ArbNation Join free

Water bags, drip tubes and tree watering aids: what four extension services describe

Penn State puts a slow-release watering bag at 15 gallons over 5 to 9 hours. Iowa State says most bags empty in 2 to 9 hours. Colorado State lists bag problems and says drip emitters must be moved outward as the tree grows.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 15, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

Penn State Extension, Iowa State University Extension, Colorado State University Extension and the Clemson Home and Garden Information Center each describe watering aids for newly planted trees. They describe them. None of the four reports a field trial of bag or drip output, so the figures below are extension descriptions, not trial results.

Watering bags and leaky buckets

Penn State describes a watering bag as a slow trickle of 15 gallons over 5 to 9 hours. It says the bag needs tending over the growing season and comes off over the winter. Iowa State describes tree watering bags and leaky buckets as ways to wet the root ball deeply while reducing runoff, and puts most at 2 to 9 hours to empty.

Iowa State adds limits. Bags do not replace regular soil moisture checks, and they do not cut watering frequency. They suit the original root ball, and other methods are needed once roots grow into the surrounding soil. Clemson calls tree watering bags a temporary aid for when hand watering is not possible, and adds that the bag comes off when not in use.

Colorado State lists three problems with self-watering devices, which it limits to newly planted trees:

  • The bag has to be watched to confirm it is filled.
  • Bags are often dark, and left around the trunk they can trap heat.
  • They can keep the trunk and soil overly moist, which leads to disease and insect problems.

Colorado State's conclusion is that they may be used for the short term but are not a reliable way to irrigate.

Drip, soaker hoses and tubing

Colorado State says drip irrigation is often used on newly planted trees. One mistake many homeowners make is leaving the emitters in the original spot for years: they have to move outward and more are added as the tree grows, or drought stress may follow. It gives an example of the arithmetic: two emitters at 2 gallons an hour each deliver 4 gallons an hour.

It calls soaker hoses probably most effective on smaller trees and notes they apply water so slowly that an inch can take several hours. Plastic tubing with built-in emitters, sometimes called drip tape or dripline, is more durable and ideally runs in a circle near the dripline. Penn State warns that a soaker hose may clog or water unevenly, and suggests coiling it around the plant. Colorado State rates deep root watering devices as not effective, because most roots are not deep, and prefers a hose and sprinkler.

Amounts and timing quoted with them

Watering figures as each service gives them
ServiceFigure
Penn StateAt least 1 to 1.5 gallons per inch of trunk diameter per watering. Daily for weeks 1 to 2, every 2 to 3 days for weeks 3 to 12, then weekly until first frost.
Iowa StateWater when the root ball is dry to the touch 1 or 2 inches down. Continue until the ground freezes. At least one growing season, often two, and 3 to 5 years in dry conditions.
Colorado StateIts guide to mature shade trees says to water when the top 4 to 6 inches of soil has dried. Ten gallons per inch of trunk caliper per watering is a method it calls more useful for smaller trees, so a 4 inch tree gets 40 gallons.
ClemsonKeep watering new trees and shrubs, especially in summer, until they can survive without supplemental water. No amount is given.

The services also differ on how long establishment takes. Penn State puts it at a year for each inch of trunk diameter in USDA zones 2 to 6. Colorado State gives a season for each inch of caliper. Iowa State reports recent evidence that frequent irrigation benefits new trees more than large infrequent volumes, the reverse of its advice for established trees.

Sources