ArbNation Join free

Tree risk assessment report structure: what the ISA TRAQ form and ASCA standards cover

ISA's Basic Tree Risk Assessment Form runs to ten sections over two pages, and it is not a report. ASCA's standards name what a consulting arborist's report must disclose.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on ISA's form instructions, ISA's TRAQ pages, the ASCA Standards of Professional Practice and a New Zealand TRAQ course outline. It is not training and does not teach the work. No template is reproduced here.

The form is not the report

The International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) instructions describe the Basic Tree Risk Assessment Form as a guide for collecting, recording and analyzing tree risk information. It is intended for a basic (Level 2) assessment. Limited visual (Level 1) and advanced (Level 3) assessments need different forms or datasheets. The form can help in developing a written report and is often attached to reports. It is not intended to serve as a report on its own, and some municipalities require it with permit applications.

ISA's instructions also say the form lacks some of the elements of a report that the Tree Risk Assessment Manual describes. The manual is given to every TRAQ course registrant. ISA says the form is used throughout the TRAQ program.

Sections of the ISA form

Basic Tree Risk Assessment Form, 2025 edition
SectionWhat it records
1 Assignment and general tree informationClient, assessor, date, address or tree location, species, tree number, trunk diameter, height, tools used and the time frame of the assessment
2 Target descriptionUp to three targets in priority order, each with a target zone and an occupancy rate of rare, occasional, frequent or constant
3 Site conditionsSite factors that affect wind load, history of failures, and site changes such as grade change, clearing or changed hydrology
4 CrownFoliage, tree health, density, wind exposure, pruning history and load concerns
5 BranchesBranch conditions, failure types, part size, fall distance and load
6 TrunkTrunk conditions and failure types
7 Root collar, roots and soilConditions of the root collar, roots and soil, and failure types
8 Risk categorization and analysisFor each part, failure type and target: likelihood of failure, likelihood of impact, consequences and the resulting risk rating
9 Matrices, notes, explanations and descriptionsThe likelihood matrix and the risk matrix, notes on anything taken into account, and sketch templates
10 Mitigation, inspection limitations, data, advanced assessment and reassessmentMitigation options with residual risk, limitations such as visibility or access, whether data is final or preliminary, advanced assessment recommended, and a reassessment interval

In section 8 the ratings come from fixed terms. Likelihood of failure is improbable, possible, probable or imminent. Likelihood of impact is very low, low, medium or high. Consequences are negligible, minor, significant or severe. The tree's final rating is the highest risk rating found on it.

Reporting in the TRAQ course

NZ Arb, which hosts the course with ISA, lists a risk reporting block. Participants learn to communicate tree risk to clients in written and verbal reports and learn the key components a report holds after an assessment. The outline does not list the components.

ASCA standards for consulting reports

The American Society of Consulting Arborists (ASCA) published its Standards of Professional Practice in July 2024, and members agree to follow them. Section 2.1 starts before the report, with the definition of each assignment. It lists the issue to be resolved, the agreed level of thoroughness, the scope of work, the type of results wanted, the scope and limitations of any report with its intended use, and the compensation.

Section 2.2, on reports and presentation, asks members to report conclusions, opinions and recommendations in a manner that is clear, unambiguous and usable. It encourages ASCA's book A Consultant's Guide to Writing Effective Reports, first published in 2004. Six items follow.

  • Limiting conditions: limits on authority, competence, scope, data, methodology or results, and on use of the report, are disclosed and explained.
  • Preliminary reports: a report meant to be preliminary, or to present preliminary investigations, is identified as such.
  • Degrees of certainty: members shall not misstate the degree of certainty of an opinion.
  • Originality: members shall not represent the work of others as their own.
  • Professional responsibility: members accept responsibility for their own work and conclusions.
  • Divergent opinions: members use professional judgment on whether to disclose a collaborator's dissenting opinion.

Section 2.1 also covers the work behind a report. Conclusions rest on adequate methodology and adequate data. Where adequate data cannot be had, members disclose the limits. Results "should generally be verifiable" by other professionals using similar methodology. Copies of written reports are kept for five years after the assignment, or two years after the end of any dispute proceeding, whichever is later, or for any longer period the law requires. Expert evidence rules for tree reports have their own guide.

Sources