ArbNation Join free

Wind-damaged trees: how extension and forest services assess hurricane and gale damage

The University of Florida and the North Carolina Forest Service list the signs they weigh after a hurricane or gale: cracked trunks, broken roots, split stems, large broken limbs and how much crown is gone.

Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 16, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.

This page draws on what the named extension and forest services publish. It is not training and does not teach the work. It is not a diagnosis of any tree and does not say what should be done with one.

Eight factors in the Florida publication

The University of Florida IFAS publication FR172 weighs eight interrelated factors when a hurricane-damaged tree is judged for removal or restoration. They are the amount of damage, tree size and age, species, health, structure, past pruning, site conditions and cultural value.

On damage, FR172 says conifers such as pines with 30 to 50 percent of the canopy damaged, and broadleaf trees such as live oak with 50 to 70 percent, might be beyond recovery. On species, it separates good compartmentalizers, trees that wall off decay, from poor ones. It names live oak, mahogany, false tamarind, winged elm and buttonwood as good, and laurel oak, water oak, redbay, African tuliptree and Hong Kong orchid as poor.

It treats decay as a major cause of failure. Cracks, seams, abnormal swelling, cankers, dead branch stubs and large old wounds suggest internal decay, which is often present with no outward sign. Topping and large pruning cuts, compacted or shallow soil, a high water table and roots cut by construction all lower stability in its account.

Signs FR172 lists for removal and for restoration

Removal signsRestoration signs
Lower main trunk cracked or brokenTree under 10 inches in diameter
Large stem split from the treeLeaves lost, tree otherwise healthy
Leaning toward a targetSmall broken or dead branches under 4 inches
Remaining structure prone to breakageDecay-resistant species with most of the canopy damaged
Major roots severed or brokenSome major limbs broken in a decay-resistant species
Large limbs broken, over 8 inches acrossLeaning or fallen trees under 4 inches across, or newly planted
Stem girdling roots with dead spots and cracksMajor limbs, trunk and roots intact, with no cracks, decay or bark inclusions

FR172 adds that trees losing their leaves in a hurricane usually are not dead, and many grow new foliage in the weeks after. For live oak and gumbo limbo, it says defoliation is usually a survival strategy that cuts wind resistance. Some species, such as pines, may not regrow foliage.

The North Carolina method

The North Carolina Forest Service best management practice is written for municipal staff and professionals. It splits a storm assessment into situational and safety awareness, hazard remediation and crown loss. Trained staff can do the first two. A qualified professional does the third, and it can wait for a return visit in a severe event. Inspection runs from the bottom of the tree to the top.

Its root check names a lean, soil mounded on the side away from the lean, and root zone lifting. Its trunk check names horizontal or buckling cracks and vertical cracks, and it probes cracks for depth and decay. It describes lightning damage as frayed bark with a crack that can run to the top of the tree. It also suggests FEMA damage codes for documentation.

CodeCondition
F1Hazardous limbs over 2 inches at the break, hanging or lodged in the tree
F2Fallen or uprooted tree
F3Lean of 30 degrees or more
F4Exposed heartwood
F550 percent or more of the crown damaged or destroyed

The guide marks these codes as subject to change.

A measured storm

A USDA Forest Service paper in Forests (2021) estimates the damage from the derecho that crossed Iowa on August 10 and 11, 2020. It puts 2.67 million trees and 1.67 million cubic metres of sound bole volume as damaged or killed on 23 thousand hectares of forest land. Damage rates were slightly higher for volume than for number of trees. The abstract calls stem breakage more prevalent than branch breakage, while the discussion puts stem breakage on live trees about four percent lower than branch breakage. With no post-storm field measurements in the damage zone, the authors could only estimate the totals.

Sources