Why tree workers get ISA certified, and what stops them: what the 2024 Arboriculture & Urban Forestry study found
Jason Gordon and Arnold Brodbeck interviewed 60 tree workers in Georgia, Tennessee and Alabama and surveyed 742 more. Internal motives and internal barriers outweighed external ones.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
The study is "Motivations and Barriers of Professional Certification for Tree Workers" by Jason S. Gordon and Arnold "Beau" Brodbeck. It ran in Arboriculture & Urban Forestry, volume 50, issue 4, pages 259 to 277, in the July 2024 issue. Gordon is Associate Professor of Community Forestry at the Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources, University of Georgia.
Who was asked
The authors held 60 qualitative interviews in three southern states: Georgia, Tennessee and Alabama. They also ran an online survey with 742 respondents. About 49 percent identified as commercial tree care providers, and 16 of those were based outside the United States. The paper's starting point is that many southern communities have few credentialed tree care professionals. It looks at why commercial tree workers go for ISA Certified Arborist status or stay away from it.
Why workers pursue certification
The authors sort the motives into two groups.
- External: an employer requirement or raise, access to municipal contracts, a wider list of services, and credibility with clients and partner firms.
- Internal: seeing certification as an extension of education, a sense of belonging to a profession, achievement, and continuing education as a way to keep learning.
Survey respondents named internal motives more often than external ones. Peer influence was the motive named least. Interviewees also pointed to company culture and mentorship. One interviewee said certification "overcomes a psychological barrier for clients hiring" the professional. Another is quoted as saying, "I'm part of a profession; this is bigger than just me." Another, uncertified, wanted a move into tree health care: "I can't remove and prune trees forever, it's hard work".
What holds workers back
- External: clients rarely ask about certification, some workers already have enough business, and exam and renewal costs are a concern. Some respondents disliked paying ISA.
- Internal: procrastination, lack of time, test anxiety, difficulty studying, and a belief that years of experience are enough.
In the survey, internal barriers were cited more often than external ones. Both certified and uncertified interviewees suggested few clients were aware of certification. One certified arborist put it as "Anybody can cut their tree; anybody can work on their tree."
The four worker profiles
The authors describe four profiles: Fervent Believer, Eager Beginner, Antipodean and Experienced Skeptic. They state that these profiles illustrate the range of views and are not statistically based.
What the authors recommend
- Professional associations could keep evaluating ways to ease testing barriers, particularly learning disabilities, with study aids such as smartphone apps, videos and short online sessions.
- Stepped micro-credentials, for example one in pruning, so certification is easier to reach.
- Marketing arboriculture to the public as a science-based profession, so clients can tell certified arborists apart.
- Peer networking and professional organisation involvement, especially for uncertified workers.
- Employer mentorship programmes that support certification and continuing education.
Related reading: ISA Certified Arborist exam domains and exam accommodations for ISA credential exams.
Sources
- Gordon, J. S. and Brodbeck, A., Motivations and Barriers of Professional Certification for Tree Workers, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 50(4), 259-277, July 2024, read October 21, 2026
- International Society of Arboriculture, July 2024 issue of Arboriculture & Urban Forestry now online, posted July 1, 2024, read October 21, 2026
- University of Georgia Warnell School of Forestry and Natural Resources, Jason Gordon, faculty listing, read October 21, 2026