ArbNation Join free

Tree risk assessment levels compared: limited visual, basic and advanced (TRAQ), Basic and Detailed (VALID), zoning (NTSG)

The District of Saanich numbers its levels 1 to 3, VALID trains for Basic, Detailed and Advanced assessment, and the UK's National Tree Safety Group splits checks from detailed inspection.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on five published sources. It is not training and does not teach the work. The methods behind these levels have their own guide.

The level names in one table

Level names by system
SystemLevelsWording from the source
District of Saanich, which requires ISA or ANSI standardsLevel 1 Limited Visual, Level 2 Basic, Level 3 AdvancedLevel 1 means walking or driving by the tree and recording limited information. A more detailed visual assessment with simple tools such as a mallet or probe is Level 2. Level 3 is a detailed assessment of the crown, stem or roots using advanced diagnostic techniques.
VALIDActive Assessment at Basic, Detailed and Advanced levelValidators trained for all three. A separate Basic Validator course is for people who spend a lot of time outside.
NTSG, United KingdomInformal observation, formal check, detailed inspectionChecks are brief visual observations. A detailed inspection is a closer assessment by a competent specialist, commonly prompted by a concern.

Levels in the Saanich specification

The District of Saanich in British Columbia sets out the ISA levels in its arborist report specifications for tree risk assessment. Saanich says assessments are conducted at different levels depending on circumstances. When Saanich Parks requests one, it specifies the level in the request. Assessments, recommendations and methods must be consistent with ISA or ANSI standards, and the assessor must be an ISA Certified, TRAQ qualified arborist.

Saanich describes Level 3 as detailed information about specific tree parts, defects, targets or site conditions. Its examples are an air spade for root flare inspection, resistance drilling and sonic tomography for internal decay, laboratory analysis of soil or disease, a pull test, and climbing to inspect part of the tree. For a Level 3 assessment, supporting evidence such as resistograph records or laboratory results is required.

The ISA book that covers them

The ISA store lists Best Management Practices: Tree Risk Assessment, Third Edition (2025), by Smiley, Matheny, Lilly, Kane, Klein and Brantley, at 118 pages. It replaces the second edition of 2017. Its topics include risk assessment concepts, scope of work, levels of tree risk assessment, assessing targets, sites, weather and trees, categorizing tree risk, risk mitigation and risk reporting. The store page names the level topic but does not print the level text, which sits in the book.

VALID levels

VALID's training page describes Validator Training as 16 hours of CPD or CEU tree risk training for arborists and tree managers. After it, trainees can carry out Active Assessment at Basic, Detailed and Advanced level. Basic Validator training is 6 hours, for people who spend a lot of time outside and may not know much about trees. They learn to recognise obvious tree risk features that a Validator should look at closely. The training dates listed for 2026 are in Australia.

Checks, inspection and zoning in the NTSG guidance

The National Tree Safety Group's guidance, Common sense risk management of trees (2024), divides tree safety assessment into informal and formal procedures. Informal observation is incidental to other activities. Formal procedures are usually planned, specified and proactive. They include drive-by and walk-over checks, inventories, and inspections at different levels.

The guidance uses check in the sense of the HSE's Sector Information Minute: a quick visual look by a competent person for obvious signs that a tree is likely to be unstable. Inspection is a formal procedure. Detailed inspection is more specialised than a visual check. It starts with a close visual assessment, usually from ground level, and in special cases covers soil and roots, aerial inspection of the upper trunk and crown, and diagnostic tools. It is described as time-consuming and relatively expensive, and in general reserved for individual trees of concern.

The NTSG defines zoning as dividing land around trees by levels of occupancy, to put resources where risk is likely to be highest. Two zones, high and low use, may be enough at some sites. Others may use more, and the guidance says more zones mean a more complex system.

Likelihood terms in the ISA method

A 2019 literature review in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, by Klein and co-authors, sets out the matrix steps behind the ISA method. Likelihood of failure runs improbable, possible, probable, imminent. Likelihood of impacting a target runs very low, low, medium, high. Combined, they give a likelihood that a tree will fail and hit a target: unlikely, somewhat likely, likely, very likely. A second matrix adds consequences, negligible, minor, significant or severe, for the risk rating. The review treats QTRA separately: its users assign probabilities to occupancy, failure and consequence to calculate a risk of harm, and a risk of harm of 1 in 10,000 is called tolerable when imposed on others.

Sources