ArbNation Join free

Tree risk perception: how owners, assessors and the public differ

Three sources compare how people judge tree risk: a 2019 literature review, a 2015 University of Florida survey of experts and homeowners, and a 2026 survey of 500 southeastern US homeowners.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Risk assessment methods rate a tree's likelihood of failure and the target it could hit. What people believe about that risk is a separate thing, and the sources below record it. The methods themselves are covered in tree risk assessment methods.

Reality, assessment and perception

Klein, Koeser and Hauer reviewed the literature for Arboriculture and Urban Forestry in 2019. They separate three things: the risk that exists, the arborist's assessment of it, and the property manager's or homeowner's perception. All three are interconnected, and each influences which management strategy is adopted. The review says an arborist's assessment is shaped by the reality of the situation and by perception of the threat. Perception is influenced by personal experience and personal fears, and people who share social networks tend to perceive risk alike.

The review also reports variability among assessors. Studies it cites found significant variability in the final determinations of risk assessors, and in those of arborists using common methods. It says personal biases likely account for some of it. The authors add that arborists from different nations, trained in different methods, appear to hold different underlying perceptions of tree risk.

A study of Australian arborists by Davison and Kirkpatrick, cited in the review, recorded frustration with clients who seemed to have an illogical fear of trees. In the most extreme cases the review links a gap between reality and perception to unnecessary removal or ill-advised retention. Its conclusion is that the literature on perceived risk from tree failure is limited, and that how property owners perceive and accept tree risk is still a gap.

Experts and homeowners shown the same photos

A University of Florida IFAS news release from October 6, 2015 reports a study by Andrew Koeser in Urban Forestry and Urban Greening. More than 90 people in the Tampa Bay area, tree experts and homeowners, saw photographs of trees and gave a gut-level rating of risk. The trees varied by species, condition, size and position relative to a target.

Koeser says most respondents were fixated on tree defects. Only experienced professionals considered whether the tree was actually a threat to a person, vehicle or house. He describes two risks, the real risk to nearby targets and the perceived risk. Sometimes perceived risk is close to actual risk and sometimes the two are way off. In the second case he says a structurally sound tree may be removed out of fear, or a hazardous one left unmanaged.

Homeowners and insurers, 2026

Gauldin, Gordon, Brodbeck and Calabria, from the University of Georgia and Auburn University, surveyed homeowners in the southeastern United States with a pilot tree risk perception scale (Arboriculture and Urban Forestry, July 2026). Of 500 completed surveys, 459 could be used for the scale analysis. Florida supplied 43.2 percent of respondents, Georgia 13.8 percent and North Carolina 11.2 percent.

Selected findings, 2026 homeowner survey
FindingFigure
Pruning or removal decisions influenced by the insurance carrier84.11%
Respondents who knew others who hired a tree company after insurer requests52.99%
Respondents who changed insurers over pruning or removal requests29.30%
Median scale score, local agent versus none16 versus 14.5
Median scale score, personal relationship with agent versus none17 versus 15

Higher risk perception correlated with trust and satisfaction in the insurer. It correlated negatively with average tree canopy cover in the respondent's zip code. Respondents who changed insurance companies had lower scores than the other groups, a significant difference. Those influenced by their insurer three or more times had higher scores than those influenced less, also a significant difference. Political ideology also correlated with the score: Very Liberal and Very Conservative respondents had median scores of 19 and 20, and Moderates 15. The final model explained 69.0 percent of the variation in scores. The authors say risk perception was driven mainly by institutional trust, affective concern and perceived control rather than by demographics or exposure.

Public attitudes to trees

The 2019 review cites Hull (1992), who found in a Charleston telephone survey after Hurricane Hugo that over 30 percent of respondents named part of the urban forest as one of the most important physical features destroyed. It cites Wyman and colleagues (2012), who found that 57 percent of Florida community leaders in two hurricane-prone counties agreed it was important to enlarge their urban forests. Insurance claims on trees are covered in insurance claims for tree damage.

Sources