Natural gas leaks and soil contamination: what extension services describe
Natural gas from a leaking main kills tree roots by using up the oxygen in the soil, not by poisoning them. The sources describe the crown symptoms, the soil signs and the problems that look alike.
Checked against the sources at the bottom of this page on October 21, 2026. Rules, fees and pay change: the source has the last word.
Three sources describe gas in the root zone. The University of California Statewide IPM Program covers gas injury from several sources, including natural gas lines, sewers and landfills. Spencer H. Davis Jr. of Rutgers wrote a 1977 article for Arboriculture & Urban Forestry. A 2012 Penn State final report to the US pipeline safety regulator (PHMSA) reviews the literature and records field surveys.
How the damage happens
The Penn State report states that modern natural gas is mainly methane, which by itself is relatively harmless to vegetation. Soil bacteria that feed on methane multiply near a leak. They use up soil oxygen and release carbon dioxide. The report puts the cause of root death on the lack of oxygen, mainly from methane oxidation by those bacteria. Pressurized gas may also push oxygen out of the soil.
Davis traces the same finding to J. Hoeks, who published soil-air measurements near leaking mains in the Netherlands in 1972. In normal soil the oxygen was about 18 percent and carbon dioxide 3 percent. After gas release, oxygen fell almost to zero and carbon dioxide rose to as much as 15 percent. Hoeks named the very low oxygen as the most important cause of tree death.
Davis also reports earlier soil tests from 1962. Soil near trees that had just died held more methane, up to 10 percent carbon dioxide and under 5 percent oxygen. The root zone of healthy trees held no methane, 3 to 4 percent carbon dioxide and 20 percent oxygen.
Symptoms on the tree and in the soil
UC IPM lists slow growth, then foliage that wilts and turns brown, crispy and dry. Roots may discolor and look black, bluish or water-soaked. Plants may only partly leaf out in spring, limbs may die back, and plants can be killed. UC IPM adds that soil above an underground source may be discolored bluish or gray.
The pattern on the ground carries information too. UC IPM points to damage found only on plants near vents or over a gas or sewer line. The Penn State report summarises an older utility survey paper. It says the damage is directly related to the size of the leak. Damage above a deeply buried pipe usually runs from heavy at the center to lighter at the edge. Gas leaking from a pipe at or above the soil surface gives a variable pattern, because wind moves the gas and it does not reach the roots.
Soil shapes the pattern. The report says sandy soils let gas spread freely, so damage tends to be circular. Dense clay resists the gas, which follows cracks, so damage is worst directly above the cracks. Wet upper soil in spring can also hold gas down. The backfilled pipe trench is loose and porous, so gas spreads fast along it and the damage is linear rather than round.
Smell and testing
UC IPM says the odor of natural gas (methane), ammonia or hydrogen sulfide may be detectable in air and soil near injured plants. For a suspected landfill source it lists site history, air tests with special gas monitoring instruments, and laboratory analysis of air samples.
Davis reports an older field method. Where manufactured gas had leaked, a potted tomato plant placed in a hole in the suspect area showed severe leaf curling (epinasty) within 24 hours, from the ethylene in that gas. Davis adds that natural gas itself was known to be apparently non-toxic to plants, yet trees near leaks still died. A consultant quoted in his article said vegetation had been used to locate gas leaks for more than 25 years by 1958. In many instances the effects were more striking with natural gas than with manufactured gas, one reason being the higher distribution pressures.
Look-alike problems
UC IPM says gas exposure may resemble herbicide or other chemical injury, root-disease pathogens, thermal injury and acute water stress. It also says gas injury causes an aeration deficit and its symptoms. Waterlogged soil is covered in flooding and tree roots. The Penn State report quotes a 1958 paper that symptoms from escaping gas are easily confused with salt injury, drought, compacted soil, wilt diseases, root rots, insect problems, twig blights and cankers. The report says these cautions still hold.
The Penn State field work shows the problem in practice. An aerial survey of about 540 miles of Pennsylvania pipelines in July 2011 could not separate gas damage from other browning. A July drought had browned vegetation along the routes. Pipeline trenching and right-of-way work had exposed bare soil and bulldozed trees and brush. The report then moved its emphasis to urban and suburban trees as indicators, checked against gas readings taken at ground level.
Who deals with the leak
UC IPM names the utility company as the contact for a suspected natural gas leak. For a broken sewer line it says the local water agency, property owner or the party that caused the damage is responsible for repair, depending on the situation. For landfill gas it lists investigation of the site's prior land use. See also buried gas, power and fibre lines on stump jobs.
Sources
- University of California Statewide IPM Program, Gas Injury (Home and Landscape), read October 21, 2026
- Spencer H. Davis Jr., The Effect of Natural Gas on Trees and Other Vegetation, Arboriculture & Urban Forestry 3(8):153-154, August 1977, read October 21, 2026
- Penn State Institute for Energy and the Environment for US DOT PHMSA, Forest Vegetation as a Bioindicator to Detect Leaking Natural Gas Pipelines, final report, October 2012, read October 21, 2026