ArbNation Join free

Tree quality categories A, B, C and U: how BS 5837 sorts trees for planning

BS 5837:2012 sorts surveyed trees into A (at least 40 years of life left), B (20 years), C (10 years or a stem under 150 mm) and U (early loss expected). Leeds treats A to C as trees to consider keeping.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

A tree survey to BS 5837 divides trees into one of four categories. The categories come from Table 1 of BS 5837:2012, Trees in relation to design, demolition and construction. BSI lists that edition, published on April 30, 2012, as current and under review. It replaced the 2005 edition, which is withdrawn.

The standard's own text is sold by BSI and is not reproduced here. What follows restates how the explanatory notes to a tree survey published on GOV.UK, and Leeds City Council's guidance note, describe the categories. The Arboricultural Association's workshop on the draft revision supplies the history and the proposed changes.

Where the letters came from

The Arboricultural Association traces the system through four editions. The 1980 code sorted trees A to D, from retain through to remove. The 2005 edition brought in a cascade chart with categories R, A, B and C. The 2012 edition changed them to U, A, B and C and added arboricultural impact assessments.

The four categories

The survey notes call Table 1 a cascade chart. A tree has to fall within a category's definition to qualify for it. Each of A, B and C has three sub-categories, numbered 1 to 3, which the notes say reflect arboricultural value, landscape value, and cultural or conservation value.

Category definitions as the survey notes restate them
Category and plan colourRemaining lifeWhat the category covers
A, high quality, greenAt least 40 yearsParticularly good examples of a species, including rare ones and the dominant trees of an avenue (A1). Trees or groups of particular visual importance (A2). Trees of significant conservation, historical or commemorative value, such as veteran or wood pasture trees (A3)
B, moderate quality, blueAt least 20 yearsTrees that might be A but are marked down for impaired condition, such as remediable defects, past management or storm damage (B1). Groups that rate higher together than alone (B2). Trees with material cultural or conservation value (B3)
C, low quality, greyAt least 10 years, or a young tree with a stem under 150 mmUnremarkable trees of very limited merit or such impaired condition that they do not qualify in higher categories (C1). Trees in groups with no greater collective value, or with low or short-term screening value (C2). Trees with no material conservation or cultural value (C3)
U, unsuitable for retention, no colour givenEarly loss expectedTrees with a serious irremediable structural defect, trees that are dead or in significant, immediate or irreversible decline, trees carrying pathogens that matter to neighbouring trees, and very poor trees suppressing better ones

The notes add that some category U trees have existing or potential conservation value that may make keeping them desirable. They also call the life-expectancy figures arbitrary and say real lives may vary.

What a category means in planning

The survey notes say category U trees are not considered in the planning process on arboricultural grounds, because they would be lost in the short term. Categories A, B and C are the trees that count as material considerations in development.

Leeds City Council states the rule in its guidance note: trees graded A to C should be considered for retention. The council says the BS 5837 default is no structures within the root protection areas of retained trees. Leeds also asks the impact assessment to separate trees removed for health reasons, category U, from trees removed to make way for the development.

The draft revision

The Arboricultural Association reported on the draft revision in September 2024. Howard Booth, chair of the revision panel, ran the workshop. The public consultation on the draft was open until October 16, 2024. BSI's page still lists the 2012 edition as the current one, so the draft categories below are proposals from the workshop write-up and not the standard in force.

  • A new Category V would hold veteran trees and ancient woodland. They sit inside Category A in the 2012 edition.
  • Category X would replace U. The Association says the new letter avoids a misreading of V as U. Category X features would usually be left out of the canopy cover assessment.
  • For everything else the cascade changes. The draft names high, moderate and low quality, with B as the starting point. The arboriculturist then decides on balance whether to raise a feature to A or lower it to C.
  • The draft gives lists of factors that point to high or low quality. The Association describes them as not prescriptive.
  • The Association notes that consultants may be pressed to rate trees down. The Association says the survey schedule should therefore record enough information to justify the category given.

The workshop also covers root protection areas in the draft. Veteran trees get a buffer of 15 times the stem diameter or 5 m beyond the crown spread, taking the larger figure. Ancient woodland gets 15 m. Mature Category A trees get a 15 times multiplier capped at 1,590 square metres, a 22.5 m radius. All other live features keep a 12 times multiplier, capped at 707 square metres, a 15 m radius.

Sources