ArbNation Join free

Trees in sustainable drainage: tree pits in the CIRIA SuDS Manual, Edinburgh and Wycombe guidance

A SuDS tree is planted as a working part of a drainage system. Edinburgh's factsheet says the contract maintenance period should be five years, and Wycombe's note asks for 0.6 m3 of good soil per 1 m2 of mature crown.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 19, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

What a SuDS tree is

The City of Edinburgh Council defines a SuDS tree as a tree planted as a functioning part of an engineered drainage system. Its requirements differ from conventional urban planting. Above ground it looks like a typical street tree. The difference is below ground, where the planting system collects, stores and treats rainwater runoff.

The factsheet names three ways the tree helps with surface water. The canopy intercepts and absorbs rain. Roots take up water and the leaves transpire it. Infiltration raises the volume and rate of water moving into the soil. Edinburgh says a SuDS tree can attenuate much more rainwater than a conventionally planted one.

The factsheet sorts SuDS trees into three kinds:

  • Street trees in proprietary pits or trenches, with drainage layers or piped inlets, root support, engineered soil and under-drainage.
  • Street trees and shrubs in large rain gardens, lined or unlined, with engineered soil, drainage layers and underdrains.
  • Trees in open greenspace, where land drains to damp woodland planting in a low-lying area.

It also states that not every tree needs to be a SuDS tree. Some conservation areas call for locally characteristic trees, such as small-leaved lime, that do not suit SuDS pits.

Where the CIRIA manual comes in

CIRIA publishes The SuDS Manual (C753), dated December 2015 and running to 964 pages. Authors are Woods Ballard, Wilson, Udale-Clarke, Illman, Scott, Ashley and Kellagher. CIRIA says it updates the 2007 manual (C697) and complements the Government's non-statutory technical standards for sustainable drainage. It is free to CIRIA members.

The CIRIA product page gives the title, edition and authors but no chapter list. Edinburgh's factsheet points to the manual's Part D chapter 19 on trees and to chapter 32 on operation and maintenance. Edinburgh gives page numbers for both. Wycombe District Council's note lists the manual and the Trees and Design Action Group (TDAG) guides as further reading, along with BS 8545:2014 on trees.

Soil volume in a hard surface

Wycombe District Council's guidance note on tree pit design in a hard surface was published in November 2018 and is hosted by Buckinghamshire Council. It works to 0.6 m3 of available, good quality, aerated soil per 1 m2 of crown projection at maturity. The note bases this on Lindsey and Bassuk (1991) and calls it a guideline that does not take into account the water-use strategies of different tree species or the characteristics of specific growing media. Interconnected pits or root paths to nearby uncompacted soil may reduce the volume needed in the pit itself.

Minimum soil volume for species named in the Wycombe note
TreeHeightSpreadMinimum soil volume
Whitebeam10 m6 m17 m3
Field maple12 m7 m23 m3
Small-leaved lime24 m9 m38 m3

For pits under load, such as car parking spaces, the note names two supports. Structural soils suit places where non-structural soil is also at hand and roots can reach uncompacted ground beside the paving. Pre-engineered soil cells may be needed in denser urban areas. The note adds that either method takes specialist knowledge and the maker's advice.

It also treats the surface. Sealing the ground over the roots limits gas exchange and sends rain off as runoff, which leaves the roots in drought conditions. The note asks for surfaces that pass air and water, or frequent irrigation and aeration inlets. Root barriers are for a specific need, and the note advises against lining the whole pit with one, because that blocks drainage and root growth into adjacent soil.

Design points in the Edinburgh factsheet

Edinburgh lists what engineered soil for a SuDS tree should have: root volume that bears load, a structure that survives intermittent waterlogging, overflow provision, maintainable inlets, a drainage base and aeration. Inlets range from simple weir kerbs with gaps to below-ground systems linked to road gullies. The factsheet cautions that the appropriate amount of water must drain to the pit so the tree can grow without prolonged waterlogging. Every tree system needs adequate drainage to remove excess water.

Species have to cope with swings from dry to very wet. Edinburgh's example list for very dry and wet conditions includes white swamp oak, thornless honey locust, pin oak and Freemans maple. Ginkgo is listed for free-draining soils, and field maple is a SuDS tree only in free-draining conditions. Species that produce large quantities of pollen likely to increase allergy problems are not acceptable as street trees in Edinburgh. Alder is named among the few native trees that cope with sudden wet and dry swings, and the factsheet says most of those need excluding from Edinburgh streets for their allergenic pollen.

The factsheet compares a swale tree pit with a paved one on several measures. The swale has high land-take and low capital cost. The paved pit has low land-take and high capital cost.

Maintenance periods

Edinburgh states that every SuDS feature needs a maintenance plan covering specification, frequency, timing, equipment and annual cost. SuDS features should be regularly inspected and the maintenance monitored by a competent professional, and the contract maintenance period after construction should be 5 years. Once established, a SuDS tree in paving needs about what any street tree needs, plus twice-yearly checks of vents and inlets.

Indicative maintenance for SuDS tree pits and trenches, City of Edinburgh
TaskFrequency
Water new trees in dry periods, establishment period of 2 to 5 yearsEvery 2 weeks in summer, as required
Water established trees in prolonged dry periodsAs required
Check and clear water inlets and soil aeration ventsEvery 6 months
Clear leaf debris from inlet channelsAnnually, late November
Remove grilles, if used, and clean accessible water channelsAnnually
Inspect, check and clean filter media in trough systemsBi-annually
Manage tree growthPruning as required

For trees and shrubs in rain gardens and bioretention areas, the same factsheet lists annual inlet checks and litter removal every 3 to 12 months. Soil spiking and scarifying is listed every 5 to 10 years, as sediment levels and soil type require. Edinburgh also answers one question directly: SuDS trees in engineered systems do not need replacing every 20 years if the pit is sized for the tree to reach maturity. It states that concrete sewer rings are not acceptable.

Edinburgh adds one caution about existing trees. New SuDS features should not damage established mature trees or compact soil within their root zone.

Sources