VTA in Germany and the Baumkontrolle tradition: Mattheck, Breloer and the FLL guidelines
Germany's FLL tree inspection guideline first appeared in December 2004 and was revised in 2010. It is not binding, and courts draw on it. Mattheck and Breloer's t/R ratio of 0.3 is a separate decay threshold.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The text below describes what the named codes and training bodies publish. It is not training and does not teach the work. The German word Baumkontrolle means tree inspection for traffic safety, and the duty behind it is the Verkehrssicherungspflicht. Two of the three sources here are in German: a 2019 paper by Prof. Dr. Dirk Dujesiefken of the Institut für Baumpflege Hamburg, and a 2011 leaflet from the Saxon state forest enterprise Sachsenforst. The third is a 2004 English paper from Arboriculture & Urban Forestry. For the method in English see the guide to visual tree assessment.
The FLL guideline and its editions
The FLL is the Forschungsgesellschaft Landschaftsentwicklung Landschaftsbau, based in Bonn. Dujesiefken records that a rules committee on traffic safety and tree inspection formed in May 2003 at the suggestion of the parks directors' conference, GALK. Dr Hans-Joachim Schulz chaired it. The final guideline appeared in December 2004 and was the first for this field in Germany.
- 2004: first edition. A survey two years later found 61 percent of municipalities applying it.
- 2010: second edition, with few changes and added rules for inspecting stands of trees.
- 2013: separate FLL guidelines for detailed tree examination, split from the inspection guideline.
- 2016 to 2019: revision under Prof. Dr. Andreas Roloff. A draft for comment appeared in May 2019, with the final text expected in spring 2020.
Dujesiefken adds that well over 6000 inspectors had been certified on the basis of the guideline since 2007 in Germany and Austria, with Switzerland added in 2019.
Routine inspection and detailed examination
The 2019 paper separates routine inspections, additional inspections after storms, damage or major changes around a tree, and the detailed examination that follows when doubt remains about breakage or stability. It names three factors behind inspection frequency: the justified safety expectation of traffic, the tree's condition and its development phase. Dujesiefken says this differentiated table ended the practice of inspecting every tree twice a year whatever its site, condition or age.
Sachsenforst quotes the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) judgment of January 21, 1965 (III ZR 217/63). The court said a careful external look at the tree's health and condition is enough, and a detailed expert examination is needed only when suspicious signs turn up. Sachsenforst reads this as a visual check from the ground. Climbing lifts, tapping and drilling are not needed at that stage.
Legal weight of the guideline
Sachsenforst states that the FLL guideline is not binding and does not bind the courts. It can serve as a yardstick for judging a breach of duty and is comparable to an expert opinion. The BGH has set no fixed inspection interval. Most higher courts, including the Dresden court, assume two inspections a year, while the Cologne court of July 29, 2010 (7 U 31/10) rejected rigid twice-yearly checks and relied on the FLL intervals.
The FLL table runs from once a year to every three years, and no special checks in the juvenile phase. For its own roadside stands Sachsenforst advises keeping to two checks a year, because terms such as slight damage and higher safety expectation can be rated differently. It sees the FLL intervals as better suited to small, manageable stands.
Mattheck and Breloer's decay threshold
Brian Kane and H. Dennis P. Ryan III of the University of Massachusetts tested four decay formulas in 2004. One was Mattheck and Breloer's formula of 1998, which rests on the buckling strength of a cylinder and was built by examining failed and standing decayed trees. It compares sound wood thickness t with the stem radius R. A cross-section with t/R below 0.3 counts as a hazard under the formula. The formula also treats a cavity smaller than one third of the stem circumference as having no effect on failure.
The US formulas in the same study use a 33 percent loss of stem moment of inertia (Wagener 1963 and Smiley and Fraedrich 1992) or 20 to 44 percent as a caution zone (Coder 1989). Kane and Ryan found that each formula misclassified some trees against the threshold it carries.
Sources
- Prof. Dr. D. Dujesiefken, Stand der Ueberarbeitung der neuen FLL-Baumkontrollrichtlinien (in German), Institut fuer Baumpflege Hamburg, 2019, read October 16, 2026
- Sachsenforst, Verkehrssicherungspflicht im und am Wald (in German), extract from WaldPost 2011, via Waldwissen.net, read October 16, 2026
- Kane and Ryan, The Accuracy of Formulas Used to Assess Strength Loss Due to Decay in Trees, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 30(6), November 2004, read October 16, 2026