v. Royce Realty and Management Corp., Illinois Appellate Court, 2012
The Second District filed its opinion on June 4, 2012 (No. 2-11-0602), on an appeal from Lake County. A tree on a golf course next to a cart path fell and struck a person walking nearby. The jury found the defendants equally responsible. The manager appealed the denial of its motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict, arguing it owed no duty. The court affirmed.
The facts the opinion records:
- Two cottonwoods stood three to four feet apart. One fell across a cart path in 2006, and another failed in 2008.
- After the 2006 fall a person living next to the course told the golf course superintendent the wood inside the stump looked unusual, like sponge, and suggested it be checked. He said he would have someone check them. He did not contact an arborist.
- A certified arborist testified that both trees failed from excessive decay caused by the fungus Ganoderma applanatum, and that a 2006 inspection would have shown fruiting bodies on the trunk. He said the 2008 tree probably should have been removed given its location and target potential.
- The same arborist agreed that a tree can look biologically healthy while structurally unsound, and that the disease might have been externally apparent, at best, six months to a year before the failure.
- A professor in forest and wildlife ecology testified that the only sure way to find internal disease before a tree falls is a structural integrity analysis, using a resistograph, a drill, sound waves and a mallet.
The court applied the four duty factors from Krywin v. Chicago Transit Authority: the reasonable foreseeability of the injury, the likelihood of the injury, the magnitude of the burden of guarding against it, and the consequences of placing that burden on the defendant. It found a duty to inspect and remove the tree. The danger was foreseeable, the burden was not onerous, and the manager knew a tree of the same variety had fallen two years earlier because it was "rotten". The opinion also notes that duty based on knowledge covers constructive knowledge, which means facts that would make the danger known to an ordinary prudent person.
The opinion reviews earlier Illinois decisions. It quotes Mahurin v. Lockhart (1979). There a landowner in a residential or urban area had a duty to others outside the land. The duty was reasonable care against an unreasonable risk from defective or unsound trees, including trees of purely natural origin.
Where the two opinions meet
| Point | Pennsylvania, 2025 | Illinois, 2012 |
|---|---|---|
| Setting | Steep hillside above an urban highway | Golf course beside a cart path |
| Tree | 110-year-old oak, healthy-looking per the owner's arborist | Cottonwood with internal decay |
| What the owner knew | Limbs and trunks lay on the hillside regularly | A neighbouring cottonwood had fallen two years earlier |
| Question for the court | Was a visible defect required? | Was there a duty to inspect? |
| Result | Jury verdict affirmed over a dissent | Jury verdict affirmed |
Both courts affirmed a jury verdict, and each looked at the tree's setting and what the owner knew. For how the same question is handled elsewhere, see the guide to tree inspection duty in the UK and Ireland.
Sources
- Superior Court of Pennsylvania, Harris v. Felouzis, 2025 PA Super 30, No. 85 WDA 2023, opinion filed February 10, 2025, read October 16, 2026
- Superior Court of Pennsylvania, Harris v. Felouzis, 2025 PA Super 30, dissenting opinion filed February 10, 2025, read October 16, 2026
- Illinois Appellate Court, Second District, Stackhouse v. Royce Realty and Management Corp., 2012 IL App (2d) 110602, filed June 4, 2012, read October 16, 2026