ArbNation Join free

Tree work incidents 2001 to 2017: Ball, Vosberg and Walsh in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry (2020)

Ball, Vosberg and Walsh reviewed 865 fatal and 441 severe nonfatal US arborist incidents from 2001 to 2017. Climber falls led both lists, and falling trees, electrical contact and falling branches followed among the deaths.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

The paper is by John Ball, Shane Vosberg and Timothy Walsh, in Arboriculture and Urban Forestry volume 46, issue 2, March 2020, pages 67 to 83. Its title is A Review of United States Arboricultural Operation Fatal and Nonfatal Incidents (2001 to 2017): Implications for Safety Training.

Where the data came from

The authors drew arborist incidents from the OSHA Fatality and Catastrophe incident database and from Bureau of Labor Statistics sources, with NIOSH and state fatality investigation reports compared to remove duplicates. They reviewed 865 fatal incidents, about 51 a year, and 441 nonfatal ones. Only severe nonfatal injuries count, meaning at least one day in hospital, a work-related amputation or the loss of an eye.

BLS identified about 67 tree trimmer deaths a year between 2003 and 2016 under SOC code 37-3013, and other studies found between 56 and 80 tree worker deaths a year. The authors say their count is lower because it holds only incidents with a complete investigation summary. The CDC's 2009 report counted about 80 a year from 1992 to 2007: see the CDC count of tree care deaths.

The leading causes

The four leading fatal incidents, from most to fewest deaths, were climber falls, workers struck by a falling tree, workers making indirect contact with an electric current, and workers struck by a falling branch. Climber falls also led the severe nonfatal injuries. They were followed by ground workers struck by a falling branch, workers struck by a chain saw, and falls by aerial device operators.

Fatal and severe nonfatal incidents by event category, 2001 to 2017
Event categoryFatalNonfatal
Contact with objects and equipment359 (41.5 percent)189 (42.8 percent)
Falls, slips and trips293 (33.9 percent)206 (46.7 percent)
Exposure to harmful substances or environments144 (16.6 percent)20 (4.5 percent)
Caught in or compressed by equipment or objects73 (8.4 percent)43 (9.8 percent)
Transportation incidents53 (6.1 percent)21 (4.8 percent)

Contact with objects includes struck-by incidents, 286 fatal and 146 nonfatal, and the caught-in group. Exposure to harmful substances includes electrical contact, with 135 fatal (15.6 percent) and 18 nonfatal incidents.

Falls and fall heights

Climbers were in 173 fatal (20.0 percent) and 136 nonfatal (30.1 percent) incidents. For falls from trees where the height was recorded, the mean fatal fall was 13.6 m, with a range from 4.6 m to 30.5 m, and the mean nonfatal fall 6.4 m, from 1.5 m to 22.8 m. The authors report the difference as significant. Aerial device operators were in 93 fatal (10.7 percent) and 32 nonfatal (7.3 percent) fall incidents. The most common was falling out of the bucket, 49 fatal and nine nonfatal. A strike by a falling branch or tree jarred the boom in most of the fatal bucket falls.

Anchor failure caused 27 fatal and 29 nonfatal incidents, and a climbing line or lanyard cut by a saw or another line caused 26 fatal and 25 nonfatal ones. Ladders were a source for four fatal and 22 nonfatal incidents.

Struck-by, saws, chippers and heat

Workers struck by a falling tree or its debris during manual felling were in 145 fatal (16.8 percent) and 24 nonfatal incidents. Those struck by a falling cut branch were in 104 fatal (12.0 percent) and 56 nonfatal. The most common branch incident was a ground worker in a drop zone struck by a free-falling branch.

A chain saw was the hazard source in 13 fatal (1.5 percent) and 41 nonfatal (9.3 percent) incidents. Most injuries were lacerations to the left upper limb, hand or arm. Pulled into a chipper accounted for 34 fatal and 23 nonfatal incidents, and heat stroke for eight fatal ones, with air temperatures above 35 degrees C noted in some summaries. Collapsing palm skirts were behind 25 fatal and three nonfatal incidents.

Electrical contact

The authors call electrocution one of the most common causes of death in arboricultural operations, about 16 percent of fatalities. Of the 135 fatal electrical incidents, 106 were indirect contact through a conductive object and 29 were direct contact. Voltages and objects involved are broken out in electrical contact deaths in tree work.

Limits stated by the authors

Only incidents that were inspected are included. OSHA posts fewer inspections than the incidents it investigates, and the authors cite an estimate that about one-third of work-related deaths are posted. Only private companies appear. There are more fatal than nonfatal incidents reviewed, so the two cannot be compared directly, and the paper works in proportions, not rates, because the number of workers doing each activity is unknown. Driving on public roads falls under the Department of Transportation, so the authors say the transportation share would likely be higher if every driving incident were included. The authors tie their findings to the ANSI Z133 safety standard and conclude that safety training should stress the most common hazards.

Sources