ArbNation Join free

Trees that extension services caution against planting: Bradford pear, silver maple, Siberian elm

Clemson calls Bradford pear thorny, poorly branched and spread by birds. Florida and North Carolina call silver maple and Siberian elm weak-wooded. Ohio bans selling Callery pear and Siberian elm.

This page is for tree owners. It reports what the named sources say and is not advice about your tree: for that, ask a qualified arborist or one of the offices under Who to call.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page reports what the official source says. It is not legal advice: ask the office named here.

Bradford pear

Clemson Extension's Home and Garden Information Center writes that Bradford pears cannot reproduce with each other. They can cross with other Callery pear cultivars, though, and the cross yields viable fruit. Birds eat the fruit and spread the seeds, which grow into thorny wild pear thickets. Clemson calls the invasiveness something that "thwarts any beauty that might have been". It describes the tree's branch structure as poor and asks why it became one of the most planted trees in South Carolina subdivisions.

The Clemson page does not mention a ban. It encourages owners to remove Bradford and other Callery pears, and says the Bradford Pear Bounty, supported by Clemson Extension, offers free native replacement trees to South Carolinians who do.

Silver maple

The University of Florida IFAS fact sheet describes a vase-shaped, fast-growing and fairly weak-wooded tree 60 to 80 feet tall. It should be saved for wet areas or places where nothing else will thrive, the sheet writes. Silver maple is native to the eastern half of the United States and southeastern Canada, and IFAS rates its invasive status as native.

The sheet lists the faults. Roots often grow on the surface and are aggressive, growing into septic tank drain fields and into broken water and sewer pipes. Branches often form poor attachments with the trunk, which causes branch failure in old, mature specimens, and ice and snow loads can break branches on younger trees. The tree can lift sidewalks and sends up sprouts and many volunteer seedlings. Cultivars of silver maple also have weak wood. IFAS concludes there are too many other superior trees to warrant wide use of the species, though it has its place in tough sites away from buildings and people.

Siberian elm

The North Carolina Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, from NC State, calls Siberian elm a very adaptable, fast-growing tree that withstands drought and poor soil. It is resistant, but not immune, to Dutch elm disease. The Toolbox also rates it a poor ornamental tree, mostly because of weak branches, a messy habit and susceptibility to insects, leaf beetles above all. In some areas it is considered weedy and borderline invasive. Copious seed lets it form large colonies, and it is considered invasive in some states. The tree is native to Asia and was brought to the United States in the 1860s for hardiness and fast growth. Its native alternatives are Acer rubrum, Populus tremuloides, Quercus pagoda, Quercus rubra and Tilia americana.

Ohio Administrative Code 901:5-30-01

Ohio's rule on invasive plant species, effective February 13, 2023, has the Director of Agriculture declare listed plants invasive. The list includes Callery pear (Pyrus calleryana) and Siberian elm (Ulmus pumila). Silver maple is not on it. Paragraph (B) says no person shall sell, offer for sale, propagate, distribute, import or intentionally cause the dissemination of a listed plant in Ohio. A time-limited exception for Callery pear sits in (C), tied to January 7, 2023. Listed plants may be disposed of or controlled under (D), if the spread does not continue. Under (E), the director may seize a plant found in violation or order it removed from sale or distribution. Under (F), the director may exempt a cultivar if scientific evidence shows it is not invasive.

TreeFaults the source namesOhio rule
Bradford (Callery) pearPoor branch structure; seeds spread by birds into thicketsListed
Silver mapleWeak wood, surface roots in pipes and drain fields, sidewalk liftingNot listed
Siberian elmWeak branches, leaf beetles, large seedling coloniesListed

Who to call

Sources